The Lucky Lure

412 Main St, Madison Lake
(507) 243-4343

Recent Reviews

Anthony freitas

I'm glad I found this place after being spoiled in a large city with food everywhere. Chicken is hands down ??? Super friendly

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

CD

Got a perfectly gooey and cheesy pepperoni thin crust pizza! Quick and friendly delivery too!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

D Miller

Delicious pizza! It was definitely enough to fill a person up. I would definitely go back again, but with an army to eat the pizza I couldn’t finish!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

J Twaddle

Pizza is OK at best. Avoid the dessert pizza. It tastes just as terrible as the picture looks.

Barb Lysne

Great service while ordering. Fast delivery. Excellent customer service from delivery gal. And of course the pizza was delicious. We had thin crust chicken alfredo. Highly recommend.

Cherie Crawford

I ordered online. It said my order would be ready at 12:45 and when I arrived at 12:45, boom! Fresh hot pizza. The it was delicious. The folks are friendly. The atmosphere is perfect. How is the thin crust loaded down with toppings yet still crispy? The veggie pizza can’t be beat. The only negative is that I live 1,125 miles from this place and can’t stop in anytime I get the urge for this scrumptiousnessVegetarian options: I got the veggie pizza

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Cristina Bean

Visited The Lucky Lure on vacation last week, and it was delicious! I had an unusual request -- could I try the hot Ham & Swiss sandwich on the gluten-free pizza crust? It worked out beautifully and was delicious, too. So glad they were willing to work with me. Will definitely eat here again next time I'm in town!Dietary restrictions: They have #glutenfree pizza crust, as well as many delicious-sounding salad options.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ramona M.

I struggle and want so badly to give them a better review, but time and again I am disappointed in their service. Today is not the first time we placed a delivery order and estimated delivery time was more than an hour out. And it is not the first time that 30 minutes after the estimated delivery time the food had not arrived and I had to call and check on the status of the order. Once, they had trouble finding the order, and when they did find it, it still took nearly an hour more to arrive. Another time, as well as today, I called 30 minutes past the delivery time and was told it was "in the oven". And it finally arrived 30 minutes late Now the food, it's good. I like the Buffalo chicken pizza for a change of pace, and the comfy combo with soft warm breadsticks and a really good alfredo are satisfying. The loaded toasted sub and Philly cheese steak are among our favorites and they have a decent gyro for a local dive bar. The prices are reasonable for the quality and quantity of food you get.

Megan Ulrich

The new take and bake options are amazing. The cheese bread is to die for!! We had the cheeseburger pizza and it was so delicious. We also loved the pastas, lots of cheese and such a yummy snack or meal for anyone!!

Dennis Stanke

It was the worst service I have ever seen... Food was cold and tasted terrible...

Angela “Annie” Karels

I feel that this place was worth my time to say something awesome about it. I usually don't go to bars or drink but this place is so much more than just alcohol they have awesome food awesome people. bingo on the weekend what more could u ask for.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nicholas Caven

Good pizza and reasonable prices. We'll be back!

Angela Karels

I feel that this place was worth my time to say something awesome about it. I usually don't go to bars or drink but this place is so much more than just alcohol they have awesome food awesome people. bingo on the weekend what more could u ask for.

Steve Carlberg

Great food. Friendly staff

Kathy Thomas

Nice place, good pizza.

Load More