Green Mill Restaurant & Bar

Food ans and service were outstanding. A little bit loud for my taste, but it is understandable since they have a sport bar inside the restaurant. My God!!! The fries and burgers were to perfection, and they were not greasy. They went out of their way to find the beer I wanted. The restaurant was getting really hot inside, and the servers closed the blinds, so the summer sun doesn't roast the customer inside, and then the AC works better. Awesome service guys! Thank you!!!

Consistently one of the worst food places in the area. I’ve eaten from here maybe once a year for the past 5 years and every.single.time. the food sucks. Lately, the thin crust pizza I ordered was undercooked. The dough was all floppy and chewy. Pizza should be their specialty. The marinara sauce that came with the breadsticks was waaaayyyy too acidic! Wow. This isn’t the first time I’ve ordered food and basic cooking steps were F’d up. I once pulled an intact wax paper liner out of my mouth from the burger patty I took a bite into, as the cook forgot to take it off. They also screwed up my date’s food on the same order. Every time I come here it’s either a new server or a server getting trained in, so there has to be high turnover. I surmise the cause of consistently untrained/lack of knowledgeable staff and repeated incompetence with basic cooking skills points to bad management. Unfortunately, they keep relatively full with locals - I imagine walking over from 3M after work or have just been coming there for so long out of loyalty - that they don’t appear to be close to saving us from mistakenly wasting our time and money while thinking this is a smidgeon better than the bottom.

Bartender figured it was ok to serve a couple regulars but told me and another customer that last call was over and we couldn't get another drink. Definitely not a way to do business.

The double burger patty with the mashed potatoes drove me crazy I've been eating here three times a week the texture of the steak burger patty is out of this world I've always tipped at least $8

Great food Great service! Calzone was yummy!!

If you’re looking for exceptional catering with outstanding food and top-tier service, look no further than Green Mill in Woodbury. Wayne and Keegan went above and beyond to cater our daughter’s graduation party, delivering a flawless experience for our out-of-town guests. From start to finish, everything was impeccable! Thanks Green Mill! You’re THE BEST!!!

A group of 10. Waited almost 20 minutes just to get orders in. Then we waited for over 80 minutes for our food. 3 of the orders were wrong. Can't really recommend this place. Just get fast food.

Great place to hang out with friends and to watch football games. Food is always tasty and the bartenders are the best!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I used to love their old chicken marsala, but their new chicken marsalait's pretty darn good and your pizza sauce. I think is the best in the cities.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wings, Pepperoni Deep Dish Pizza, Pizza

Waiter was great

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Fast and patient while I was with a big party

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Cheese Garlic Bread

Good service. Very accomodating staff. The food was great.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Waitress was good in the beginning,
Didn't come around too often
To check on if I needed anything

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Pizza

I had ordered over the phone 3 dozen chicken wings for a birthday party for pick up last Sunday. I got home and opened the 3 containers and there were on 20 wings, not 36 wings. I called and the person who answered attempted to explain they are now sold by the pound. Not once during my call in order was that explained or called out. None the less when ordering 3 dozen wings a person should get 3 dozen not 20 small wings. 50$ for 20 small wings is absolutely ludicrous. What has happen to the Green Mill of past.

Food: 3

Service: 2

I’ve been to this restaurant 3 times, and it’s been great every time.
Food - Me and my friends that go here have gotten a Hot Honey pizza every time we go, along with some appetizers. None of the things we order disappoint. We usually get a large pizza and save some leftovers, and they heat up great.
Service - Great service, especially when compared to some other sit down restaurants. Short wait times, food is always fresh, and staff is always friendly. They also granted us a special request when we asked for an XL pizza while we were there (XL is usually only an online option)
Atmosphere - Plenty of seating and many booths, which I appreciate. Only con is that it can be noisy when seated next to the bar, but that’s totally fine and to be expected.
Great place for group dining, they do serve large portions here.

Parking: Never have had any issues with parking.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza, Millhouse Nachos