Had the Detroit Supreme the other day. Omg let me tell ya it was Soo good!!! I about died at how BIG and loaded this pizza was. Definitely worth trying them out. Will have to try a coney next! So nice to have great quality pizza in my back yard. Thank you!
Nicole Burgio
We decided to try the pizza for the first time because we had some business to attend out at New Town. The staff was super sweet, very upfront about their 25 minute wait time. We were told the original cook had to have 5 stents put in today. We went over to the market looked around and it seems like the 25 minutes went so fast. The girl on the register came to our vehicle and brought out soda and the hand delivered the delicious slices of pizza. Hot and fresh!! We will for sure be back!!Kid-friendliness: Definitely for kids and family's.Wheelchair accessibility: The shack is located outside.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: BBQ Chicken
John Zimmer
Love the ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
kathy johnson
Dietary restrictions: Gluten free crust!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amber S.
Awesome first timer! Great double pepperoni & double pizza and cheese bread. Will definitely be back!
Skye Mendez
Easy service for to go orders. Be warned, at times you have to wait 45+ min for a pick up order because they’re busy. They give my dog treats as we wait, good Missouri ranch on the side of the Za! I also like the Mozz
Great pizza in a great location! Convenient walking distance for us and they have plenty of benches for sitting outside. They also have fans running which makes it a lot cooler if it's hot out! We called ahead and our pizza was ready quickly and still hot when we got there!
Sean Mckinney
Was watching Joel Hanson on YouTube today do a coney challenge found myself wanting a hotdog so I went on Google to find a gourmet style dog and was recommended Paulys Pizza and Coney Shack so I went found it odd that it was in Newtown a residential area so I was skeptical.... BUT LET ME TELL YOU the cashier and the manager were VERY patient explained how they dogs went so I ordered the Coney Combo with the meat sauce and waffle fries when I say at this moment my taste buds are DANCING that Coney hit EVERYTHING in my soul and it was close to them closing I didn't catch y'all name but if you read this YOU DID AMAZING
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Larry Drake
I really wanted to love this. We got a pepperoni and bacon that was not very good. I will go back once more to make sure it wasn't just an off day but so far not impressed. The coney was just okay as well.
Alexis T.
Yesss.... Love their pizza and coney dogs. Great prices and great value. They are so nice here and will even deliver your food if you aren't too far away.
The staff was sweet as can be, and the whole vibe around the shack was great! Even the slushee shack next door. Food was solid.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Boom Boom Chicken Pizza, Coney Dog
Dennis Hamer
Tried the Pauly's Pie. Soooo good! You need to make this a full-scale restaurant!
Thomas Creamer
Not a Todoroffs Coney but still good.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Scott H.
The pizza is always amazing as well as the calzones! A great asset to the community! Take the time to stop by.
Jon McColgan
Great as always! We loved the Al Pastor Casa Mia colab pizza! Such a great combination of flavors! My Chicago family is visiting and they loved it! Thank you for a great dinner!
Had the Detroit Supreme the other day. Omg let me tell ya it was Soo good!!! I about died at how BIG and loaded this pizza was. Definitely worth trying them out. Will have to try a coney next! So nice to have great quality pizza in my back yard. Thank you!
We decided to try the pizza for the first time because we had some business to attend out at New Town. The staff was super sweet, very upfront about their 25 minute wait time. We were told the original cook had to have 5 stents put in today. We went over to the market looked around and it seems like the 25 minutes went so fast. The girl on the register came to our vehicle and brought out soda and the hand delivered the delicious slices of pizza. Hot and fresh!! We will for sure be back!!Kid-friendliness: Definitely for kids and family's.Wheelchair accessibility: The shack is located outside.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: BBQ Chicken
Love the ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dietary restrictions: Gluten free crust!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Awesome first timer! Great double pepperoni & double pizza and cheese bread. Will definitely be back!
Easy service for to go orders. Be warned, at times you have to wait 45+ min for a pick up order because they’re busy. They give my dog treats as we wait, good Missouri ranch on the side of the Za! I also like the Mozz
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: BBQ Chicken Pizza, Meat Lovers Pizza, Mozzarella Sticks
Great pizza in a great location! Convenient walking distance for us and they have plenty of benches for sitting outside. They also have fans running which makes it a lot cooler if it's hot out! We called ahead and our pizza was ready quickly and still hot when we got there!
Was watching Joel Hanson on YouTube today do a coney challenge found myself wanting a hotdog so I went on Google to find a gourmet style dog and was recommended Paulys Pizza and Coney Shack so I went found it odd that it was in Newtown a residential area so I was skeptical.... BUT LET ME TELL YOU the cashier and the manager were VERY patient explained how they dogs went so I ordered the Coney Combo with the meat sauce and waffle fries when I say at this moment my taste buds are DANCING that Coney hit EVERYTHING in my soul and it was close to them closing I didn't catch y'all name but if you read this YOU DID AMAZING
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I really wanted to love this. We got a pepperoni and bacon that was not very good. I will go back once more to make sure it wasn't just an off day but so far not impressed. The coney was just okay as well.
Yesss.... Love their pizza and coney dogs. Great prices and great value. They are so nice here and will even deliver your food if you aren't too far away.
Restaurantji Recommends
The staff was sweet as can be, and the whole vibe around the shack was great! Even the slushee shack next door. Food was solid.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Boom Boom Chicken Pizza, Coney Dog
Tried the Pauly's Pie. Soooo good! You need to make this a full-scale restaurant!
Not a Todoroffs Coney but still good.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
The pizza is always amazing as well as the calzones! A great asset to the community! Take the time to stop by.
Great as always! We loved the Al Pastor Casa Mia colab pizza! Such a great combination of flavors! My Chicago family is visiting and they loved it! Thank you for a great dinner!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5