New Melle Baking Company
30 W Hwy D, New Melle
(636) 673-3514
Customers' Favorites
Custom Cakes
Doughnut
Cookies
Cupcake
Donuts
Menu
Photos
+15 photos
+14 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Today was our first visit and it was amazing! We ordered two lattes, donuts and a s’mores pop tart for under 25$. Staff was extremely friendly and gave some excellent recommendations. If you come please try the s’mores pop tart! We will be back for more!
I’ve been here twice now. The first time we came in late morning and were out of a majority of items. What I had was really good so I got up extra early to go again. At 8:30 am they were out of everything in the case. It’s crazy being out of everything 1.5 hours into a weekday. This isn’t a close drive to me so I can’t keep coming when there isn’t anything to buy, unfortunately.
New Melle Baking Company made my son’s first birthday so special! The custom cakes were absolutely perfect, beautifully designed, delicious, and exactly what we had hoped for. One of the biggest highlights was how accommodating they were with my son’s egg allergy. They went the extra mile to find a recipe so he could have his own egg-free smash cake, which meant the world to us!
Elizabeth was fantastic to work with, so kind, responsive, and detail-oriented....
Elizabeth was fantastic to work with, so kind, responsive, and detail-oriented....
You May Also Like
Maracas - 4600 State Hwy Z
![]()
Mexican, Vegetarian
Quarry Wine Garden - 3960 State Hwy Z
![]()
Wine Bar, American, Music Venues, Pet Friendly, Vegetarian