It seems like every time I go by there they are closed and every time I call no one answers and I get a “voicemail box is full” message. I’d like to try their pizza since I live nearby, but it just seems like such a hassle. I’m not sure the hours on google reflect their actual restaurant hours.
Joseph Marckini
Great tasting pizza made the way its supposed to be, a lot of topping, realcheese, excellent sauce and cooked well done the way pizza is supposed to be!!!
Russell Hoye
They have very good tasting ingredients but it seems like every time I go there there is less and less on subs and evidently they don't do substitutions or additions every time I ask for something extra on as well it seems like I never get it
Melissa Hosteter
Doesn't even come with cheese on the whole pizza, and look at the tiny little mushrooms! Pathetic! I would have paid a couple bucks more for toppings everywhere. Never eating here again.
Kiran L.
We usually really enjoy their pizza but our most recent order was a little disappointing. The topping ratios seemed to be off. While there was plenty of pineapple, onions, and jalapeños, but there were very few pieces of sausage. In my opinion 1-2 pieces of meat per slice of pizza is not enough.
E R
Told me 35 minutes, waited 1 hour got the food and everything was cold. Would not recommend4/22/22. My first and last time eating here
Drew Garner
Horrible experience. I called to place an order for pick up and the person on the phone was making different voices I am assuming to be funny? and being rude. I ordered mozzarella sticks, fried mushrooms, and pizza. I was not acknowledged when I walked in. I got 4 overcooked/dry mozzarella sticks for $7 and was given a hassle because I asked for marinara sauce. The pizza was great but the mushrooms were not cooked all way. The breading was still dough. Love the pizza here but the service and other food was TERRIBLE. Not worth it.
Katy C.
We've been trying out some local Sparta restaurants as we visit our friends who just moved to the area. Papa Piccione's was our pick this time as Wing World was closed for the night. We tried a couple times to order online but it wasn't working, so we ended up calling. We got a supreme pizza, an order of boneless wings, and cheese breadsticks. It was ready in about 30 minutes and everything was hot and fresh at pickup. The pizza was great! I loved the thinner crust that still held up to the ample toppings. I tend to judge a local pizza spot by their supreme pizza, and more specifically the sausage. Theirs seemed very fresh and it was very tasty. The sauce wasn't super sweet! (I don't like really sweet pizza sauce.) The breadsticks were maybe a little overdone but they had plenty of cheese. The boneless wings were a little sad looking, but I still liked them. The chicken itself wasn't dry but they could've used a bit more buffalo sauce tossed with them. We'll save this spot as we discover more of what Sparta has to offer.
Doug V.
Papa P's wins the battle of the pizza shops in Sparta (there is no shortage of pizza options). Reasonably priced, excellent sauce, good crust and lots of high quality toppings. The staff is very friendly.
Lilyan Hall
DO NOT GO TO THIS LOCATION!!!!!!!! Absolutely terrible and disgusting. They need to retrain their employees. I will never be going here again, and will be making sure everyone that I know is aware to not go here. I spoke to the manager on duty and he was extremely disrespectful. My food tasted spoiled, and I will be contacting the health department.
We have ordered there several times and at first they were good. However they absolutely don't know what they are doing. The last two times food has been awful and the teenagers working have no idea what they are doing!
Margo Woroniecki
I ordered a large pizza they made it really good. It looked good and tasted even better. I will be going back.
melissa Price
First time visiting! Picked up 3 pizzas and an order of cheese bread tonight. Great food, great staff! We will be ordering again.
Peggy Rademacher
This is not for the Sparta but for the Kent City one. We always enjoyed their pizza but after what happened to me tonight, I am done doing business with them. I had my daughter order our family pizza tonight for delivery. They mentioned her name and she said yes but the delivery address wasn't verified and she assumed they were sending to our residence. I paid for the pizza with my card and they delivered it to the wrong address. I guess she had previously ordered for at a f
Wind Haven
They always get the order wrong the food is almost always burnt and the service is terrible. If getting delivery I’ve actually been given an order they tipped upside down and everything had spilled out and mashed together!! Here’s a pic of the BBQ WINGS. HMM NO BBQ. Beware.
It seems like every time I go by there they are closed and every time I call no one answers and I get a “voicemail box is full” message. I’d like to try their pizza since I live nearby, but it just seems like such a hassle. I’m not sure the hours on google reflect their actual restaurant hours.
Great tasting pizza made the way its supposed to be, a lot of topping, realcheese, excellent sauce and cooked well done the way pizza is supposed to be!!!
They have very good tasting ingredients but it seems like every time I go there there is less and less on subs and evidently they don't do substitutions or additions every time I ask for something extra on as well it seems like I never get it
Doesn't even come with cheese on the whole pizza, and look at the tiny little mushrooms! Pathetic! I would have paid a couple bucks more for toppings everywhere. Never eating here again.
We usually really enjoy their pizza but our most recent order was a little disappointing. The topping ratios seemed to be off. While there was plenty of pineapple, onions, and jalapeños, but there were very few pieces of sausage. In my opinion 1-2 pieces of meat per slice of pizza is not enough.
Told me 35 minutes, waited 1 hour got the food and everything was cold. Would not recommend4/22/22. My first and last time eating here
Horrible experience. I called to place an order for pick up and the person on the phone was making different voices I am assuming to be funny? and being rude. I ordered mozzarella sticks, fried mushrooms, and pizza. I was not acknowledged when I walked in. I got 4 overcooked/dry mozzarella sticks for $7 and was given a hassle because I asked for marinara sauce. The pizza was great but the mushrooms were not cooked all way. The breading was still dough. Love the pizza here but the service and other food was TERRIBLE. Not worth it.
We've been trying out some local Sparta restaurants as we visit our friends who just moved to the area. Papa Piccione's was our pick this time as Wing World was closed for the night. We tried a couple times to order online but it wasn't working, so we ended up calling. We got a supreme pizza, an order of boneless wings, and cheese breadsticks. It was ready in about 30 minutes and everything was hot and fresh at pickup. The pizza was great! I loved the thinner crust that still held up to the ample toppings. I tend to judge a local pizza spot by their supreme pizza, and more specifically the sausage. Theirs seemed very fresh and it was very tasty. The sauce wasn't super sweet! (I don't like really sweet pizza sauce.) The breadsticks were maybe a little overdone but they had plenty of cheese. The boneless wings were a little sad looking, but I still liked them. The chicken itself wasn't dry but they could've used a bit more buffalo sauce tossed with them. We'll save this spot as we discover more of what Sparta has to offer.
Papa P's wins the battle of the pizza shops in Sparta (there is no shortage of pizza options). Reasonably priced, excellent sauce, good crust and lots of high quality toppings. The staff is very friendly.
DO NOT GO TO THIS LOCATION!!!!!!!! Absolutely terrible and disgusting. They need to retrain their employees. I will never be going here again, and will be making sure everyone that I know is aware to not go here. I spoke to the manager on duty and he was extremely disrespectful. My food tasted spoiled, and I will be contacting the health department.
Restaurantji Recommends
We have ordered there several times and at first they were good. However they absolutely don't know what they are doing. The last two times food has been awful and the teenagers working have no idea what they are doing!
I ordered a large pizza they made it really good. It looked good and tasted even better. I will be going back.
First time visiting! Picked up 3 pizzas and an order of cheese bread tonight. Great food, great staff! We will be ordering again.
This is not for the Sparta but for the Kent City one. We always enjoyed their pizza but after what happened to me tonight, I am done doing business with them. I had my daughter order our family pizza tonight for delivery. They mentioned her name and she said yes but the delivery address wasn't verified and she assumed they were sending to our residence. I paid for the pizza with my card and they delivered it to the wrong address. I guess she had previously ordered for at a f
They always get the order wrong the food is almost always burnt and the service is terrible. If getting delivery I’ve actually been given an order they tipped upside down and everything had spilled out and mashed together!! Here’s a pic of the BBQ WINGS. HMM NO BBQ. Beware.