Old Tyme Diner

201 MO-21, Caledonia
(573) 779-1297

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Kenneth Schmidt

ordered 3 cheeseburgers came to table within 5min flavorless seemed to be steamed pre made patties thrown on grill for a min frozen tater tots and French fries 1 table and they got order wrong 50 dollar bill for a 15 dollar experience owner didn't try to make it right just said we should have said something to waiter so they could give us another gross burger had no problem paying bill but will not be back nor would I recommend to anyone ashame you can't find decent food anymore love supporting local businesses but this experience was just disappointing and a costly lesson.

Nichole Wakefield

went today for the first time. it was busy and only 2 actual waitresses working. we waited forever so we sat ourselves because thats what the bus boy told us to do. no one knew we were there so I went and told the register lady that we needed drinks and menus. I got a burger it was meh tasted frozen i didnt eat it after the forst few bites not worth the calories. my aunts chicken sandwich was a plain chicken strip on a huge bun. it was pretty unorganized. no one knew who took what order or who did what. I never leave reviews but the cherry on top was when they threw away my baby's burp cloth that I forgot at the table. maybe 10 minutes after we left I went back in to get it and she tried to dig it out of the trash to give it back. like who does that? Who throws away someone's belongings? is there no lost and found or wait period before you trash your customers things? it irritated me more than the bad food. I won't go back. I wasted 30 dollars on nothing.

James Sheil

Good lunch food, fair prices, and the baked potatoes are enormous.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

V Pickett

Good ole fashioned country cooking! Chicken and dumplings, the special of the day were delicious and filled with roasted chicken and lots of rolled dumplings. The outside garden decor and photo booth make you stop and take notice.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ellen Dunman

Stopped in Caladonia to end our road trip. We shared a sandwich because, well...it was a lot. Great service. And a good way to end our day.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Doyle White

I have ate there several times and tye food, service and atmosphere has been excellent. Prices are fair and the food quality excellent.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Thomas Taylor

Probably the worst food my family has eaten in years.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 1

Joey Skersick

This place seemed like a cool place. Go in and they have Joy playing on the radio. Seemed like a good place. Wrong. I had ants in my soda to start with. The waitress was nice but had to flag her down if you want something. The boss is sitting in the corner of the dining area and just looks like a total slob. Had an apron on. Dont know if he helps cooking but I sure hope not. Looked like he hasn't showered in a week and would not want him neer my food. Then I get charged 3 times for the endless wings. I did share 2 of the wings. One with the wife and one with my daughter. But still if anything should have only got charged for 2. The one I shared from and the other should have been the endless. And when I asked about my bill and getting charged so much the boss was very rude about it and just turned his back and walked away. Do not recommend this place. Food and service is definitely not worth the money and you may have to deal with rude people if you go here. Not worth it!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Alicia Marler

My husband and I and are kids went for lunch and saw an “all you can eat wings” for 14.95. So my husband decided to order it, my daughter and I got something else. There were two ants in my husbands soda, then when the food came out, he let my 3 year old daughter and I each have a wing. Well, when we went to pay, our total was $90 and was being charged 3 times for the all you can eat wings because we each had 1 wing. Where as I understand where the manager was coming from for charging us that much, I don’t think it was fair to charge us 3 times !! When my husband said something to him, he was SO RUDE and walked away. We will not be back, save your time and money and go somewhere else. The food was not even that good.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Britt H

Service was terrible- waitress never checked on us we had to flag her down and items were forgotten in our order that we never received the entire meal after asking numerous times. The chicken and dumplings were disgusting. Do yourself a favor and just go to the hot dog stand instead!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Lauren Anne Cole

Oh - MY- GOODNESS!!!! Nicest people - AWESOME FOOD!!!!’

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tiffani Radake

I loved this restaurant. I felt like I was at someone's home. I loved the Christian vibes and the wholesome food. The salad I got was amazing and the BLT was extremely good for the low price. Fresh lettuce and in season locally grown tomatoes! I was super impressed. It gave our weekend getaway the perfect touch!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Erika Sullivan

Ordered the Awesome Club and it Was Awesome and GIANT!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

sam martin

Don't eat here rude waitress's & rude boss bad food and what you get for you're meal is crap 😭😭😔

Lea Bradley

LOVE this place! We just popped in this town while camping and saw the colorful old building. Cozy grandma's house atmosphere. Sever and owner so kind and welcoming! They on the spot accommodated 16 of us. Food was actually very great. I have a lot of allergies (alpha gal and dairy) and they didn't bat an eye toward my exclusions and requests!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...