First time at Pie O My Pizza the pizza had good flavor and nice crisp to the crust well worth the 40 min drive and the guys were great Thank You
dlbstl
I ordered through doordash and got a sandwich that did not have cheese. I ordered the roast beef with cheese it's supposed to have bubbling melted cheese on it. When I called they said there was nothing they could do about it unless I came in. I wouldn't have had doordash if I could walk in because I am working. Very poor guest service.
Food: 1
Colleen Hicks
I ordered a 14in pepperoni and sausage pizza and 6 trashed wings. When I got there, they said it would be 8 more minutes. It looked like they just took my order off of the printer when I arrived, even though I put my order in 20 minutes earlier. It was yesterday afternoon(Monday). When got home, I discovered the wings were not trashed, so I had to put in the air fryer to get them crispy. I then discovered the pizza tasted like the crust was yeasty which overpowered the flavor of everything else. It tasted as if the dough was from the day before. We usually have very tasty pizza from you all, but was disappointed this time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 3
Lou Mayes
I ordered the meat lovers pizza with green peppers, onions, and mushrooms online. I paid with my credit card. I drove to Pie O My Pizza to get my pizza and they said they didn’t have my order. They wanted proof and I opened my email and there was a message and it said they couldn’t honor my order. I then opened my text messages and it said they were out of stock and couldn't honor my order. With this information, the order taker said they could make the pizza with a 20 miinute wait. They were right on time with my pizza and I paid for it with the same credit card that I used on line. The big disappointment was the pizza itself and the almost $30.00 I paid for a 14”. The sauce was good with plenty of cheese and 6 large pepperonis and that is where it stopped. I couldn't find the bacon or ham. There was a small portion of sausage, maybe 8 slivers of green pepper and onion with no trace of mushrooms. The final disappointment was the topping didn't go to the edge but was 1 1/2”-2” from the edge. If you took the 1 1/2” to be conservative and subtracted it from the 14” all the way around, I got a 11” pizza for almost $30.00. Don't think I will be back, to many problems.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Super Honky
I’ve been going here off and on since they’ve opened. The owners a good dude from the local community. He used to own another bar/restaurant in the area. Place has great pizza, food , and it’s local. Support local!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jacob Gaddis
Great food! Great service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Elizabeth Umstead
Read reviews and decided to try this place when I took family to six flags. The pizza here is absolutely amaxing!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bob Anderson
Tasty hand tossed pizza. Accommodated choices nicely, crust was light and crunchy but not overdone. Nice small business, small inside area to eat, had tables outside too. No bathroom but neighboring establishment has readily available. Will stop by again!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gluten Free Meat Lovers
Jason Clark
The hand tossed crust is excellent! Beyond any expectations. Generous toppings and the provel, mozzarella blend is my personal favorite. We ordered sausage and pepperoni and it did not disappoint. Extra large pepperoni, and perfectly seasoned sausage. Can't wait to get back for another Pie!! This place is a gem.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
CRP
Been here twice and excellent service, food, and value. Please support local.
Excellent Northeast style hand tossed pizza! Everyone working was polite and nice. Well definitely go back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bob Fobian
I could not detect even one drop of sauce. It was as if they slapped cheese and meat on dry, bland crust.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Scott Cisco
First visit tonight but won't be our last. Really friendly staff! We ordered a 16" meat lovers hand tossed pizza that was so good. Crust had an excellent crunch without being tough! It had strips of crispy bacon. Overall very good and we will be ordering again!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Lovers
Paul Dombrowski
Great mom & pop pizza joint. great pizza, quick and easy to order. Staff was great. They have a few tables outside, if you want to hang and enjoy a pizza with friends/family there. The pizza I ordered came with good amount of toppings and the crust was thin and crispy
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread Bites
Brett Condit
So let me tell you a story about a gluten free taco pizza and a guy who has celiac (surprise twist, the guy is me) I was having a good day. I'm recovering from a stem cell transplant that took place about about a year ago. The transplant was a success but recovery has been rough. It's been a very hard year. Originally the guy was from Iowa and they have a lovely taco pizza at the Casey's gas station (don't judge until you've had it anyway). Our guy learned he had celiac and thought he'd never again have a gluten free taco pizza. Fast forward 20 ish years and thhhhje guy is recovering from his stem cell transplant. It went perfectly, shout out Barnes Jewish Hospital but guy continues to suffer from GVHD. Back to today I made a fantastic breakfast because my blood sugar was good. I get to lunch and I'm feeling a grilled cheese sandwich with tomato bisque soup. I get my soup on, I go to get my bread.. mold.... Ok I'll figure something out. Then out of nowhere my head feels like it was dunked into a fishbowl. I check my pulse ox and heart rate knowing my heart rate is gonna be skyrocketing and sure enough it is but I see my pulse ox and it says 67 and I'm like surely that isn't right but yup 67 it is. I abandon my not bread sandwich and sit down I tell my partner and she calls my oncology team and they say call 911 and do whatever the ambulance says and I'm like ok. Ambulance gets there they don't take me and we go to the nearest ER shout out to Mercy South. Anyway the ER has food but nothing gluten free. Now it's like 7 or 8 and the kitchen is closed. I decide I'm gonna door dash and what do I find... A loc gluten free taco pizza. I'm so overjoyed that I bought the nursing staff some garlic bites (surprise twist number two they loved them) but alas no taco pizza there must have been a mistake on door dashes part. I contact them and they give me credit.. cool beans. I contact pie oh my Pizza and they recognized the order and saw where the mix up might have occured. At this point I believe the kitchen is closed and the oven is shut down but they're like no you wanted a gluten free taco pizza you're gonna to get a gluten free taco pizza. They fired up the ovens and made one of the greatest pizzas I've ever had in my entire life. So the best shout out o Chris Gurley and JoAnna Kinnison for bringing that place to life and whoever else worked tonight. They don't even have a delivery service one of their employees had to figure out what hospital and get it to me. That's above and beyond in my book. Bonus shout out to my man Ry an amazing nurses aide. During my recovery it's been an emotional and physical rollercoaster and people like Chris, JoAnna, Ry, Tosha (my nurse) and the other staff at Oh My Pizzza Pie and Mercy South that help me find my way through this.
First time at Pie O My Pizza the pizza had good flavor and nice crisp to the crust well worth the 40 min drive and the guys were great Thank You
I ordered through doordash and got a sandwich that did not have cheese. I ordered the roast beef with cheese it's supposed to have bubbling melted cheese on it. When I called they said there was nothing they could do about it unless I came in. I wouldn't have had doordash if I could walk in because I am working. Very poor guest service.
Food: 1
I ordered a 14in pepperoni and sausage pizza and 6 trashed wings. When I got there, they said it would be 8 more minutes. It looked like they just took my order off of the printer when I arrived, even though I put my order in 20 minutes earlier. It was yesterday afternoon(Monday). When got home, I discovered the wings were not trashed, so I had to put in the air fryer to get them crispy. I then discovered the pizza tasted like the crust was yeasty which overpowered the flavor of everything else. It tasted as if the dough was from the day before. We usually have very tasty pizza from you all, but was disappointed this time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 3
I ordered the meat lovers pizza with green peppers, onions, and mushrooms online. I paid with my credit card. I drove to Pie O My Pizza to get my pizza and they said they didn’t have my order. They wanted proof and I opened my email and there was a message and it said they couldn’t honor my order. I then opened my text messages and it said they were out of stock and couldn't honor my order. With this information, the order taker said they could make the pizza with a 20 miinute wait. They were right on time with my pizza and I paid for it with the same credit card that I used on line. The big disappointment was the pizza itself and the almost $30.00 I paid for a 14”. The sauce was good with plenty of cheese and 6 large pepperonis and that is where it stopped. I couldn't find the bacon or ham. There was a small portion of sausage, maybe 8 slivers of green pepper and onion with no trace of mushrooms. The final disappointment was the topping didn't go to the edge but was 1 1/2”-2” from the edge. If you took the 1 1/2” to be conservative and subtracted it from the 14” all the way around, I got a 11” pizza for almost $30.00.
Don't think I will be back, to many problems.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
I’ve been going here off and on since they’ve opened. The owners a good dude from the local community. He used to own another bar/restaurant in the area.
Place has great pizza, food , and it’s local. Support local!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food! Great service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Read reviews and decided to try this place when I took family to six flags. The pizza here is absolutely amaxing!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tasty hand tossed pizza. Accommodated choices nicely, crust was light and crunchy but not overdone. Nice small business, small inside area to eat, had tables outside too. No bathroom but neighboring establishment has readily available. Will stop by again!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gluten Free Meat Lovers
The hand tossed crust is excellent! Beyond any expectations. Generous toppings and the provel, mozzarella blend is my personal favorite. We ordered sausage and pepperoni and it did not disappoint. Extra large pepperoni, and perfectly seasoned sausage. Can't wait to get back for another Pie!! This place is a gem.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Been here twice and excellent service, food, and value. Please support local.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Excellent Northeast style hand tossed pizza!
Everyone working was polite and nice. Well definitely go back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I could not detect even one drop of sauce. It was as if they slapped cheese and meat on dry, bland crust.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
First visit tonight but won't be our last. Really friendly staff! We ordered a 16" meat lovers hand tossed pizza that was so good.
Crust had an excellent crunch without being tough! It had strips of crispy bacon. Overall very good and we will be ordering again!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Lovers
Great mom & pop pizza joint. great pizza, quick and easy to order. Staff was great. They have a few tables outside, if you want to hang and enjoy a pizza with friends/family there.
The pizza I ordered came with good amount of toppings and the crust was thin and crispy
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread Bites
So let me tell you a story about a gluten free taco pizza and a guy who has celiac (surprise twist, the guy is me) I was having a good day. I'm recovering from a stem cell transplant that took place about about a year ago. The transplant was a success but recovery has been rough. It's been a very hard year. Originally the guy was from Iowa and they have a lovely taco pizza at the Casey's gas station (don't judge until you've had it anyway). Our guy learned he had celiac and thought he'd never again have a gluten free taco pizza. Fast forward 20 ish years and thhhhje guy is recovering from his stem cell transplant. It went perfectly, shout out Barnes Jewish Hospital but guy continues to suffer from GVHD. Back to today I made a fantastic breakfast because my blood sugar was good. I get to lunch and I'm feeling a grilled cheese sandwich with tomato bisque soup. I get my soup on, I go to get my bread.. mold.... Ok I'll figure something out. Then out of nowhere my head feels like it was dunked into a fishbowl. I check my pulse ox and heart rate knowing my heart rate is gonna be skyrocketing and sure enough it is but I see my pulse ox and it says 67 and I'm like surely that isn't right but yup 67 it is. I abandon my not bread sandwich and sit down I tell my partner and she calls my oncology team and they say call 911 and do whatever the ambulance says and I'm like ok. Ambulance gets there they don't take me and we go to the nearest ER shout out to Mercy South. Anyway the ER has food but nothing gluten free. Now it's like 7 or 8 and the kitchen is closed. I decide I'm gonna door dash and what do I find... A loc gluten free taco pizza. I'm so overjoyed that I bought the nursing staff some garlic bites (surprise twist number two they loved them) but alas no taco pizza there must have been a mistake on door dashes part. I contact them and they give me credit.. cool beans. I contact pie oh my Pizza and they recognized the order and saw where the mix up might have occured. At this point I believe the kitchen is closed and the oven is shut down but they're like no you wanted a gluten free taco pizza you're gonna to get a gluten free taco pizza. They fired up the ovens and made one of the greatest pizzas I've ever had in my entire life. So the best shout out o Chris Gurley and JoAnna Kinnison for bringing that place to life and whoever else worked tonight. They don't even have a delivery service one of their employees had to figure out what hospital and get it to me. That's above and beyond in my book. Bonus shout out to my man Ry an amazing nurses aide. During my recovery it's been an emotional and physical rollercoaster and people like Chris, JoAnna, Ry, Tosha (my nurse) and the other staff at Oh My Pizzza Pie and Mercy South that help me find my way through this.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: 10 Gluten-Free
Loading...