My daughter and I visited Eureka for vocation. We’re unfamiliar with the area and was unsure where to eat. We definitely weren’t disappointed with the atmosphere, food, and live music it was a pleasant experience and the food was great. I’d recommend stopping by Sarah’s on Central.
dave moses
This is a great, small town diner. The staff is friendly and professional. The food is fantastic.
Eric Peoples
Fantastic little Brunch/Bakery place. The food was top-notch, and the service was excellent! Central is a wonderful street in Eureka!
Ashley Grier
Sarah’s was a fun cute spot to stop and have lunch. The food was delicious and different. Love the breakfast or brunch options all day as well as sandwiches and salads. Service was great and attentive. It’s a little pricey but delicious food.
Donna Hager
What a great place for brunch! Top notch bloody Mary’s and the food was so good as well. Montana was our bartender/server and made the whole experience that much more excellent! Will definitely be back!
Jenny Roques
Everyone was extremely nice, and the service was good, but unfortunately some of the food did not meet the bar today.
I had one of the specials, the Shrimp and Grits, and after two bites, I could not eat anymore. The shrimp was extremely overdone and chewy, the grits a nearly solid consistency, and the sauce tasted soured. My stomach has been off since. When the server came to check on the table I informed them that the food was not good, and they apologized, but that was it.
Everyone else’s meal was ok and I’m expecting the issue with my food was not the norm. I wish our server was more helpful with taking action in the meal, instead of just saying “oh, sorry, I guess you don’t like it”. I ended up not having anything, but still paid for the meal.
Overall, I would give them another chance, but would be weary about what I ordered.
James Borgelt
The food and service is absolutely unmatched! I have never had a bad meal or experience here! Highly recommend!
Stephen Polster
I made reservations for fifteen people 3 weeks before Mother's Day. The Thursday before it, the owner called me and told me they did not take reservations. She was rude and acted like I was in the wrong for being upset. Thank you for disappointing five Mothers!
Zach Bevins
Great food, had the blue plate special , Meatloaf.. it tasted just like Mom used to make. Sat at the bar with a wonderful bartender. I think her name was Wyoming. Will be back thanks
Jeff Hopkins
We have visited Sarah’s 3 times and each time the service was terrible and the food was cold. The last time we were there there weren’t any paper towels in the bathrooms. 3 bad experiences and we won’t be back.
Our party's meals were fabulous, as was the service. For an 11am brunch rush, which filled up quickly and people were lined up outside (!), we felt no pressure to hurry and the staff didn't press us. Atmosphere is a tad loud but the interior charm makes up for that.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sandwich
Keith D
4 YUMMMERS, tasty food, quaint setting in old Towne Eureka,
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Sandwich
Ryan Poertner
Service was fast and friendly. Food was delicious. Couldn't ask for more. Great little small town restaurant.
Dietary restrictions: They were able to modify some items to be gluten free. Perfect for the celiac member of our party.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mariko Saum
Excellent food! Great service. Sweets are amazing!
My daughter and I visited Eureka for vocation. We’re unfamiliar with the area and was unsure where to eat. We definitely weren’t disappointed with the atmosphere, food, and live music it was a pleasant experience and the food was great. I’d recommend stopping by Sarah’s on Central.
This is a great, small town diner. The staff is friendly and professional. The food is fantastic.
Fantastic little Brunch/Bakery place. The food was top-notch, and the service was excellent! Central is a wonderful street in Eureka!
Sarah’s was a fun cute spot to stop and have lunch. The food was delicious and different. Love the breakfast or brunch options all day as well as sandwiches and salads. Service was great and attentive. It’s a little pricey but delicious food.
What a great place for brunch! Top notch bloody Mary’s and the food was so good as well. Montana was our bartender/server and made the whole experience that much more excellent! Will definitely be back!
Everyone was extremely nice, and the service was good, but unfortunately some of the food did not meet the bar today.
I had one of the specials, the Shrimp and Grits, and after two bites, I could not eat anymore. The shrimp was extremely overdone and chewy, the grits a nearly solid consistency, and the sauce tasted soured. My stomach has been off since. When the server came to check on the table I informed them that the food was not good, and they apologized, but that was it.
Everyone else’s meal was ok and I’m expecting the issue with my food was not the norm. I wish our server was more helpful with taking action in the meal, instead of just saying “oh, sorry, I guess you don’t like it”. I ended up not having anything, but still paid for the meal.
Overall, I would give them another chance, but would be weary about what I ordered.
The food and service is absolutely unmatched! I have never had a bad meal or experience here! Highly recommend!
I made reservations for fifteen people 3 weeks before Mother's Day. The Thursday before it, the owner called me and told me they did not take reservations. She was rude and acted like I was in the wrong for being upset. Thank you for disappointing five Mothers!
Great food, had the blue plate special , Meatloaf.. it tasted just like Mom used to make. Sat at the bar with a wonderful bartender. I think her name was Wyoming. Will be back thanks
We have visited Sarah’s 3 times and each time the service was terrible and the food was cold. The last time we were there there weren’t any paper towels in the bathrooms. 3 bad experiences and we won’t be back.
Restaurantji Recommends
A wonderful place eat breakfast
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Our party's meals were fabulous, as was the service. For an 11am brunch rush, which filled up quickly and people were lined up outside (!), we felt no pressure to hurry and the staff didn't press us. Atmosphere is a tad loud but the interior charm makes up for that.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sandwich
4 YUMMMERS, tasty food, quaint setting in old Towne Eureka,
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Sandwich
Service was fast and friendly. Food was delicious. Couldn't ask for more. Great little small town restaurant.
Dietary restrictions: They were able to modify some items to be gluten free. Perfect for the celiac member of our party.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent food! Great service. Sweets are amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: blt
Loading...