Customers` Favorites
Customers` Favorites
“Where do I even start? Every time I go here or order takeout it’s worth it. You can taste the love and the genuine care that’s put into these recipes. I ordered the Reuben pizza tonight as a carry out, I traveled 45 minutes out of my way from Petoskey plus a 30 minute drive home to Gaylord. I got to share this pizza with 2 people that have never had it and they loved it as much as I do. If you’re not familiar with this gem of a restaurant you should be. This place needs to be a destination whenever you’re traveling through northern Michigan! The thirsty Sturgeon will always hold a soft place in my heart and a soft place in the hearts of those I get to share the experience with! Kudos to you Thirsty Sturgeon, keep doing what you’re doing and the rest will fall in place!“
Customers` Favorites
“There is no welcoming atmosphere. It's a bar. They don't care if you're there or not. That said, or server was sufficient, friendly enough, but not looking to make friends. It wasn't busy, but our food still took a very long time. I'm sure it was hand-crafted in the kitchen, so I wasn't too salty about that. We shared a 1lb burrito; it was good. We are used to our fellow northern Michiganders to be somewhat more friendly than the next guy, so I was a bit disappointed with that, but I did not take it personally. If Mill Street Pizza is closed, this is definitely a decent option, but not if you're in a rush.“
Customers` Favorites
“Arrived after the kitchen closed, so can’t comment on the food. The music (genre) was good and at a very comfortable volume. The place was busy, happy, hoppin’, and welcoming. Rumor is they have “great burgers and killer pizza”. Next time we’re in town we’ll try to get there earlier to check that out.“
Customers` Favorites
“we had a great pizza and very friendly service. Thumbs up to the staff.“
Customers` Favorites
“{{restaurant.reviews}}“
Loading...
“The new owners are all amazing! The place is beautiful & food is great. This is the kind of place you go in a stranger & come out as Family.“