Amazing service and incredibly accommodating! I wish I could remember who helped me, but my husband will be really excited about waking up to his favorite key lime pie on his birthday! Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bret B.
Dedicated to making people smile with delicious pies, cakes & cookies. Next door to the outstanding Sugarfire Barbecue. I loved the oatmeal cream pie $4 and apple pie $4. Pricy but really good. The vibe is like going to visit your friends that like to bake. Extra bonus: free coffee that is good
Melinda Campbell
This was our first visit to Sugarfire Pie and it will not be our last!!! The atmosphere is unique and inviting. The staff was friendly and knowledgeable. I walked in expecting to spend $20 on 2-3 items, but walked out away spending $20 on 5 items. Our experience from start to finish exceed my expectations!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jason Smith
Guess it was a sign ? riding down olive heading home G7 started going CRAZY FROM SUGAR DROPPED FROM 100TO 60 in 15 minutes. COMPLEX IS PACKED WITH THINGS TO DO &
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Freshly Made Pie
Claire Tessier
Cobbler was great!! It was a bit overpriced for what it was.
Betty Sullivan
The caramel is so good and the owner is such a nice woman. We are visiting from out of town and she gave plenty of advice. If you're in the area definitely stop by cause it is a great spot to get a treat.
Tamika Staten
The staff were great! Super helpful and attentive. There’s only about 5 options for pie, so I ordered the apple pie. It wasn’t very good. I’ll go back and try something else.
Solodad
Best piece of apple pie I have had east of the rockies.
Al Molitor
Great service, delicious pies.
Chip Folendore
The bakery for Sugarfire Smokehouse. You can eat inside as well. Wonderful.
Overall rating: 4/5 Wait: 5/5 Arrival time: Wednesday 1pm Food: 3.5/5 Order: key lime pie, strawberry cheesecake, sugarfire Pies are a bit too sweet for my taste Service: 4.5/5 Price: 4/5 Worth a try but probably won't be back
LaShunda H
I bought my husband some chocolate chip cookies!! He said they were amazing, my daughter and I had lunch at Sugarfire BBQ. So I went next door and got my husband a treat. I definitely will come by there again and bring my husband in person. AMAZING!
Victor Galvan
Has the best pie I've ever had, butttttt I've showed up when they were supposed to be open and they weren't. They posted their monthly specials and I drove there specifically for it and they didn't have it that day. Essentially, if you can get the pie you want, it's amazing but it's 50/50 if you'l actually get it.
Shaylea W.
My mother spoke with the manager of this store to custom order a cherry pie for my grandfather's birthday. All of her information was confirmed, the day and time it was supposed to be ready by was also confirmed. My mom showed up today to pick up the pie and the girl who was working had to call her manager who then told her that it "slipped her mind". The girl working then told my mother that they could make it and have it ready tomorrow which obviously wouldn't work because my grandfathers birthday is TODAY. That obviously was the whole reason for special ordering the pie to be ready for today. Then as my mom was leaving the girl working sarcastically said "well have a good day". Very disappointing when she could of special ordered a cherry pie at ANY bakery yet chose this one. I don't think anyone would trust to have their order made after the original date and time it was supposed to be ready by "slips" the managers mind.
Amazing service and incredibly accommodating! I wish I could remember who helped me, but my husband will be really excited about waking up to his favorite key lime pie on his birthday! Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dedicated to making people smile with delicious pies, cakes & cookies. Next door to the outstanding Sugarfire Barbecue. I loved the oatmeal cream pie $4 and apple pie $4. Pricy but really good. The vibe is like going to visit your friends that like to bake. Extra bonus: free coffee that is good
This was our first visit to Sugarfire Pie and it will not be our last!!! The atmosphere is unique and inviting. The staff was friendly and knowledgeable. I walked in expecting to spend $20 on 2-3 items, but walked out away spending $20 on 5 items. Our experience from start to finish exceed my expectations!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Guess it was a sign ? riding down olive heading home G7 started going CRAZY FROM SUGAR DROPPED FROM 100TO 60 in 15 minutes. COMPLEX IS PACKED WITH THINGS TO DO &
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Freshly Made Pie
Cobbler was great!! It was a bit overpriced for what it was.
The caramel is so good and the owner is such a nice woman. We are visiting from out of town and she gave plenty of advice. If you're in the area definitely stop by cause it is a great spot to get a treat.
The staff were great! Super helpful and attentive. There’s only about 5 options for pie, so I ordered the apple pie. It wasn’t very good. I’ll go back and try something else.
Best piece of apple pie I have had east of the rockies.
Great service, delicious pies.
The bakery for Sugarfire Smokehouse. You can eat inside as well. Wonderful.
Restaurantji Recommends
Great pie
Overall rating: 4/5 Wait: 5/5 Arrival time: Wednesday 1pm Food: 3.5/5 Order: key lime pie, strawberry cheesecake, sugarfire Pies are a bit too sweet for my taste Service: 4.5/5 Price: 4/5 Worth a try but probably won't be back
I bought my husband some chocolate chip cookies!! He said they were amazing, my daughter and I had lunch at Sugarfire BBQ. So I went next door and got my husband a treat. I definitely will come by there again and bring my husband in person. AMAZING!
Has the best pie I've ever had, butttttt I've showed up when they were supposed to be open and they weren't. They posted their monthly specials and I drove there specifically for it and they didn't have it that day. Essentially, if you can get the pie you want, it's amazing but it's 50/50 if you'l actually get it.
My mother spoke with the manager of this store to custom order a cherry pie for my grandfather's birthday. All of her information was confirmed, the day and time it was supposed to be ready by was also confirmed. My mom showed up today to pick up the pie and the girl who was working had to call her manager who then told her that it "slipped her mind". The girl working then told my mother that they could make it and have it ready tomorrow which obviously wouldn't work because my grandfathers birthday is TODAY. That obviously was the whole reason for special ordering the pie to be ready for today. Then as my mom was leaving the girl working sarcastically said "well have a good day". Very disappointing when she could of special ordered a cherry pie at ANY bakery yet chose this one. I don't think anyone would trust to have their order made after the original date and time it was supposed to be ready by "slips" the managers mind.