We ordered a cake and 2 dozen donuts for a baptism celebration. The bakery did a great job and had it ready to go for us at pick up!
Emmanuel Stergen
The staff is friendly and helpful. They made a special order gooey butter cake for the holidays. I enjoy their coffee and donuts anytime.
Raging Deeds
Today was our first visit and it was amazing! We ordered two lattes, donuts and a s’mores pop tart for under 25$. Staff was extremely friendly and gave some excellent recommendations. If you come please try the s’mores pop tart! We will be back for more!
Logan Dexter
I’ve been here twice now. The first time we came in late morning and were out of a majority of items. What I had was really good so I got up extra early to go again. At 8:30 am they were out of everything in the case. It’s crazy being out of everything 1.5 hours into a weekday. This isn’t a close drive to me so I can’t keep coming when there isn’t anything to buy, unfortunately.
Casey Garcia
I’m excited about the new ownership bringing homemade, quality ingredients to the area!
Logan Northrup
Great service and good food
Lia Ploesser
New Melle Baking Company made my son’s first birthday so special! The custom cakes were absolutely perfect, beautifully designed, delicious, and exactly what we had hoped for. One of the biggest highlights was how accommodating they were with my son’s egg allergy. They went the extra mile to find a recipe so he could have his own egg-free smash cake, which meant the world to us!
Elizabeth was fantastic to work with, so kind, responsive, and detail-oriented. She made the entire process seamless and stress-free. Our guests couldn’t stop raving about how amazing everything looked and tasted. If you’re looking for a bakery that truly cares about their customers and delivers both gorgeous and delicious cakes, I highly recommend New Melle Baking Company. We will definitely be back for future celebrations! Thank you for making Wyatt’s first birthday so special!
Lia Ploesser
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
New Melle Baking Company made my son’s first birthday so special! The custom cakes were absolutely perfect, beautifully designed, delicious, and exactly what we had hoped for. One of the biggest highlights was how accommodating they were with my son’s egg allergy. They went the extra mile to find a recipe so he could have his own egg-free smash cake, which meant the world to us!
Elizabeth was fantastic to work with, so kind, responsive, and detail-oriented. She made the entire process seamless and stress-free. Our guests couldn’t stop raving about how amazing everything looked and tasted. If you’re looking for a bakery that truly cares about their customers and delivers both gorgeous and delicious cakes, I highly recommend New Melle Baking Company. We will definitely be back for future celebrations! Thank you for making Wyatt’s first birthday so special!
Ashley Kelly
New Melle Baking Company is a true gem, offering not only delicious baked goods but also exceptional customer service. Our experience was outstanding, with Julie providing warm and friendly service. We appreciated the opportunity to chat with her and felt right at home. Our girls enjoyed the welcoming atmosphere, and we stocked up on a variety of goodies, including sourdough bread, coffee, sandwiches, sourdough cookies made without artificial dyes, and donuts. I highly recommend visiting New Melle Bakery, where you will be treated like family. We cannot wait to return ❤️❤️
Brittany Murphy
I stopped in Friday (Valentines day) to see what kind of treats they had. I ended up getting an amazing cookie cake and a couple of cake pops! They were delicious.
I also met Erin and she was the sweetest! You can tell she truly cares about her community and customers!
We used their services for our daughter's wedding in Defiance. I ordered four 1/4 sheet cakes and one 6" round. Elizabeth is so talented in baking and decorating the cakes. She made all the flavors I asked for and they all were so moist, delicious, fresh and flavorful! The buttercream frosting is most delicious! The vanilla almond cake with dark cherry filling could be called cherry pie cake! Vanilla with strawberry filling went fast, and chocolate cake with raspberry was so fantastic, chocolate with cookies and cream was our daughter's favorite and chocolate with espresso butter cream was so very rich and decadent. All cakes were moist and exceptional in flavor and decoration!
Also their coffee cake is outstanding! Breakfast sandwiches and breakfast casserole are very good as well. We live an hour away in Illinois and will drive to enjoy this bakery, they are that good!
I highly recommend this business!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ashley Long
Great quality and customer service!! Thankful to find this local gem!! We will be back for more!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kyle Schramm
The owner was so wonderful and helpful. AMAZING jelly donuts. My wife loved her cream cheese Danish. 50/10, would recommend to everyone that enjoys pastries, coffee, and the like. Will definitely be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lauren Tripp
Amazing experience! We have ordered from the bakery for the past 3 years for our annual business event. We have always been happy with our orders throughout each owner. This year was amazing!!!! We asked what they could do, any suggestions and they had great ideas: we did cake pops, mini apple pies & pumpkin pies (AMAZING!!!!!) and our normal chicken salad sandwich bites which we requested and they accommodated above & beyond. This year they were truly phenomenal! Hands down the best we have had out of many of our catered deserts and events. Thank you New Melle Baking Company, look forward to more orders! —Aisling Med Spa
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lauren Tripp
Amazing experience! We have ordered from the bakery for the past 3 years for our annual business event. We have always been happy with our orders. This year was amazing!!!! We asked what they could do, any suggestions and we did cake pops, mini apple pies & pumpkin pies (AMAZING!!!!!) and our normal chicken salad sandwich bites. This year they were truly phenomenal! Hands down the best we have had out of many of our catered deserts. Thank you New Melle Baking Company! -Aisling Med Spa
We ordered a cake and 2 dozen donuts for a baptism celebration. The bakery did a great job and had it ready to go for us at pick up!
The staff is friendly and helpful. They made a special order gooey butter cake for the holidays. I enjoy their coffee and donuts anytime.
Today was our first visit and it was amazing! We ordered two lattes, donuts and a s’mores pop tart for under 25$. Staff was extremely friendly and gave some excellent recommendations. If you come please try the s’mores pop tart! We will be back for more!
I’ve been here twice now. The first time we came in late morning and were out of a majority of items. What I had was really good so I got up extra early to go again. At 8:30 am they were out of everything in the case. It’s crazy being out of everything 1.5 hours into a weekday. This isn’t a close drive to me so I can’t keep coming when there isn’t anything to buy, unfortunately.
I’m excited about the new ownership bringing homemade, quality ingredients to the area!
Great service and good food
New Melle Baking Company made my son’s first birthday so special! The custom cakes were absolutely perfect, beautifully designed, delicious, and exactly what we had hoped for. One of the biggest highlights was how accommodating they were with my son’s egg allergy. They went the extra mile to find a recipe so he could have his own egg-free smash cake, which meant the world to us!
Elizabeth was fantastic to work with, so kind, responsive, and detail-oriented. She made the entire process seamless and stress-free. Our guests couldn’t stop raving about how amazing everything looked and tasted. If you’re looking for a bakery that truly cares about their customers and delivers both gorgeous and delicious cakes, I highly recommend New Melle Baking Company. We will definitely be back for future celebrations! Thank you for making Wyatt’s first birthday so special!
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ New Melle Baking Company made my son’s first birthday so special! The custom cakes were absolutely perfect, beautifully designed, delicious, and exactly what we had hoped for. One of the biggest highlights was how accommodating they were with my son’s egg allergy. They went the extra mile to find a recipe so he could have his own egg-free smash cake, which meant the world to us! Elizabeth was fantastic to work with, so kind, responsive, and detail-oriented. She made the entire process seamless and stress-free. Our guests couldn’t stop raving about how amazing everything looked and tasted. If you’re looking for a bakery that truly cares about their customers and delivers both gorgeous and delicious cakes, I highly recommend New Melle Baking Company. We will definitely be back for future celebrations! Thank you for making Wyatt’s first birthday so special!
New Melle Baking Company is a true gem, offering not only delicious baked goods but also exceptional customer service. Our experience was outstanding, with Julie providing warm and friendly service. We appreciated the opportunity to chat with her and felt right at home. Our girls enjoyed the welcoming atmosphere, and we stocked up on a variety of goodies, including sourdough bread, coffee, sandwiches, sourdough cookies made without artificial dyes, and donuts. I highly recommend visiting New Melle Bakery, where you will be treated like family. We cannot wait to return ❤️❤️
I stopped in Friday (Valentines day) to see what kind of treats they had. I ended up getting an amazing cookie cake and a couple of cake pops! They were delicious.
I also met Erin and she was the sweetest! You can tell she truly cares about her community and customers!
Restaurantji Recommends
We used their services for our daughter's wedding in Defiance. I ordered four 1/4 sheet cakes and one 6" round. Elizabeth is so talented in baking and decorating the cakes. She made all the flavors I asked for and they all were so moist, delicious, fresh and flavorful! The buttercream frosting is most delicious! The vanilla almond cake with dark cherry filling could be called cherry pie cake! Vanilla with strawberry filling went fast, and chocolate cake with raspberry was so fantastic, chocolate with cookies and cream was our daughter's favorite and chocolate with espresso butter cream was so very rich and decadent. All cakes were moist and exceptional in flavor and decoration!
Also their coffee cake is outstanding! Breakfast sandwiches and breakfast casserole are very good as well. We live an hour away in Illinois and will drive to enjoy this bakery, they are that good!
I highly recommend this business!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great quality and customer service!! Thankful to find this local gem!! We will be back for more!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The owner was so wonderful and helpful. AMAZING jelly donuts. My wife loved her cream cheese Danish. 50/10, would recommend to everyone that enjoys pastries, coffee, and the like. Will definitely be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing experience! We have ordered from the bakery for the past 3 years for our annual business event. We have always been happy with our orders throughout each owner. This year was amazing!!!! We asked what they could do, any suggestions and they had great ideas: we did cake pops, mini apple pies & pumpkin pies (AMAZING!!!!!) and our normal chicken salad sandwich bites which we requested and they accommodated above & beyond. This year they were truly phenomenal! Hands down the best we have had out of many of our catered deserts and events. Thank you New Melle Baking Company, look forward to more orders!
—Aisling Med Spa
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing experience! We have ordered from the bakery for the past 3 years for our annual business event. We have always been happy with our orders. This year was amazing!!!! We asked what they could do, any suggestions and we did cake pops, mini apple pies & pumpkin pies (AMAZING!!!!!) and our normal chicken salad sandwich bites. This year they were truly phenomenal! Hands down the best we have had out of many of our catered deserts. Thank you New Melle Baking Company! -Aisling Med Spa
Loading...