Jersey Mike's Subs

2508 State Hwy K, O'Fallon
(636) 294-8900

Recent Reviews

Sort by
John Krajewski

Great Roast Beef and Provolone Sandwich, loaded with meat and toppings. My wife got the Italian and it was delicious as usual. I’ve ordered dozens of times and every order has been accurate and well made and on time.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sir-Mittler

Thanks Jersey Mike's you guys make an awesome sandwich. And you catered to my custom sandwich which really impressed me. Thank you for your hospitality, awesome atmosphere and all out. Good times.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

A Google User

workers felt very stand offish and i didn’t feel welcome to order when it was my turn

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 1

Cordula Hostetter

Always the best! You guys are awesome!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Steve Spin

This place always makes me regret coming here. I keep giving it a shot because I love Jersey mikes but I always leave upset from this location. They are not friendly and always upset when you ask for a slight modification or if you don’t get it mikes way they look at you with disgust.
The management is very cut throat and rude to their employees, she is not friendly to the customers either.
I have even heard employees talking bad about her when she isn’t there.
Stay away if you don’t want your day ruined.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Sierra Wickenhauser

As great as my sandwich was, I can safely say I will never be back, at least not to this location. I went in with my infant who has a severe milk and egg allergy. I kindly asked if they would mind changing their gloves as I noticed they wore the same gloves for every sandwich. The young man (who was training) was very kind and had no issue. The woman training him asked me what the allergy was to which I again said milk and egg. She states “we do not have any egg product” (which is untrue as they have mayonnaise but whatever) and can’t guarantee 100% milk free as they use the same slicer for cheese and meat, but offered to wipe the machine down. I said that would be perfect to which she responded multiple times asking me “how serious the allergy actually is” and if we “really need to clean the machine or if it’s just a minor allergy”. We should have just walked out the door when we started being questioned but we stayed. Once we got to the register I heard her talking with the young man about people with allergies and how they can make things difficult and to just go with what they say. Not only was I made to feel like an inconvenience for making sure my child could safely eat her lunch but it does not matter how severe someone’s allergy is. If there is an allergy all things should be done to help prevent any contamination and people shouldn’t be interrogated. I understand maybe it was an off day, or maybe it wasn’t meant to come off any certain type of way but allergies are serious and if I can’t feel safe offering my child a sandwich because it takes a couple extra steps I will not return.

Food: 5

Service: 1

Beth Sansoucie

We came in this evening with a pretty big order but one of our sandwiches is for someone with a severe dairy allergy, he can die from dairy. It's pretty scary! The guy taking out order said he was going to have to clean the deli/cheese machine completely and it will take a while and we said we would wait however long it would take. He was very kind and didn't seem annoyed at the extra work he had to do. We felt soooo bad but he didn't make us feel like we were burdening him at all! Too notch service!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Harvey Farkwire

The sandwich was incredible as usual! My advice...get in on the rewards program. Our bill was $29+. We paid $9.00. Can't beat it.
Never had a bad sandwich.
They serve Pepsi products.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ross Adams

I didn't appreciate having to tell people multiple times how to make my order just for them to acknowledge then mess it up. Once I pointed it out, the employee that kept messing up insisted he could not hear me. Maybe if the music was not blasting and people were not goofing off, they would.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Yuri Woods

If they would toast the sandwiches, this would be my absolute favorite. until then, firehouse will be my favorite

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Jim Walsh III

Some of the best subs in the industry.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

jimmie cottrell

Sandwiches are always 🔥

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Carmen Iacono

Giving a 5 regardless , but managers need to teach new kids there is a such thing as TOO MUCH oil all but had the bread ruined before I got home with our sandwiches.

Josh Downing

I told the guy I wanted Gf bun for my order and they took care not to cross contaminate my order. I have missed getting a Philly cheese and now that I know this place sells GF bun I will be back.

Rhonda Hart

Excellent service. The whole staff showed attention to detail and was efficient and pleasant.

Loading...