American Pie Co.
1017 N Olive St, Sullivan
(573) 468-2050
Customers' Favorites
20 Oz Iced Latte or Mocha
Mushroom Swiss Quiche
Ham and Cheese Quiche
St Louis Blueberry
Pie of the Month
Chicken Pot Pie
Shepherd's Pie
Spiced Peach
Tart Cherry
Menu
Photos
+12 photos
+11 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
They were about to close in 30 minutes but they were friendly, kind, and helpful in selecting pies for my niece and I. The pies were amazing quality in little individual sized servings. I am glad we stopped on a whim!
First time visiting and certainly won’t be the last! Such a comfortable and cute little pie shop that feels cozy and local for being a chain. The customer service is what sets apart this location from other places in the area. The coffee was delightful as are the baked goods! Next time I’ll try the savory foods!! The pricing is beyond reasonable. A 20oz coffee and a jumbo puff was $9 and some change. Would’ve spent that at the other coffee place in town on one drink alone!
What a surprise! I wasn't quite sure what to expect but this place is awesome! I had the salad bar which was packed with options and toppings, so yummy. The chicken pot pie was amazing!! I can't wait to come back again and try some of the other items on their menu. Such a nice, quint little lunch spot.
You May Also Like
Pizza Hut - 100 S Outer Rd
![]()
Pizza, Chicken Wings, Fast Food
McDonald's - 6 Es, S Service Rd W
![]()
Fast Food, Coffee & Tea, Burgers
Rich's Famous Burgers - Sullivan - 101 Grande Center
![]()
Hamburger, American, Burgers