Casey's is usually pretty good for everything. But my recent Pizza order was terrible. I ordered via the Casey's app. I always order the same pizza. Large Supreme. Placed the order and set a pick-up time of 30 minutes later. I got the E-mail, location and pick-up time.So I arrive maybe 2 minutes before my order is due. 15 minutes later, I got my order. Seems like she put my order in when I arrived. Not a big deal except last night was game night and we had people waiting at the house for pizza. Question, why offer a pick-up time if you put in my order when I arrive. Makes no sense.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 2
Todd Earnest
If you aren't going to stay open till 1:00 then you should change your hours on your stores website. Drove all the way from the south side of Galmey and hustled the whole way. Only to drive by with 10 minutes to spare, so I thought. Closed!! Glad I wasn't needing any gasoline or had it been an emergency, I would have been totally f....!!! The Casey's I worked for in Greenwood MO would have terminated an employee for closing early!!
Dale Forrest
Love accessing their kitchen. Always have warm food for you.
Mark Neufeld
Always
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pamela Walters
Pizza was dry and horrible pizza.
Food: 1
Service: 1
Jennifer Drake
Food was decent not high end like a restaurant but it was good staff was very friendly and helpful but was extremely busy that day and only had 1 casher who kept apologizing for the wait which was not her
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Kristaladawn Gerst
The only food is for animals but good selection
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Seanna Kirkland
I really like this place. The employees are always knowledgeable, funny and helpful. I'm originally from the east coast and I know good pizza, if you're looking for great pizza, it's not your place, but it is good pizza, and the wings are awesome. For a middle of nowhere gas station/ pizza joint I would say they're pretty top par. Love the manager Robin, she's strong and sweet. Good place overall ??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Victor Foster
Employees are great! Pizza was ok, but $35 for two Medium pizzas that were really SMALL was a little pricy$$$$$. But this store really needs a remodel. It looks worn out inside. But again the staff were VERY nice.
I happen to love their pizza, now pizza is like barbecue and there are many different styles and you can enjoy several that are vastly different.It seems to be sometimes difficult to get the attention of the person working in the food area when you just need to pick up your order n get going.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Kurtis Lampo
I ordered a ham, mushroom, and extra cheese. It had a few slivers od mushroom and I couldn't tell there was any ham at all. Not at all up to Casey quality I'm used to.
Raven
The large is a little small, but my orders have been good. Service is good
Max Noel
We come by almost every day and love Gwendolynn (I hope that’s how you spell her name) so much The staff are all super friendly!! We drive from Hermitage just to go to this Casey’s because of how sweet all of you are and how good you make the food. -1 star for the simple fact Shannon is there. She was rude the entire time (over the phone and when we showed up). We’ve never been treated like this at Wheatland before but it’s the exact reason we stopped going to the Hermitage location.
Love the pizza and service the staff is
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Casey's is usually pretty good for everything. But my recent Pizza order was terrible. I ordered via the Casey's app. I always order the same pizza. Large Supreme. Placed the order and set a pick-up time of 30 minutes later. I got the E-mail, location and pick-up time.So I arrive maybe 2 minutes before my order is due. 15 minutes later, I got my order. Seems like she put my order in when I arrived. Not a big deal except last night was game night and we had people waiting at the house for pizza. Question, why offer a pick-up time if you put in my order when I arrive. Makes no sense.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 2
If you aren't going to stay open till 1:00 then you should change your hours on your stores website. Drove all the way from the south side of Galmey and hustled the whole way. Only to drive by with 10 minutes to spare, so I thought. Closed!! Glad I wasn't needing any gasoline or had it been an emergency, I would have been totally f....!!! The Casey's I worked for in Greenwood MO would have terminated an employee for closing early!!
Love accessing their kitchen. Always have warm food for you.
Always
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza was dry and horrible pizza.
Food: 1
Service: 1
Food was decent not high end like a restaurant but it was good staff was very friendly and helpful but was extremely busy that day and only had 1 casher who kept apologizing for the wait which was not her
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
The only food is for animals but good selection
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
I really like this place. The employees are always knowledgeable, funny and helpful. I'm originally from the east coast and I know good pizza, if you're looking for great pizza, it's not your place, but it is good pizza, and the wings are awesome. For a middle of nowhere gas station/ pizza joint I would say they're pretty top par. Love the manager Robin, she's strong and sweet. Good place overall ??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Employees are great! Pizza was ok, but $35 for two Medium pizzas that were really SMALL was a little pricy$$$$$. But this store really needs a remodel. It looks worn out inside. But again the staff were VERY nice.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I happen to love their pizza, now pizza is like barbecue and there are many different styles and you can enjoy several that are vastly different.It seems to be sometimes difficult to get the attention of the person working in the food area when you just need to pick up your order n get going.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
I ordered a ham, mushroom, and extra cheese. It had a few slivers od mushroom and I couldn't tell there was any ham at all. Not at all up to Casey quality I'm used to.
The large is a little small, but my orders have been good. Service is good
We come by almost every day and love Gwendolynn (I hope that’s how you spell her name) so much The staff are all super friendly!! We drive from Hermitage just to go to this Casey’s because of how sweet all of you are and how good you make the food. -1 star for the simple fact Shannon is there. She was rude the entire time (over the phone and when we showed up). We’ve never been treated like this at Wheatland before but it’s the exact reason we stopped going to the Hermitage location.
Great!