Fun, small, quiet boutique style place. We didn't try the wine but got a flatbread and it was so good. We also got the grilled cheese for the kids and they were so polite and cut it up on two different plates for us so each kid has their meal separate which we found so thoughtful. Cookie Cheesecake was also fabulous!Kid-friendliness: It's not a rowdy place so was welcoming for the kids.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheesecake of the Week, Cheese Flatbread Pizza, Cheese Grilled Cheese
J E
Fun little place to sit and have a break or food, nice staff and good food and wine!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jenny Hansen
Very cute quaint place. Wine is delicious. The food is more unique than your standard Applebees which is nice. They have apps there. Be sure to ask about the history of this place; that is what also adds character.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chad Rudnik
The owner Christy is an awesome person, great selection of wines, and awesome handmade cocktails in Muffys Basement!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
staci b.
The husband planned a date night here. I'll be honest when we arrived I was like, hmm not sure about this place. It is small and quaint, like having dinner at an older relative's house. We were immediately greeted and asked to pick a two top table of our choice. The attention from waitstaff was on point throughout our meal as should be expected with the size. The wine flights are adorable as they served them in miniature wine glasses. We ordered the house salad and two different flatbreads, the September special & the apple one. The salads were average, nothing wow or horrible. The flatbreads were very tasty, they are made on a cracker like base which paired well with the toppings. By far a top flatbread contender for us. Before leaving we tried the speakeasy in the basement, talk about charm and fantastic drinks. Our bartender was engaging and made the best cocktails, do yourself a favor and make sure you visit the speakeasy!!
Dave Harrison
Very nice experience. Staff very friendly and knowledgeable. Will definitely return!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
David H.
A lovely place to have a delicious lunch while you take a break from the eclectic shopping opportunities in Buffalo. The staff is friendly and attentive. We split a delicious Mediterranean salad, flat bread pizza, and enjoyed a couple glasses of the house red. All were full of flavor and our food was packed with ingredients. The colorful flower vases, triptych mural, and vintage mosaic floor add to the ambiance. Thinking we might have to end our shopping day with a stop by Muffy's Speakeasy!
What a cool, funky little wine bar. We tried Evelyn's on a whim last weekend for date night and had the nicest time. Wine flights and a focused food menu were perfect! Ended the night downstairs at Maggie's playing Scrabble. Awesome!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Crab Dip
CuriousTraveler5050
So excited to find this place. Well rounded yet simple wine list from around the world. Great food menu. I had the lobster crab dip and paired with a Portuguese Vinho Verde. A quite place, feels like an Italian cafe. Will definitely be back.
Natasha C.
A great GF flatbread, great service upstairs in the restaurant and downstairs in the speakeasy and a cute place!
Ted Nash
Evelyn’s Wine Bar is a nice, cozy place and recommend.We typically order the charcuterie board, a couple flat breads, beer from Haye’s Pub house and my wife enjoyed their Buffalo Rock Spritzer.Can’t wait to come back.
andrew lindberg
This place shines when it comes to a calm atmosphere to share a night out with my wife. The staff is very welcoming and responsive. They have great food across the board, but from the lobster crab dip and the bruschetta to the wealth of other great appetizers and desserts, my wife and I tend to enjoy the great selection of wines and fill our table with appetizers to munch on.
I brink and drive
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Price is steep for what you get for food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Charcuterie Board
Way too
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Fun, small, quiet boutique style place. We didn't try the wine but got a flatbread and it was so good. We also got the grilled cheese for the kids and they were so polite and cut it up on two different plates for us so each kid has their meal separate which we found so thoughtful. Cookie Cheesecake was also fabulous!Kid-friendliness: It's not a rowdy place so was welcoming for the kids.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheesecake of the Week, Cheese Flatbread Pizza, Cheese Grilled Cheese
Fun little place to sit and have a break or food, nice staff and good food and wine!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very cute quaint place. Wine is delicious. The food is more unique than your standard Applebees which is nice. They have apps there. Be sure to ask about the history of this place; that is what also adds character.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The owner Christy is an awesome person, great selection of wines, and awesome handmade cocktails in Muffys Basement!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The husband planned a date night here. I'll be honest when we arrived I was like, hmm not sure about this place. It is small and quaint, like having dinner at an older relative's house. We were immediately greeted and asked to pick a two top table of our choice. The attention from waitstaff was on point throughout our meal as should be expected with the size. The wine flights are adorable as they served them in miniature wine glasses. We ordered the house salad and two different flatbreads, the September special & the apple one. The salads were average, nothing wow or horrible. The flatbreads were very tasty, they are made on a cracker like base which paired well with the toppings. By far a top flatbread contender for us. Before leaving we tried the speakeasy in the basement, talk about charm and fantastic drinks. Our bartender was engaging and made the best cocktails, do yourself a favor and make sure you visit the speakeasy!!
Very nice experience. Staff very friendly and knowledgeable. Will definitely return!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A lovely place to have a delicious lunch while you take a break from the eclectic shopping opportunities in Buffalo. The staff is friendly and attentive. We split a delicious Mediterranean salad, flat bread pizza, and enjoyed a couple glasses of the house red. All were full of flavor and our food was packed with ingredients. The colorful flower vases, triptych mural, and vintage mosaic floor add to the ambiance. Thinking we might have to end our shopping day with a stop by Muffy's Speakeasy!
Restaurantji Recommends
What a cool, funky little wine bar. We tried Evelyn's on a whim last weekend for date night and had the nicest time. Wine flights and a focused food menu were perfect! Ended the night downstairs at Maggie's playing Scrabble. Awesome!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Crab Dip
So excited to find this place. Well rounded yet simple wine list from around the world. Great food menu. I had the lobster crab dip and paired with a Portuguese Vinho Verde. A quite place, feels like an Italian cafe. Will definitely be back.
A great GF flatbread, great service upstairs in the restaurant and downstairs in the speakeasy and a cute place!
Evelyn’s Wine Bar is a nice, cozy place and recommend.We typically order the charcuterie board, a couple flat breads, beer from Haye’s Pub house and my wife enjoyed their Buffalo Rock Spritzer.Can’t wait to come back.
This place shines when it comes to a calm atmosphere to share a night out with my wife. The staff is very welcoming and responsive. They have great food across the board, but from the lobster crab dip and the bruschetta to the wealth of other great appetizers and desserts, my wife and I tend to enjoy the great selection of wines and fill our table with appetizers to munch on.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Crab Dip, Sweet Wine Flight