Godfather's Pizza Express

15402 Hornsby St NE, Columbus
(651) 846-1010

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Christina Dukek

Very nice staff and great tasting pizza. Sausage is my absolute favorite. They're sausage is different from other places. I only get sausage pizzas from here. I never order sausage anywhere else because it tastes funny and has weird looking fat pieces in it, not here.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brian Alto

Brings me back to my younger days. Great pizza!

AM CISO

Not the welcoming Godfathers Pizza we used to have in this country. This is a gas station with a godfather's sign and cold white/blue lighting, probably profit-focused and less about tasty pizza.

The pizza somewhat resembles Godfather's pizza, but its also very much like general gas station pizza. The flavor personality just isn't there.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 4

Lindy

We ordered 8 Pizza's, and 3 Family Size Wings. We only received 5 Pizza's and 1 Family Size Wing. I called asking where the missing pizza's and wings were, and he responded he only had 5 and 1 on his end. He said he will make the three missing pizza's and 2 family size wings. They get here and the 3 pizza's are wrong and no wings. We order lunch for staff every Saturday. Wont be going here again.

Braxton

Terrible service I ordered 2 pizza rolls said it would take 15 minutes I was waiting for 1 hour

Terrence Rheault

Delicious food, lazy employees.

Godfather's own website states that this location closes at 9:30, but the cashier refused to make an order of cheesesticks an hour before they closed.

Their pizza is fantastic but plan on arriving hours before they close if you want to order something other than what they made ahead of time and have sitting out.

William Farrell

I’ve worked in foodservice for eight years and never had it been difficult, EVER, to properly cut a half-and-half pizza. We came in this Sunday and ordered a half pepperoni, half veggie pizza, you can clearly see the toppings beneath the cheese, so how do you POSSIBLY cut in such a way that you get both sides of the pizza on the same slice. On top of that it tasted like cheesed cardboard, completely lacking any sort of seasoning or originality at all: for thirty dollars I expect quality, not domino’s-level garbage.

Nick Sobek

I stopped in here out of curiosity because I never noticed this place before. The pizza had no flavor and tasted like cardboard. The edges were burnt too. Am I going to get whacked now?

Mark Johnson

I used to love Godfathers pizza but hadn't had it in years. Loves has the cheapest gas prices, so I decided to stop for gas and pizza. The service was adequate, and so was the pizza. Could have used more cheese. There is nothing to rave about and nothing to complain about either.Lots of "seedy" characters just wandering around. That was wierd.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 2

Amy Organ

We go pretty often since its near by and we love it. Always always get a great pizza!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

dawn locker

Well ordered a classic combo no Black Olives. When taking my pizza out of pan the kid flipped the pizza over on itself. They then handed it to us. No offer of discount or to make a different. Instead girl working sent boy home and she went on break. One of the worst pizza I have ever had. I will never come back again.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Jahn Marton

Delicious pizza and reasonably

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

josi yosef

Customer service 000000

Service: 1

Dolores Moore

I ordered by phone. Order was perfect and exactly as expected! Was cooked to perfection!

Parking: Perfect in front of God Fathers entrance.

Christy Anderson

Disappointed and expensive. I would of rather ate a lunchable (pizza) with a oreo and Capri sun and saved $36.00

Loading...