I had the French dip. The beef was strange. Very dry and crumbly. The beef was gritty, like sand in the mouth. Flavor was nothing special. Not at all worth $9.49 plus tax, $10.42. Maybe a 6 inch bun. A complete disappointment! This was my first, and my last Earl of Sandwich.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5
John Syers
We love Earl of Sandwich, we weren't even aware there was a location in the Midwest and we just saw the sign and stopped. I had my usual the Holiday Turkey, comfort food at it's finest!! Took it back to our resort, amazing sandwich!! You should be eating here!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Shelley Rohleder
We got the meatball sandwich and a couple pizzas. They were both good but the meatball sandwich was fantastic. Easy online ordering and pickup.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Kenji Snow
Everytime I’ve ordered a sandwich with “everything on it” I get bread, meat and a slice of cheese. No mayo no mustard no onions no pickles, no tomatoes, nothing just a dry county jail sandwich.
Why offer everything, acknowledge everything when asked and then pull that kind of cheapskate bs?
Alicia Ellis
Don’t do it! Save your money! SKIP
Brooke Johnson Wormington
Rude staff and less than mediocre food
MOPAR MAN 1978
Ordered from Door Dash the Earl Roast beef and cheddar and a side of tator tots. sandwich was good but tator tots was grease soaked not crispy and brownish black specs in most of the tator tots ?? Dont know if this was bruised spots in the potatoes when they got made into tots form factory or rotten spots in the potato ? didnt eat them
Heather Connell
Terrible. I spent $40 on 4 sandwiches that I could have made better myself. The bread was dense, dry, and flavorless. The bacon was bacon bits from a jar. The amount of meat was 1/8 of that found on a typical sub sandwich. It tasted as if it was days old. The first red flag I should have considered was the fact that the building was inside a gas station. I could have spent the same amount of money on the masterpiece that is Jersey Mikes. Do not go.
Ashley W
Very tasty sandwich!!! Made to order and toasted. Very clean and tidy gas station with sandwich shop inside.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mrs Hoeft
Just had order delivered by DoorDash and it’s missing almost all of it. They were out of Dr Pepper, put no meat at all in the wrap and I’m missing my son’s sandwich and can’t get ahold of anyone
Just had order delivered by DoorDash and it’s missing almost all of it. They were out of Dr Pepper, put no meat at all in the wrap and I’m missing my son’s sandwich and can’t get ahold of anyone
Michelle Abel
OMGosh, what a surprising little gem of a find! EVERYTHING we ordered was absolutely delicious. I mean seriously– YUM.The serving size for their soup is big enough to feel satisfied, and even comes with a bag of homemade croutons! (FYI: We had the Tomato and the Chicken Tortilla.) We also got a couple of sandwiches (some crazy-big Meatball sub w/cheese, sauce, & [?] + a Pastrami sandwich/sub; pepperoni pizza bread; and mac & cheese (which we were supposed to share, but it was so good that I ate it all myself! ?). The rest of the food lasted us all weekend, and it was still just as delicious reheated!I feel I need to make a point to mention that the 2 gentleman that took our order and made our food that night were BEYOND friendly. Not for even one second did they ever make me feel like I was an inconvenience [for having the nerve to order FOOD at a 'food establishment' ?] like many places do –if ya know-what-I-mean?? Another pleasant surprise – it only took about 15 minutes for the entire order to be ready!
Vegetarian options: I know they offer Tomato Soup, Cheese Pizza and Garlic Cheese Bread. I don't recall an actual 'Vegetarian' Menu section, but there ARE some choices for you.?
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mac & Cheese, Chicken Noodle
Kendall Hayes
Had this delivered today was a very tasty Italian sandwich salad and soup was
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian, Side Salad, Premium Combo
Nathan Moore
Had The Club Sub and Pastrami Sandwich while eating here. You can add or take off whatever you want and is fairly welcome to do so. A combo was around $12 to $14 with tax not too bad. The tater tots are really good light but they could be a little more crispier but not bad at all very flavorful. The better sandwich in my opinion was the club with fresh vegetables and tasty fresh turkey. The pastrami was pretty good as well not the best pastrami I’ve had but the sauerkraut was the perfect amount of acidic vinegar taste. Atmosphere is…. Lack luster with maybe one or two tables to sit and eat but also had a side of warm Mac n cheese with bacon, while completely cooked it could have used a bit more spice. Also the noodles are done al dente, which isn’t a problem but not a favorite of mine. Al dente-less boiled noodles.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Italian
Jett G
We woked to The World’s greatest Sandwich and we very happy with our choice!! It lives up yo it’s claim!!Mahalo~Jett. ??
I had the French dip. The beef was strange. Very dry and crumbly. The beef was gritty, like sand in the mouth. Flavor was nothing special. Not at all worth $9.49 plus tax, $10.42. Maybe a 6 inch bun. A complete disappointment! This was my first, and my last Earl of Sandwich.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5
We love Earl of Sandwich, we weren't even aware there was a location in the Midwest and we just saw the sign and stopped. I had my usual the Holiday Turkey, comfort food at it's finest!! Took it back to our resort, amazing sandwich!! You should be eating here!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We got the meatball sandwich and a couple pizzas. They were both good but the meatball sandwich was fantastic. Easy online ordering and pickup.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Everytime I’ve ordered a sandwich with “everything on it” I get bread, meat and a slice of cheese. No mayo no mustard no onions no pickles, no tomatoes, nothing just a dry county jail sandwich.
Why offer everything, acknowledge everything when asked and then pull that kind of cheapskate bs?
Don’t do it! Save your money! SKIP
Rude staff and less than mediocre food
Ordered from Door Dash the Earl Roast beef and cheddar and a side of tator tots. sandwich was good but tator tots was grease soaked not crispy and brownish black specs in most of the tator tots ?? Dont know if this was bruised spots in the potatoes when they got made into tots form factory or rotten spots in the potato ? didnt eat them
Terrible. I spent $40 on 4 sandwiches that I could have made better myself. The bread was dense, dry, and flavorless. The bacon was bacon bits from a jar. The amount of meat was 1/8 of that found on a typical sub sandwich. It tasted as if it was days old. The first red flag I should have considered was the fact that the building was inside a gas station. I could have spent the same amount of money on the masterpiece that is Jersey Mikes. Do not go.
Very tasty sandwich!!! Made to order and toasted. Very clean and tidy gas station with sandwich shop inside.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Just had order delivered by DoorDash and it’s missing almost all of it. They were out of Dr Pepper, put no meat at all in the wrap and I’m missing my son’s sandwich and can’t get ahold of anyone
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Just had order delivered by DoorDash and it’s missing almost all of it. They were out of Dr Pepper, put no meat at all in the wrap and I’m missing my son’s sandwich and can’t get ahold of anyone
OMGosh, what a surprising little gem of a find! EVERYTHING we ordered was absolutely delicious. I mean seriously– YUM.The serving size for their soup is big enough to feel satisfied, and even comes with a bag of homemade croutons! (FYI: We had the Tomato and the Chicken Tortilla.) We also got a couple of sandwiches (some crazy-big Meatball sub w/cheese, sauce, & [?] + a Pastrami sandwich/sub; pepperoni pizza bread; and mac & cheese (which we were supposed to share, but it was so good that I ate it all myself! ?). The rest of the food lasted us all weekend, and it was still just as delicious reheated!I feel I need to make a point to mention that the 2 gentleman that took our order and made our food that night were BEYOND friendly. Not for even one second did they ever make me feel like I was an inconvenience [for having the nerve to order FOOD at a 'food establishment' ?] like many places do –if ya know-what-I-mean?? Another pleasant surprise – it only took about 15 minutes for the entire order to be ready!
Vegetarian options: I know they offer Tomato Soup, Cheese Pizza and Garlic Cheese Bread. I don't recall an actual 'Vegetarian' Menu section, but there ARE some choices for you.?
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mac & Cheese, Chicken Noodle
Had this delivered today was a very tasty Italian sandwich salad and soup was
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian, Side Salad, Premium Combo
Had The Club Sub and Pastrami Sandwich while eating here. You can add or take off whatever you want and is fairly welcome to do so. A combo was around $12 to $14 with tax not too bad. The tater tots are really good light but they could be a little more crispier but not bad at all very flavorful. The better sandwich in my opinion was the club with fresh vegetables and tasty fresh turkey. The pastrami was pretty good as well not the best pastrami I’ve had but the sauerkraut was the perfect amount of acidic vinegar taste. Atmosphere is…. Lack luster with maybe one or two tables to sit and eat but also had a side of warm Mac n cheese with bacon, while completely cooked it could have used a bit more spice. Also the noodles are done al dente, which isn’t a problem but not a favorite of mine. Al dente-less boiled noodles.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Italian
We woked to The World’s greatest Sandwich and we very happy with our choice!! It lives up yo it’s claim!!Mahalo~Jett. ??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...