O'Neill's Pizza Pub
50 Main St E, Elgin
(507) 871-3377
Customers' Favorites
Creme Brulee & Peanut Butter Pie
Greek Salad and Fab Five Pizza
4 Meat Lovers Pizza
Pumpkin Cream Cake
Cheese Bread
Meatball Sub
Greek Pizza
Taco Pizza
Sauce
Menu
Photos
+12 photos
+11 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Visited O’Neills for the first time and we were really impressed! The pizza was outstanding and don’t get me started on the desserts. We had the bread pudding and the peanut butter pie, both were exceptional. So many pizza selections to choose from. Great service, fun environment. Definitely worth the short drive from Rochester!
This place is a must-try. We usually take pizza to-go, but have eaten inside the restaurant as well. There's a very warm and welcoming environment; we really felt cared for. The pinball machine was a hit with my 6 yr old and husband alike. We usually order a pineapple pizza (my son's favorite), but have also tried the pepperoni and both were delicious. Perfectly crunchy crust, no frills, just yummy pizza. Oh, and the creme brulee was to die for!! I want so badly to try...
We love to order pizza to-go from O'Niells. The pizza is always amazing. We usually order a taco pizza half no olives and a pepperoni pizza. It is always done well and is delicious.
You May Also Like
The BlackTop Bar and Grill - 30 Main St E
![]()
Sports Bar, Venues & Event Spaces, American
Tarasco's - 25188 534th St
![]()
New Mexican Cuisine, Bar, Burgers