Sarah's On Central
127 S Central Ave, Eureka
(636) 938-4800
Customers' Favorites
Big Cake Slice Cinnamon Roll Cake
Quiche Bacon and Cheddar
Gourmet Grilled Cheese
Blackened Salmon Tacos
Chicken and Waffles
Bloody Mary Flight
Central Benedict
Chicken & Waffle
Shrimp & Grits
Breakfast blt
Menu
Photos
+58 photos
+57 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I have been wanting to try Sarahs for over a year now. Finally made it there today (8/31/25). There was a bit of a wait but everyone was very pleasant and kind and we were able to walk on main street a little. The bloody mary was wonderful and the cinnamon roll was hands down the best I have ever had! Everyone enjoyed what they ordered.
I used to really love Sarah’s but lately it’s been really busy and loud. We aren’t able to make reservations, which is a big bummer, and the service has been a bit slow. The food also feels overpriced. I wish the hours were more consistent too. While they are posted on google (and that’s on me for not checking), I don’t want to check google every day to see their hours. Closing at 2pm, then 6pm, then 8 pm is hard to adjust to and can be really frustrating when you pull...
Such a great spot for a breakfast lunch or dinner. If you’re there for breakfast, I always get the loaded breakfast burritos, smothered, and gravy… And I pair it with the mayor bloody Mary. I’m not a big guy, but my kids absolutely adore their desserts as well.
You May Also Like
O'Dell's Irish Pub & Ale House - 141 S Central Ave
![]()
Irish Pub, American, Pubs, Irish, Bar
Chick N Elly's - 122 S Central Ave
![]()
Family, American, Chicken Wings, Dive Bar, Vegetarian
Joe Boccardi's - 128 Boccardi Lane, 128 S Central Ave
![]()
Italian, Pizza, Vegetarian