Her cakes are amazing! She did the cake for my wedding, and guests were raving not only over how beautiful the cake was, but also how delicious it was. I could not even get over how beautiful it was. She and her husband are super nice and wonderful to work with, and the cost is affordable, including the delivery cost. Our caterer dropped the ball, but her cake definitely picked up the slack. Our middle tier was red velvet and it was gone almost immediately after being cut. The other cut flavor was fudge marble and that went fast too. We are definitely savoring what was left down to the last crumb. I could not recommend her enough. I promise you, you will not regret ordering from her. Absolutely, amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Jennifer Rehmeier
Her cakes are amazing! She did the cake for my wedding, and guests were raving not only over how beautiful the cake was, but also how delicious it was. I could not even get over how beautiful it was. She and her husband are super nice and wonderful to work with, and the cost is affordable, including the delivery cost. Our caterer dropped the ball, but her cake definitely picked up the slack. Our middle tier was red velvet and it was gone almost immediately after being cut. The other cut flavor was fudge marble and that went fast too. We are definitely savoring what was left down to the last crumb. I could not recommend her enough. I promise you, you will not regret ordering from her. Absolutely, amazing!
Allison Wilson
She is an incredible artist who bakes delicious cakes! Her level of detail and precision is amazing! Her creations made a special event even more memorable. She and her husband are extremely nice people and easy to work with. I will use them again!
Kathy Landewee
Beautiful lace replicated from my daughter’s dress and the monogram she designed were masterfully put together in one amazing cake! To attest to the cake flavor…they ate it all and after the reception I had relatives asking for the extras!! Super easy to work with and even a tasting. Thanks Katie!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Brooke Homann
Seriously so delicious. Not only are the designs incredible, the cake actually tastes amazing. Rave reviews from all of our guests and we’re now trying to find an excuse to order more cake because the leftovers are gone…
Taylor Hendrix
Katie has done am amazing job on every cake she had made for us.
Hailey Mouser Gleason
Katie is absolutely amazing!!!! She made the wedding cake of our dreams, and I'm not just talking about looks! The cake was just as delicious as it looked. Super easy to work with and the cake tasting was everything and more. Do yourself and favor and book Katie! :)
Rebecca Hurst
We chose Fancy That Cake to do the cakes for our daughter's wedding. Katy created a drawing that she sent to the bride, and they tweaked it together to make it the perfect cake. She also worked with the groom to make the coolest groom's cake ever. We were able to go to a tasting to select flavors.When she delivered the cakes, people gathered around, and it was the talk of the wedding party until the event began. The main cake was a winter scene, incorporating the snowfall pattern of the bridal dress, and winter trees and mountains that were so detailed it was incredible. The groom is a duck hunter, and Katie made a cooler with a duck on top which was again, intricate in amazing detail.The cakes did not just look great, they also tasted amazing. Katie offers a wide variety of cake and icing flavors. She is a pleasure to work with and we would most definitely call her again.
taylor adams
I can not express enough how amazing she is!!! My husband and I got married a couple of months ago and she made the process painless! The cake was amazing. She can do just about anything and loves to do it too! My husband loves the board game Catan and she was able to make the game board come to life!! I will recommend her to everyone.
Taylor Moore
Fancy that cake did an amazing job on both cakes, absolutely loved them!! Thank you so much!
Katie did an amazing and wonderful job on our wedding cake. She is easy to talk to and always willing to answer any questions you may have. I showed her a picture of our wedding cake and she made it come to life. Worried about flavors?… DONT! I did a different layer on each tier plus had side cakes, they were phenomenal!!! My husband and I took some on our honeymoon to continue enjoying. YOU WILL NOT BE DISAPPOINTED :) thank you for everything Katie.
Alicia Irvin
She did our wedding and grooms cake! Exactly like the picture I showed her! The cakes tasty too!!
Brittany Dawson
Katie did an absolutely incredible job on my daughter’s 18th birthday cake. I wanted a sushi-themed cake and she created a cake that looked realistic and absolutely beautiful. The best part was that nobody could stop talking about how delicious it was, as well! I will definitely recommend Fancy That Cake to everyone I know! ❤️
David Rohr
Fancy that cake did a fantastic job on my wife’s and my cake for wedding back in 2017. She made an exact replica of my fathers semi truck for my grooms cake. So if anyone want a cake that looks like something give fancy that cake a call and she will be able to make it come to life from your brain.?????
Laura Findlay
Fancy That Cake made our wedding cake and a jumbo birthday cupcake. They were both perfect in their own essence and tasted delicious. I'm not a huge cake fan because I don't like frosting... but that's not the case here, perfectly balanced!
Her cakes are amazing! She did the cake for my wedding, and guests were raving not only over how beautiful the cake was, but also how delicious it was. I could not even get over how beautiful it was. She and her husband are super nice and wonderful to work with, and the cost is affordable, including the delivery cost. Our caterer dropped the ball, but her cake definitely picked up the slack. Our middle tier was red velvet and it was gone almost immediately after being cut. The other cut flavor was fudge marble and that went fast too. We are definitely savoring what was left down to the last crumb. I could not recommend her enough. I promise you, you will not regret ordering from her. Absolutely, amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Her cakes are amazing! She did the cake for my wedding, and guests were raving not only over how beautiful the cake was, but also how delicious it was. I could not even get over how beautiful it was. She and her husband are super nice and wonderful to work with, and the cost is affordable, including the delivery cost. Our caterer dropped the ball, but her cake definitely picked up the slack. Our middle tier was red velvet and it was gone almost immediately after being cut. The other cut flavor was fudge marble and that went fast too. We are definitely savoring what was left down to the last crumb. I could not recommend her enough. I promise you, you will not regret ordering from her. Absolutely, amazing!
She is an incredible artist who bakes delicious cakes! Her level of detail and precision is amazing! Her creations made a special event even more memorable. She and her husband are extremely nice people and easy to work with. I will use them again!
Beautiful lace replicated from my daughter’s dress and the monogram she designed were masterfully put together in one amazing cake! To attest to the cake flavor…they ate it all and after the reception I had relatives asking for the extras!! Super easy to work with and even a tasting. Thanks Katie!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Seriously so delicious. Not only are the designs incredible, the cake actually tastes amazing. Rave reviews from all of our guests and we’re now trying to find an excuse to order more cake because the leftovers are gone…
Katie has done am amazing job on every cake she had made for us.
Katie is absolutely amazing!!!! She made the wedding cake of our dreams, and I'm not just talking about looks! The cake was just as delicious as it looked. Super easy to work with and the cake tasting was everything and more. Do yourself and favor and book Katie! :)
We chose Fancy That Cake to do the cakes for our daughter's wedding. Katy created a drawing that she sent to the bride, and they tweaked it together to make it the perfect cake. She also worked with the groom to make the coolest groom's cake ever. We were able to go to a tasting to select flavors.When she delivered the cakes, people gathered around, and it was the talk of the wedding party until the event began. The main cake was a winter scene, incorporating the snowfall pattern of the bridal dress, and winter trees and mountains that were so detailed it was incredible. The groom is a duck hunter, and Katie made a cooler with a duck on top which was again, intricate in amazing detail.The cakes did not just look great, they also tasted amazing. Katie offers a wide variety of cake and icing flavors. She is a pleasure to work with and we would most definitely call her again.
I can not express enough how amazing she is!!! My husband and I got married a couple of months ago and she made the process painless! The cake was amazing. She can do just about anything and loves to do it too! My husband loves the board game Catan and she was able to make the game board come to life!! I will recommend her to everyone.
Fancy that cake did an amazing job on both cakes, absolutely loved them!! Thank you so much!
Restaurantji Recommends
Katie did an amazing and wonderful job on our wedding cake. She is easy to talk to and always willing to answer any questions you may have. I showed her a picture of our wedding cake and she made it come to life. Worried about flavors?… DONT! I did a different layer on each tier plus had side cakes, they were phenomenal!!! My husband and I took some on our honeymoon to continue enjoying. YOU WILL NOT BE DISAPPOINTED :) thank you for everything Katie.
She did our wedding and grooms cake! Exactly like the picture I showed her! The cakes tasty too!!
Katie did an absolutely incredible job on my daughter’s 18th birthday cake. I wanted a sushi-themed cake and she created a cake that looked realistic and absolutely beautiful. The best part was that nobody could stop talking about how delicious it was, as well! I will definitely recommend Fancy That Cake to everyone I know! ❤️
Fancy that cake did a fantastic job on my wife’s and my cake for wedding back in 2017. She made an exact replica of my fathers semi truck for my grooms cake. So if anyone want a cake that looks like something give fancy that cake a call and she will be able to make it come to life from your brain.?????
Fancy That Cake made our wedding cake and a jumbo birthday cupcake. They were both perfect in their own essence and tasted delicious. I'm not a huge cake fan because I don't like frosting... but that's not the case here, perfectly balanced!
Loading...