Andys Hometowne Pizza

While you can dine in, I strongly recommend against it. They were crazy busy with deliveries, so somebody obviously likes their pizzas. I'd suggest walling off the kitchen from the cash registers - not everything said in the kitchen should be consumed by dine-in or carry-out guests. The salad we ordered was forgotten. We were served but no silverware, plate ware or paper products despite the staff knowing we were dine in. Waited 52 minutes for a large pizza and spaghetti. Garlic bread was good, sauces bland and unremarkable. Food overall was solid, but nothing great. Probably a small step above Domino's.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Ultimate Meat Lovers Pizza

Really delicious pizza at a reasonable price, and the staff are friendly too!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

very nice and even gave me a free dr.pepper!

Service: 5

I love the pizza, but the delivery is ALWAYS late.

Food: 5

Service: 1

Food was good. Don't recommend dining in. No soda fountain or table service. Only 4 tables. Appetizer name was misleading. Ordered pizza fries and got a cheese calzone. German pizza was ok. I would expect a specialty pizza to be at least three toppings not only 2. Great small business but it has a long ways to go.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 5

90 minutes for 2 lukewarm medium pizzas to be delivered. Why can’t the place call and explain there is a delay and why. Tipped the driver $7.00. Not his fault. I’m done with this place.

I really like their pizza. The only reason I’m not giving 5 stars is because they’re consistently late these days. By about 20-30 minutes every time.

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Andy's Monstrosity - The Largest Pizza Around

Super good! Walked over for lunch from the hotel nearby. I had the chicken Piada (pea-ya'-dah); a baked sandwich folded like a calzone - YUMMY!
Plain and simple dining room. It seems their business is mainly carryout and delivery, but the place is very clean. I fully enjoyed my food and having the whole place to myself. ☺️ ... won't be around to try the Monstrosity Challenge though it sounds fun.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great pizza highly recommend

Was there for Randy Santel, Ethan Teske
had a Ex large pepperoni specialty pizza very good, excellent crust
would definitely be ordering from them if I lived nearby

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Take piadas off your menu!!! Terrible!!! Order a salad and some garlic bread without meat... thats it but worse. Normally like the pizza but this was aweful!

Food: 1

Service: 3

Vegetarian options: Veggie Lover's + Green Olives is awesome, Mac N Cheese pizza is great too!

Food: 5

Recommended dishes: Andy's Fully Loaded, Wings

I ordered a 2 topping large pizza bacon and pineapple extra sauce... first time here and grabbed a pizza while visiting family... we were all impressed with how amazing the pizza was from the thin crust to the toppings and the sauce... I love finding local restaurants especially pizza to expand my options... friendly staff and it was ready super fast... I will be going back for sure, hopefully in the next week... will be frequenting this place when I am up in the area... local pizza is always so much better than chains... price is reasonable... inwish they had a 2 pizza deal though... otherwise, I am really impressed... ty staff for the great service and pizza... TY for your hard work and dedication to making an amazing ?!!!

Parking: Lots of parking in the lot

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: BBQ Wings, Ultimate Meat Lovers Pizza, Andy's Monstrosity - The Largest Pizza Around, 3 Topper Deal, Andy's Fully Loaded, Steak, Cherry Streasil Peza, Ultimate Meat Lovers, Ham & Cheese Piada, Steak Piada, blt Piada, Wings, Sauce, Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza

This pizza would probably be good if it wasn't ordered on a Friday at 5pm. Our pizza definitely didnt look like the recent posted google pizza photos. The crust was wafer thin despite not ordering thin crust. There were many air pockets between the bottom and the cheese. Only the middle of the pizza actually had cheese on it; the rest was just dried up sauce on almost every border piece. Some of the pieces were partly flipped over in the box when we got it home too. This was our first time eating it and it might be our last.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 4

Pizza is really good. But phone line doesn't always work.

Food: 5

Service: 1