We came from California where great Mexican food was in abundance. We tried many Mexican restaurants only to be disappointed. We stumbled across Casa Mia & were so happy to find amazing, delicious Mexican food again. The drinks are tantalizing, the food is mouth watering & the service is even better. Go visit Casa Mia, you won’t be disappointed! I know it sounds like I was paid to say this but I swear I wasn’t paid a cent. Even with the margarita kicking I’m telling it like it is! ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Whitney
Always has the best food and drinks! Love their refried beans and the burritos. Any protein choice is always so flavorful and moist. Good vibes and good food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
H JD
The ceviche de pescado was AMAZING! Same for the coconut mojito. Here goes: I see a lot of undeserved low ratings here from- honestly- some pretty spoiled brats who don’t understand that they are not the center of the universe. So I’m setting the record straight. The seating was completely comfortable, service was great, and the food was fresh!As far as the complaints about small portions go, the portions are only small if you’re a total fat @$$ and can’t understand what constitutes a normal amount of food per meal. For all of us who aren’t 500 pounds, it was the perfect size, hands down. The chairs were not uncomfortable at all. By the way, I’m totally not sorry at all. These people deserve WAY more 5 star reviews.It’s hard to find genuinely good Mexican food with real actual fresh ingredients, but Casa Mia sets the bar! It is a gem tucked away in New Town and a local favorite. ❤️Dietary restrictions: There are vegan and vegetarian options as well as fish for pescatarians.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jessica S
First timer and less than impressed. Sat down and for 2 of us we got one menu and were told they were out of menus. But a table next to us later on had 2 people and 3 menus. Make it make sense. Perhaps a QR code on the table would help if menus are scarce. Then we didn't get what we asked for. The server wrote it all down and it still came out completely wrong so my husband didn't eat at all. And we would've said something and had her bring it back however 20 mins went by without even seeing her once it was pointless by the time we did. Salsa tasted like tomato sauce it was not good at all. I ate what we got and it was nachos and it was so bland, zero flavor at all. The place is nice and inviting and well decorated.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
Dean B
Good food. Good service. Fun trivia night on Wednesday.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Susan Schuster
My friends and I really like Casa Mia. We were looking forward to trying the tortilla soup they posted on Facebook, for this weekend only. However, by 5:30 Saturday evening, they had run out of it. We were disappointed, but stayed and enjoyed another choice from the menu.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Seth M.
I recently dined at this Mexican restaurant, and unfortunately, the experience left much to be desired. The chips and salsa were a disappointment, as neither had a pleasant taste. The main courses were notably bland and lacked the vibrant flavors one would expect from Mexican cuisine. To make matters worse, the margarita I ordered didn't have any discernible liquor taste. Overall, the food could have been vastly improved, and I left feeling unsatisfied.
Robert W.
Good food and large plate entree and sides. Service was quick and friendly. Open seating indoor and out including bar service. Great first visit. Will be back!
John D.
Can't believe I haven't posted a review of this absolute GO-TO for us. We regularly visit here since it's less than a mile from our house. But we would drive further if we needed to because the clean, delicious menu with fresh, made-to-order goodies is worth it. I've had a number of menu items and pretty much loved all of them. They have some great unique and clean items on the menu for us (staying away from grains and wheat). The Mahi Mahi Adobo is the top! But there's others, only warning would be the dishes with Queso or cheese sauce on them, they can tend to go a little heavy, so consider asking for it in the side if that's a concern. Great, reasonably priced cocktail options and an "unofficial" kids menu(just ask) will keep us coming back. Always good, friendly service too, even when it's packed.
Anthony Sonstein
Food is very average, drinks and flavor profiles seem tailored for suburban palate, not bad by any means just not memorable. The salsa however is not good, it needs some serious work , its like tomato sauce, needs some heat and maybe a little smokeyness from roasted peppers maybe.
Went here 3 times and 2 of the 3 times they were closed during advertised business hours with no explanation. They kind of just close whenever they want and don't even put up a sign. If you're going to go, call first and see if they're actually open. Food was ok the one time they were actually open, but the service was bad.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 2
Güneş Ö.
We have been here couple of times before and they lost us (2 customers) today.We came here at 6.30 pm and left without having dinner at 8 pm. The waitress kept telling us that our food will be ready in 5 minutes - for 1-1/2 hours! They were busy, but they were not short staffed. Everyone came after us, got their food. And we only ordered few tacos, not a complicated meal.They have the least comfortable chairs, their chips were ok but salsa tasted bad.We will not return.
Tawni F.
Excellent food. Friendly staff Lovely environment. Doing well navigating the current job shortage by bringing in people that drive a long distance. Thank you to them for making the journey to serve us. Hires local high school students to seat people and clear tables. And the young people are working! If you can, give them a tip. Love this place.
Scott J.
The food and drinks were on point. Our Bravo Shrimp was to die for. After our first visit it instantly became a regular must hit restaurant.
Mike M.
Amazing food and service at this authentic Mexican restaurant. It's feels like any other place but the food sets it's apart.
We came from California where great Mexican food was in abundance. We tried many Mexican restaurants only to be disappointed. We stumbled across Casa Mia & were so happy to find amazing, delicious Mexican food again. The drinks are tantalizing, the food is mouth watering & the service is even better. Go visit Casa Mia, you won’t be disappointed! I know it sounds like I was paid to say this but I swear I wasn’t paid a cent. Even with the margarita kicking I’m telling it like it is! ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Always has the best food and drinks! Love their refried beans and the burritos. Any protein choice is always so flavorful and moist. Good vibes and good food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The ceviche de pescado was AMAZING! Same for the coconut mojito. Here goes: I see a lot of undeserved low ratings here from- honestly- some pretty spoiled brats who don’t understand that they are not the center of the universe. So I’m setting the record straight. The seating was completely comfortable, service was great, and the food was fresh!As far as the complaints about small portions go, the portions are only small if you’re a total fat @$$ and can’t understand what constitutes a normal amount of food per meal. For all of us who aren’t 500 pounds, it was the perfect size, hands down. The chairs were not uncomfortable at all. By the way, I’m totally not sorry at all. These people deserve WAY more 5 star reviews.It’s hard to find genuinely good Mexican food with real actual fresh ingredients, but Casa Mia sets the bar! It is a gem tucked away in New Town and a local favorite. ❤️Dietary restrictions: There are vegan and vegetarian options as well as fish for pescatarians.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First timer and less than impressed. Sat down and for 2 of us we got one menu and were told they were out of menus. But a table next to us later on had 2 people and 3 menus. Make it make sense. Perhaps a QR code on the table would help if menus are scarce. Then we didn't get what we asked for. The server wrote it all down and it still came out completely wrong so my husband didn't eat at all. And we would've said something and had her bring it back however 20 mins went by without even seeing her once it was pointless by the time we did. Salsa tasted like tomato sauce it was not good at all. I ate what we got and it was nachos and it was so bland, zero flavor at all. The place is nice and inviting and well decorated.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
Good food. Good service. Fun trivia night on Wednesday.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My friends and I really like Casa Mia. We were looking forward to trying the tortilla soup they posted on Facebook, for this weekend only. However, by 5:30 Saturday evening, they had run out of it. We were disappointed, but stayed and enjoyed another choice from the menu.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I recently dined at this Mexican restaurant, and unfortunately, the experience left much to be desired. The chips and salsa were a disappointment, as neither had a pleasant taste. The main courses were notably bland and lacked the vibrant flavors one would expect from Mexican cuisine. To make matters worse, the margarita I ordered didn't have any discernible liquor taste. Overall, the food could have been vastly improved, and I left feeling unsatisfied.
Good food and large plate entree and sides. Service was quick and friendly. Open seating indoor and out including bar service. Great first visit. Will be back!
Can't believe I haven't posted a review of this absolute GO-TO for us. We regularly visit here since it's less than a mile from our house. But we would drive further if we needed to because the clean, delicious menu with fresh, made-to-order goodies is worth it. I've had a number of menu items and pretty much loved all of them. They have some great unique and clean items on the menu for us (staying away from grains and wheat). The Mahi Mahi Adobo is the top! But there's others, only warning would be the dishes with Queso or cheese sauce on them, they can tend to go a little heavy, so consider asking for it in the side if that's a concern. Great, reasonably priced cocktail options and an "unofficial" kids menu(just ask) will keep us coming back. Always good, friendly service too, even when it's packed.
Food is very average, drinks and flavor profiles seem tailored for suburban palate, not bad by any means just not memorable. The salsa however is not good, it needs some serious work , its like tomato sauce, needs some heat and maybe a little smokeyness from roasted peppers maybe.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
Went here 3 times and 2 of the 3 times they were closed during advertised business hours with no explanation. They kind of just close whenever they want and don't even put up a sign. If you're going to go, call first and see if they're actually open. Food was ok the one time they were actually open, but the service was bad.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 2
We have been here couple of times before and they lost us (2 customers) today.We came here at 6.30 pm and left without having dinner at 8 pm. The waitress kept telling us that our food will be ready in 5 minutes - for 1-1/2 hours! They were busy, but they were not short staffed. Everyone came after us, got their food. And we only ordered few tacos, not a complicated meal.They have the least comfortable chairs, their chips were ok but salsa tasted bad.We will not return.
Excellent food. Friendly staff Lovely environment. Doing well navigating the current job shortage by bringing in people that drive a long distance. Thank you to them for making the journey to serve us. Hires local high school students to seat people and clear tables. And the young people are working! If you can, give them a tip. Love this place.
The food and drinks were on point. Our Bravo Shrimp was to die for. After our first visit it instantly became a regular must hit restaurant.
Amazing food and service at this authentic Mexican restaurant. It's feels like any other place but the food sets it's apart.