Haven't been here for about 20 years so decided to give it a try. Waited for 10 minutes because of a "Wait to be seated" sign as we looked over 7 or 8 empty tables. We were ultimately greeted with "it's going to be about a 40 to 45 minute wait"...at that point we were out...I'd love to do a real review but not under those circumstances.
Airka Tatiana Gould
New name new menus but still a great place to sit n relax over dinner or hit the bar and throw down on etabs or pool. Smoke deck great staff good prices and altogether great place. If ever there ask for Lisa if ur eating.
Justin Brune
Was there on a Tuesday night bartender was fantastic my drink was never empty for more than 30 seconds. I had the Goliath Burger very good wish they had some more fish, ribs or chicken meals to choose from.
95zChevy
First off, the service folk are excellent! Impeccable service indeed.Sadly though the food was not the most impressive at all. The grilled cheese is clearly made with Kraft singles or maybe even an off-brand. Disgusting grilled cheese sandwich. Beef was overcooked and the boneless wings have way too much breading on them.Great service but disappointed in the food. The cod meal was subpar as well. Upgrade the food quality people.
Michele Agnes
We had a family reunion at the Rustic this weekend. Even though we had a large group, Jordan & Lisa did a wonderful job. The food was delicious!
Beth Beckman
Great food and excellent service! We really enjoyed our meal and time there.
Kenny Dodge
Over priced food, my pop was only 50 cents cheaper than a mixed drink. Not much of a selection and the waitress still didn't know what was on it. Took forever to get service once seated and the waitress got our order wrong. Do not recommend eating here!
Andrew Nyblom
Fajitas were on par with the best available in the area. The collection of kids games/puzzles were a plus.
Cindi Bell
Delicious food, priced right, good portions, everything fresh. Great service, polite, accommodating, but not intrusive. Very clean and observed wait staff clean thoroughly after every diner. Bathroom was clean too. I'd give it 5 stars. The only critique I'd have is flavored vodka other than raspberry or cherry. How about a limone, lemon, lime or mandarine orange?
AJ Hans
My friends mini burgers were very bland while my beef Quesadilla was too salty. Very basic bar menu. Server was ok. She brought the bill without asking if we wanted dessert, refills or anything else. I would have ordered more but felt a little pushed out.
Love this new addition to the Rustic and the whole revamp of their business!! We took our daughter here and they had coloring pages and puzzles. It kept her entertained for quite some time! She had the cutest time burger, dad got the Philly cheesesteak and I had a chicken strip basket. Only complaint is that the Philly cheesesteak has like a full green bell pepper in it in very thick slices, but that could be a preference thing.
Mike
Our first trip to the Rustic Inn since it was renamed the Rustic Buffalo under new owners. Slightly disappointed in the menu as it was primarily sandwiches and didn’t include many menu selections that appear on-line. But, the food we ordered was good as was service and cleaned up furnishings. Hoping the menu adds some old dinner favorites!
Josh Bydlon
My son and I went for a snowmobile ride and stopped. We had burgers and they were delicious. The buns were toasted and amazing. Burger was juicy and flavorful. Tots were fried, no need to say more on those. Also had great service. Would come back again anytime.
Stephanie Mrachek
This place just recently opened up and is called the Rustic Buffalo as it replaced the old Rustic Inn. It's a nice quaint place to have lunch or dinner. We enjoyed the food, and the portions were perfectly sized for the price. We will definitely go back.
Shocked Monk
Sadly have to give this place a 1 star, the new owners destroyed the experienceThe burgers I had tasted bland, the food was cold and the bun was soggy when we got itMy mother got the fajitas and the meat was cold, the cheese was moldy, and the meat was spicy without it being labeled as suchOne of the burgers we ate had hard chunks in itAll in all we had around 12 people eat here as a family get together and less than half of us actually ate any of the food, they ended up giving us 10 percent off but when only half the meal was edible its quite ridiculousThe only saving grace of the experience was that the waitresses were amazing, they alone made the experience better by being so kind and understandingMe and my family will not be coming back to eat here likely ever again, we would rather eat fast food
Haven't been here for about 20 years so decided to give it a try. Waited for 10 minutes because of a "Wait to be seated" sign as we looked over 7 or 8 empty tables. We were ultimately greeted with "it's going to be about a 40 to 45 minute wait"...at that point we were out...I'd love to do a real review but not under those circumstances.
New name new menus but still a great place to sit n relax over dinner or hit the bar and throw down on etabs or pool. Smoke deck great staff good prices and altogether great place. If ever there ask for Lisa if ur eating.
Was there on a Tuesday night bartender was fantastic my drink was never empty for more than 30 seconds. I had the Goliath Burger very good wish they had some more fish, ribs or chicken meals to choose from.
First off, the service folk are excellent! Impeccable service indeed.Sadly though the food was not the most impressive at all. The grilled cheese is clearly made with Kraft singles or maybe even an off-brand. Disgusting grilled cheese sandwich. Beef was overcooked and the boneless wings have way too much breading on them.Great service but disappointed in the food. The cod meal was subpar as well. Upgrade the food quality people.
We had a family reunion at the Rustic this weekend. Even though we had a large group, Jordan & Lisa did a wonderful job. The food was delicious!
Great food and excellent service! We really enjoyed our meal and time there.
Over priced food, my pop was only 50 cents cheaper than a mixed drink. Not much of a selection and the waitress still didn't know what was on it. Took forever to get service once seated and the waitress got our order wrong. Do not recommend eating here!
Fajitas were on par with the best available in the area. The collection of kids games/puzzles were a plus.
Delicious food, priced right, good portions, everything fresh. Great service, polite, accommodating, but not intrusive. Very clean and observed wait staff clean thoroughly after every diner. Bathroom was clean too. I'd give it 5 stars. The only critique I'd have is flavored vodka other than raspberry or cherry. How about a limone, lemon, lime or mandarine orange?
My friends mini burgers were very bland while my beef Quesadilla was too salty. Very basic bar menu. Server was ok. She brought the bill without asking if we wanted dessert, refills or anything else. I would have ordered more but felt a little pushed out.
Restaurantji Recommends
Love this new addition to the Rustic and the whole revamp of their business!! We took our daughter here and they had coloring pages and puzzles. It kept her entertained for quite some time! She had the cutest time burger, dad got the Philly cheesesteak and I had a chicken strip basket. Only complaint is that the Philly cheesesteak has like a full green bell pepper in it in very thick slices, but that could be a preference thing.
Our first trip to the Rustic Inn since it was renamed the Rustic Buffalo under new owners. Slightly disappointed in the menu as it was primarily sandwiches and didn’t include many menu selections that appear on-line. But, the food we ordered was good as was service and cleaned up furnishings. Hoping the menu adds some old dinner favorites!
My son and I went for a snowmobile ride and stopped. We had burgers and they were delicious. The buns were toasted and amazing. Burger was juicy and flavorful. Tots were fried, no need to say more on those. Also had great service. Would come back again anytime.
This place just recently opened up and is called the Rustic Buffalo as it replaced the old Rustic Inn. It's a nice quaint place to have lunch or dinner. We enjoyed the food, and the portions were perfectly sized for the price. We will definitely go back.
Sadly have to give this place a 1 star, the new owners destroyed the experienceThe burgers I had tasted bland, the food was cold and the bun was soggy when we got itMy mother got the fajitas and the meat was cold, the cheese was moldy, and the meat was spicy without it being labeled as suchOne of the burgers we ate had hard chunks in itAll in all we had around 12 people eat here as a family get together and less than half of us actually ate any of the food, they ended up giving us 10 percent off but when only half the meal was edible its quite ridiculousThe only saving grace of the experience was that the waitresses were amazing, they alone made the experience better by being so kind and understandingMe and my family will not be coming back to eat here likely ever again, we would rather eat fast food
Loading...