Sarah's Cake Shop

I ordered petit four cakes from here for a rehearsal dinner and they were absolutely delicious! Everyone loved them! The service here was great also. I highly recommend going here!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cake Shop, Bakery, Cake, Cake and Cupcakes

Ordered 2 birthday cakes and they were spectacular. Exactly as requested and delicious. Everyone asked where they came from. I will be ordering again soon 💕

We order for my son’s first birthday. We needed a vegan cake because he has a couple of food allergies. It was so good. Everyone raved about it!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We ordered our wedding cake from Sarah's Cake Shop and only have incredible things to say!

Nicole was a breeze to work with despite me planning the wedding from California -- from the initial tasting and quote, to the design meeting, to the final invoicing and delivery -- everything went smoothly and was completely stress free. The cake tasted absolutely incredible -- we did a sheet cake with white cake, cream cheese frosting and raspberry jam. I sent Nicole a short PDF detailing my inspiration and color desires and she made it perfectly -- I was absolutely in love with the cake. 10/10 experience and would recommend Sarah's Cake Shop to anyone looking for their wedding cake!

Photos were taken by Lenaig of Weiss Photo and Film :)

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sarah's Cake Shop is spectacular! We have tried everything from the little slices of cake available in the shop to hiring them to provide dessert at our 200+ person wedding. Every experience has been delicious. They are so easy to work with and given the quality, their prices are very fair. We look forward to returning for many years to come.

Absolutely loved our wedding cake! Multiple guests commented on how this was the best wedding cake they ever had! Being able to include our cat as part of the cake was so special. This company was responsive, prompt with delivery and they even placed our cake topper and extra flowers we had so beautifully! Definitely recommend!

We used Sarah’s Cake Shop for our wedding cake and dessert bar and everything was absolutely perfect. Not only did everything look beautiful, but it all tasted amazing. We barely had any desserts left by the end of the night. Their team was so easy to work with throughout the entire process. They were responsive, professional, and made everything feel seamless. I would absolutely recommend them to anyone looking for a bakery that delivers both quality and service.

We used Sarah’s Cake Shop for our wedding cake and dessert bar and everything was absolutely perfect. Not only did everything look beautiful, but it all tasted amazing. We barely had any desserts left by the end of the night. Their team was so easy to work with throughout the entire process. They were responsive, professional, and made everything feel seamless. I would absolutely recommend them to anyone looking for a bakery that delivers both quality and service.

Glitter bites and cinnamon rolls are delicious!! Have had these several times and will continue to buy them. I tried the cake slices this weekend and they were very dry, had to throw the chocolate one away. (I bought one of each flavor.) I have tried cupcakes in the past and they were dry also. Perhaps they are best with custom orders for cake and not what is in their case.

Yesterday was my first time experiencing Sarah's cake shop, and I purchased a slice of the everyday wedding cake and OMG!!! It was absolutely DELICIOUS!!!! Cake is moist, flavorful and just absolutely amazing!! The icing is light, fluffy and the almost flavoring is totally scrumptious!! Will definitely be returning to try more!!

I am the girl who goes to weddings for the cake. My sister discovered the shop on TikTok and told me about it. Luckily, my nephew lives near it and and brought me three pieces of the wedding cake, knowing my love wedding cake my granddaughter who is three and I sit down to try this cake and both of us believe that this cake was created in heaven. It was the best cake I’ve ever eaten, and she loves it as well

Absolutely love this place :) their brownies are one of my favorite things and their custom cake they did for a friend's birthday was spectacular!

Very rude no one greeted us. And desserts were plain and not good. Please learn customer service and learn how to greet paying guests when they walk in your shop.

We absolutely love Sarah's. We used to get stuff from their food trucks, they made the cake for our wedding, and we've come to the chesterfield location several times. It's always so good. 😍 Wish they still had the food trucks delivering around the area.

A delicious cake that my husband got me for my birthday and it was so cute!