Super cute ship with a wide variety of pies. Highly recommend the pecan pie.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sarah Hackman
Purchased three pies (lemon, Dutch apple, pecan) which were all delicious! Brought them to a barbecue/picnic and the lovely woman was kind enough to put the lemon pie on ice for me so it would be perfect after a long drive. They were so kind to call to check on the pickup time. Highly recommend to anyone in the area!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
J Boren
Got coconut cream and gooseberry. Very good. I had self-inflicted pick up issues. Despite that, the service and customer support was stellar.
Food: 5
Service: 5
John J
My first visit to Pie Time was a delightful experience overall! It’s a nice little shop with a warm and inviting atmosphere. The young blonde girl working there was incredibly nice and friendly, which really added to the positive vibe. The pie I chose was absolutely delicious, and I could tell it was made with high-quality ingredients. The flavor was fantastic, and it was clear that a lot of care went into its creation. However, there were a couple of minor drawbacks. For its size, the pie seemed quite expensive. Also, the selection of individual slices was limited, which meant I had to purchase a whole pie. This pie was in the freezer, and there wasn't any indication of when it was made or how long it had been stored. Thankfully, the employee was very helpful and provided clear instructions on how to thaw it before eating, which was much appreciated. It would be even more convenient if those thawing instructions (and prepared date) were printed directly on a label on the pie's container. Despite these small issues, I would still recommend Pie Time. It’s a lovely spot to visit if you're willing to spend a bit more for a truly delicious, high-quality pie.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amy Sheets Konkle
Take and bake chicken pot pie is a new favorite. We're also big fans of key lime, lemon icebox, and cowboy cookies!
Ashley Carter
If you haven’t bought a pie from here , do it! They have take and bake, savory, sweet, and mini pies. It’s AMAZING.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Specialty Pies, Sheet Cake
Cassidy Lowry
The crust on every pie is beyond perfect deliciousness. We have enjoyed many different options, including cherry, coconut cream, chicken pot pie, broccoli and cheddar quiche, chocolate hand pies, mini key lime, pecan, Rice Krispie treats, and more! Each item has been packed with the freshest ingredients and the creativity in selecting flavors that are complementary to each of the boxes is always outstanding. The kindness and enthusiasm in getting my order just right is always evident when I place it. In person, on line or by phone, I am always treated like a friend. I have referred many others as well as gifted items that have been loved by all that receive them. The talent and care that go into baking and creating each dish is tasted in every bite. The service is fantastic as well. Place an order - you won’t regret it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hand Pies
Blythe Bots
Listen. I couldn't sleep last night because I wanted rhubarb crumble and the stars aligned today. I was driving and saw a sign that said "Pie" slammed the brakes, parked, and walked out with the rhubarb crumble pie. I'm enjoying it right now and I'm already concerned about how soon I'll be able to buy it again. I live in a two person household and I don't think this will last another 24hrs because it's so delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Shelley Punzo
I bought a cherry pie today. It is fabulous! The crust is so flaky and we can really taste the almond flavoring. Best cherry pie I think I’ve ever had. My husband loved it just as much.
Our Godfather was in town for his birthday and requested a Dutch Apple Pie. Pie Time came highly recommended and so we ordered a Dutch Apple Pie from them. He said as he’s taking bites each time how amazing the pie was and that we should keep ordering them for him when he comes. Sounds like we will be regulars! Thanks for the love and time put into his pie that he enjoyed each bite.
We will be returning 🫶
Jusbnlee
I ordered a butterscotch pie and it was small and did not taste at all like butterscotch, I was very disappointed for a $30 pie.. I hate writing reviews that aren’t nice but I feel totally ripped off! I won’t be going back and I’m still on the hunt for a good butterscotch pie!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 5
Cathy Varnell
Great place! I make it a tradition to get my son-in-law his favorite pie from here for Father’s Day. Highly recommend Pie Time!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Specialty Pies
Jeff Hammond
It's a cute little shop just off Liberty Square. The service was pleasant, and the selections were good. We ended up with a chicken pot pie, a broccoli and cheddar quiche, and a desert sample box. We are currently devouring the chicken pot pie. The crust is flaky and light, the carrots are fresh. I think you get the point and I need another slice. We will be back!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Specialty Pies, Cookie
Lisa Owens
Pie Time is an experience that reminds me of my childhood. It is a bakery that cares more about customer service & quality of product than they do about social media approval. This holiday season was full of rave reviews for the pies I purchased from Pie Time. Perfect crusts & perfect flavor. My new go-to establishment for pies!
Super cute ship with a wide variety of pies. Highly recommend the pecan pie.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Purchased three pies (lemon, Dutch apple, pecan) which were all delicious! Brought them to a barbecue/picnic and the lovely woman was kind enough to put the lemon pie on ice for me so it would be perfect after a long drive. They were so kind to call to check on the pickup time. Highly recommend to anyone in the area!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Got coconut cream and gooseberry. Very good. I had self-inflicted pick up issues. Despite that, the service and customer support was stellar.
Food: 5
Service: 5
My first visit to Pie Time was a delightful experience overall! It’s a nice little shop with a warm and inviting atmosphere. The young blonde girl working there was incredibly nice and friendly, which really added to the positive vibe. The pie I chose was absolutely delicious, and I could tell it was made with high-quality ingredients. The flavor was fantastic, and it was clear that a lot of care went into its creation. However, there were a couple of minor drawbacks. For its size, the pie seemed quite expensive. Also, the selection of individual slices was limited, which meant I had to purchase a whole pie. This pie was in the freezer, and there wasn't any indication of when it was made or how long it had been stored. Thankfully, the employee was very helpful and provided clear instructions on how to thaw it before eating, which was much appreciated. It would be even more convenient if those thawing instructions (and prepared date) were printed directly on a label on the pie's container. Despite these small issues, I would still recommend Pie Time. It’s a lovely spot to visit if you're willing to spend a bit more for a truly delicious, high-quality pie.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Take and bake chicken pot pie is a new favorite. We're also big fans of key lime, lemon icebox, and cowboy cookies!
If you haven’t bought a pie from here , do it!
They have take and bake, savory, sweet, and mini pies. It’s AMAZING.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Specialty Pies, Sheet Cake
The crust on every pie is beyond perfect deliciousness. We have enjoyed many different options, including cherry, coconut cream, chicken pot pie, broccoli and cheddar quiche, chocolate hand pies, mini key lime, pecan, Rice Krispie treats, and more! Each item has been packed with the freshest ingredients and the creativity in selecting flavors that are complementary to each of the boxes is always outstanding. The kindness and enthusiasm in getting my order just right is always evident when I place it. In person, on line or by phone, I am always treated like a friend. I have referred many others as well as gifted items that have been loved by all that receive them. The talent and care that go into baking and creating each dish is tasted in every bite. The service is fantastic as well. Place an order - you won’t regret it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hand Pies
Listen. I couldn't sleep last night because I wanted rhubarb crumble and the stars aligned today.
I was driving and saw a sign that said "Pie" slammed the brakes, parked, and walked out with the rhubarb crumble pie. I'm enjoying it right now and I'm already concerned about how soon I'll be able to buy it again. I live in a two person household and I don't think this will last another 24hrs because it's so delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I bought a cherry pie today. It is fabulous! The crust is so flaky and we can really taste the almond flavoring. Best cherry pie I think I’ve ever had. My husband loved it just as much.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Best chicken pot pie I’ve ever had!
Restaurantji Recommends
Our Godfather was in town for his birthday and requested a Dutch Apple Pie. Pie Time came highly recommended and so we ordered a Dutch Apple Pie from them. He said as he’s taking bites each time how amazing the pie was and that we should keep ordering them for him when he comes. Sounds like we will be regulars! Thanks for the love and time put into his pie that he enjoyed each bite. We will be returning 🫶
I ordered a butterscotch pie and it was small and did not taste at all like butterscotch, I was very disappointed for a $30 pie.. I hate writing reviews that aren’t nice but I feel totally ripped off! I won’t be going back and I’m still on the hunt for a good butterscotch pie!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 5
Great place! I make it a tradition to get my son-in-law his favorite pie from here for Father’s Day. Highly recommend Pie Time!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Specialty Pies
It's a cute little shop just off Liberty Square. The service was pleasant, and the selections were good. We ended up with a chicken pot pie, a broccoli and cheddar quiche, and a desert sample box. We are currently devouring the chicken pot pie. The crust is flaky and light, the carrots are fresh. I think you get the point and I need another slice. We will be back!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Specialty Pies, Cookie
Pie Time is an experience that reminds me of my childhood. It is a bakery that cares more about customer service & quality of product than they do about social media approval. This holiday season was full of rave reviews for the pies I purchased from Pie Time. Perfect crusts & perfect flavor. My new go-to establishment for pies!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Specialty Pies, Apple Pie
Loading...