Big John's Pizza
TEMPORARILY CLOSED$ •
3263 E Colby St suite J, Whitehall
(231) 894-4129
About Big John's Pizza
Big John's Pizza Reviews
Not one to leave a negative review I always try and find the good in everything! Tonight at 6:30 we decided to order online. Our pickup time was for 7:50 as we showed up on time. The place appeared to be pretty busy but I as a small business owner understand being under staffed. We did not get our pizza as it hadn’t even been started yet. We did drive over a half hr to try the pizza (ive had it but the family has not). However, that’s not what’s important. What was...read full review
Ordered today August 19, 2025. Pizza tasted and looks like the cheap pizzas at the grocery store. Hardly any cheese and could not find the ham either. Tater tots a very small portion for the money, but tasted fine ( hard to mess up on tater tots). The garlic bread with cheese had no garlic flavor but a lot of cheese on plain store bought bread. Very disappointing and expensive.
One of the best pizzas I’ve ever had! Been going here for over 30 years and still my favorite.
Ratings
Menu
People in Whitehall Also Viewed
Big John's Pizza is a local favorite, serving delicious pizzas along with a variety of meals. Their pizzas feature a thin crust, offering a perfect balance of flavors. The Supreme pizza remains a popular choice, and the all meat add pineapple and BBQ Chicken pizza are so good. The restaurant is very clean inside and the staff are very friendly and professional. With carry-out options available, the estimated time is accurate. Big John's Pizza is a must-try destination for pizza enthusiasts. The restaurant is moving to the Plumb's plaza in Whitehall and will reopen in October, continuing to serve the best pizza around, along with favorites like the Chicken Parmesan sandwich with fries and garlic bread with cheese. The owner handles situations well and the service is 10/10.