Nicky D’s Coney Island

Food is great but throw the staff in the trash, especially the girl with that red tattoo on her neck. Up there looking sloppy in leggings and has a nasty, rude attitude to paying customers. She’s single handedly the reason why a lot of people I know including myself won’t be spending anymore money there.

The grilled vegetarian sandwich is one of my fast food favorites! The best I've had at any local coney - and not all the Nicky D's even have it on their menu. Tried to get the RO location to make me one, they couldn't do it! Plus points for drive-thru convenience. It's a solid coney island, in my experience.

I asked for extra tatar sauce on my fish sandwich I didnt say the whole bottle!! What a mess never again

Haven't had much food here but what I have had has been pretty good Best thing here is all that snow bunny cake

Took 40 min to make chicken tenders and closed phone on my face when I called to ask why worst customer service ever!

Love this place, portions a great, food is good. Much better than the Wendy's that use to be here

I crave their grilled marinated chicken Greek salad. The pink dressing is the best salad dressing I've ever had. The salad is massive, and full of more toppings than lettuce, which I love!

They have really good chili cheese fries and their corned beef egg rolls are a must.

I've never dined in but it looks really cute on the inside.

I am disappointed with the food that. I ordered. The grilled chicken. Salad that l purchased had a piece of hair struck on it. The pita was rough and the lettuce had brown spots on it.

Food over cooked and burnt wouldn't give me a need order...

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 5

My first time ever going1:25 am Friday. I got the Greek salad had ok reviews. NEVER again! I ordered the small to go for what they charged was pathetically tiny and mediocre taste to say the least. As soon as I open it out fell so over me literally no room to put dressing or anything and wasn't any chicken! Compared to other places I pay the same for way better and about double or more the salad! I'll stick with my guys at z.i.n.o.s. as for this place I'll never return! Very bad first impression.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 1

They need to get it together if they are going to charge these prices. Everytime I order something is messed up. Ordered Joey d pita and the outside of the pita was wet with the Buffalo sauce and the chicken had none on it at all. I'm guessing they poured it on the veg and it seeped out b4 adding the chicken or something. If you can put some Buffalo sauce on the chicken b4 adding the chicken to the pita it should prevent this. C'mon nobody wants to hold a wet pita.

This is the only Coney I have been to in a long time that actually knows how to cook a grilled cheese. The main things are the plain things and they can get them right. The cheese was completely melted all the way and it was a crisp golden color. Service was great and the place was busy!! All great signs. I wish you all the best!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Its sad when theres so much money being spent at this establishment but the owners are so cheap that they cant afford to have a real soap dispenser lmao. Shows how much they care about washing your hands.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

I jus t ordered two omelettes from there and the hash browns were raw on both orders and the hash browns in the omelette was raw also this is unacceptable I spent $100 for 4 items who’s is also outrageous if you want good breakfast i strongly advise you go some place else

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Don’t use your debit cards at this location they will add a tip on your card I would never tip $12 at a fast food restaurant