I went in the other day with an idea that I drew up for my son’s 5th birthday and they took my idea and made it even better than I imagined it! I wish I could share a picture of it on this review! I 100% recommend not only did it look good but the taste was on point as well. Thank you Eileen’s colossal cookies!
Sara Shockey
So so happy with my nieces graduation cookies! The UMKC cookies are her absolute favorite!
Corey Crystal Huskey
With the past weekend being busy with graduations I didn't know if Eileen's would be able to make my cookies order. They were able to make them just in time for my grandson's bday party.
Caitie Christian
I had dropped the ball on getting cookies for my book club party. I called them at 10am to see if could just pick some up. Then asked if by chance they could add book club or books on the cookies. They said they could and it was no problem. I went to get them at 2pm and they went above and beyond what I had expected. Everyone loved the cookies and thought they were so cute. I would highly recommend them!
Recommended dishes: Fresh Sugar Cookies
Caitie Christian
I had dropped the ball on getting cookies for my book club party. I called them at 10am to see if could just pick some up. Then asked if by chance they could add book club or books on the cookies. They said they could and it was no problem. I went to get them at 2pm and they went above and beyond what I had expected. Everyone loved the cookies and thought they were so cute. I would highly recommend them!
Joy Sullivan
Best cookies it's topping cumble
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Katey Carr
Ordered cookies for my daughter’s birthday and they were a hit! Delicious as always and decorated to match the theme perfectly! Will definitely be ordering for more birthdays to come!
Lily Williams
My cookie cake was absolutely disgusting, the cookie was crumbly and dry, and none of the icing stuck to the cake. as we cut it all the icing fell off. don’t even get me started on the design it looked absolutely awful and didn’t look anything like we asked. this cake was for a 19th birthday, looked like it was for a 5 year old. I do not recommend ordering from here ever. and I will not be back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Shawn Patrick
Went up the day before a birthday and needed a cookie cake bad!! They decorated it and made it look awesome all the same-day!!!! Great staff, awesome cookies, just a great group of people!!!! Stop by give those cookies a try.....might be your new favorite!!????
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookie Cake, Birthday Cake
Holly Morris
They have a good veriety to choose from. The PB & snickerdoodle were moist and flavorful. My friend devoured the chocolate chip. Great place to treat yourself.
These are some of the best cookies I have tasted. I usually can’t eat a lot of icing but with that lemon cookie I definitely can! Their designs are always adorable and well done! The staff is always friendly and ready to help too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sharon Fiene
I highly recommend Eileen’s cookies. I’ve tried a variety, most recently the iced sugar cookies. Amazing!
I congratulate the new owners Josh and Sheri Crawford. They are big community supporters and so friendly.
Eileen’s Colossal Cookies and J&S Pizza. The best!
Tegan Marasco
I don’t know how they do it- but every time we order a cookie cake, my kids will request some off the wall themed design - and their artistic abilities blow me away! Like a dog with spots and flowers- best spotted floral dog I’ve ever seen! One year we requested a cookie cake with tropical birds- and it was absolutely gorgeous! A few years back we attended a cookie eating contest at Eileen’s, and even though we didn’t win — it was SO MUCH FUN! But our favorite memory of Eileen’s was the scavenger hunt in Liberty and my kids found the hidden cookie! We scored free cookies for a year!!! Eileen’s is our favorite cookie place and I was even more excited to hear they are under new management with The Crawford’s! They are a well known family here in Liberty that always give back to the community and support our schools and local organizations! Highly recommend!!!
Seth Baldwin
Great cookies!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! You must try if you have not.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sarah Morerod
Our family loves this bakery, we found them at a pumpkin patch near our house and immediately got addicted. We recently ordered custom cookies for our anniversary, and they turned out perfect!
I went in the other day with an idea that I drew up for my son’s 5th birthday and they took my idea and made it even better than I imagined it! I wish I could share a picture of it on this review! I 100% recommend not only did it look good but the taste was on point as well. Thank you Eileen’s colossal cookies!
So so happy with my nieces graduation cookies! The UMKC cookies are her absolute favorite!
With the past weekend being busy with graduations I didn't know if Eileen's would be able to make my cookies order. They were able to make them just in time for my grandson's bday party.
I had dropped the ball on getting cookies for my book club party. I called them at 10am to see if could just pick some up. Then asked if by chance they could add book club or books on the cookies. They said they could and it was no problem. I went to get them at 2pm and they went above and beyond what I had expected. Everyone loved the cookies and thought they were so cute. I would highly recommend them!
Recommended dishes: Fresh Sugar Cookies
I had dropped the ball on getting cookies for my book club party. I called them at 10am to see if could just pick some up. Then asked if by chance they could add book club or books on the cookies. They said they could and it was no problem. I went to get them at 2pm and they went above and beyond what I had expected. Everyone loved the cookies and thought they were so cute. I would highly recommend them!
Best cookies it's topping cumble
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Ordered cookies for my daughter’s birthday and they were a hit! Delicious as always and decorated to match the theme perfectly! Will definitely be ordering for more birthdays to come!
My cookie cake was absolutely disgusting, the cookie was crumbly and dry, and none of the icing stuck to the cake. as we cut it all the icing fell off. don’t even get me started on the design it looked absolutely awful and didn’t look anything like we asked. this cake was for a 19th birthday, looked like it was for a 5 year old. I do not recommend ordering from here ever. and I will not be back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Went up the day before a birthday and needed a cookie cake bad!! They decorated it and made it look awesome all the same-day!!!! Great staff, awesome cookies, just a great group of people!!!! Stop by give those cookies a try.....might be your new favorite!!????
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookie Cake, Birthday Cake
They have a good veriety to choose from. The PB & snickerdoodle were moist and flavorful. My friend devoured the chocolate chip. Great place to treat yourself.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Restaurantji Recommends
These are some of the best cookies I have tasted. I usually can’t eat a lot of icing but with that lemon cookie I definitely can! Their designs are always adorable and well done! The staff is always friendly and ready to help too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I highly recommend Eileen’s cookies. I’ve tried a variety, most recently the iced sugar cookies. Amazing! I congratulate the new owners Josh and Sheri Crawford. They are big community supporters and so friendly. Eileen’s Colossal Cookies and J&S Pizza. The best!
I don’t know how they do it- but every time we order a cookie cake, my kids will request some off the wall themed design - and their artistic abilities blow me away! Like a dog with spots and flowers- best spotted floral dog I’ve ever seen! One year we requested a cookie cake with tropical birds- and it was absolutely gorgeous! A few years back we attended a cookie eating contest at Eileen’s, and even though we didn’t win — it was SO MUCH FUN! But our favorite memory of Eileen’s was the scavenger hunt in Liberty and my kids found the hidden cookie! We scored free cookies for a year!!! Eileen’s is our favorite cookie place and I was even more excited to hear they are under new management with The Crawford’s! They are a well known family here in Liberty that always give back to the community and support our schools and local organizations! Highly recommend!!!
Great cookies!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! You must try if you have not.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Our family loves this bakery, we found them at a pumpkin patch near our house and immediately got addicted. We recently ordered custom cookies for our anniversary, and they turned out perfect!
Loading...