Food is ok. The customer service was not too good. The cashier kept asking the associate in the back did I get what I'm telling her I got. It was just unprofessional for no reason.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Cranberry Ginger Ale
This place was awesome with a capital A. I haven’t been truly happy in a while, but when I ate the slice of cheese, the slice of meat lovers, and consumed the Barqs Red Creme Soda, I truly felt happiness. Me and the boys enjoyed our slices and then ate a mediocre cookie from another restaurant. The food was so great that on the way out I made sure to tip five bucks because I forgot earlier. I’m sure this is the pizza that angels eat in heaven, and I hope my dog Atlas who passed recently is enjoying it there too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: All Meat Pizza, Cheese Pizza
Michelle Derusseau
We recently spent a rainy night in Biloxi and had New York Pizza delivered. It was awesome! We had a pepperoni pizza and an Italian sandwich. The pizza was great and the sandwich was also great, lots of fresh ingredients, both very flavorful! Thanks for being the highlight of a rainy night in a strange town.
Food: 5
Yadira Williams
I typically never take the time to leave reviews, but this place blew me away! The staff and the food was amazing! I had the lasagna with garlic bread and my child had the macaroni & cheese, it was so so good. 5 stars all day!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lasagna, Garlic Bread, Mac N Cheese
Tina Apicelli
I'm from jersey and it's as good as back home. And there sauce is not bitter very smooth. Also there canoli and Stromboli is good. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sheila Patterson
On 11/06/23 at 3:30 pm I picked up my order at the Biloxi New York Pizza. I did not get the young man and lady’s name, but after leaving I wish I had so I could recognize them personally in this review. The staff was courteous and professional and called me in advance to make sure the order I placed was prepared correctly. I appreciate they took the extra step proving they care, my food was delicious cooked perfectly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Personal Stromboli, Cheese Steak
Rick B.
In a mall. Can't just run over for a pizza fix. If you are looking for take out or just a slice.
Phil F
Hands down best consistent slice of NY style on the coast. The dude up there claiming this is only a step above CC’s is mistaken; also you’re lucky if you can smoke OUTSIDE anywhere in Biloxi so I have no idea what time frame he is referring to but it’s obviously in error. Two out of three times I visit, the owner is behind the counter making pizzas and talking to customers. You can tell he really cares about providing a decent experience and judging by the fact I have been picking up pizzas here for years and see most of the same staff members, I have to assume he is a standup guy to work for. So if you were gonna drop 25 to 30$ at Pizza Hut do yourself a favor and call these guys ten minutes before you get there and order an extra large for pick up. Your food will be ready by the time you get there; it will taste better, cost less and you’ll be supporting a local business.
Went inside the Edgewater mall in Biloxi Ms. just to get a couple slices of pizza. So one of the guys asked me if he could help me I said yes. I pointed to the two slices I wanted. He told me I could not have those Slices I would have to have the slices from the front because they have to get rid of the old pizza first. I told him when the owner is working he lets me pick my slices. He still denied me. I ask him if I could speak with the owner he said he doesn't work on Sundays. So one of the ladies over heard the conversation and responded I'm the manager. I explained to her the situation and she walked away and started helping another customer. So I left and went somewhere else were you can get good customer service along with food. I won't eat there anymore.
Michael Soto
Absolutely the best pizza on the coast! if you haven't been here I highly recommend!
Tyler Sullivan
I’ve been eating New York Pizza in the Edgewater Mall for over 7 years now, and every slice of pizza is the best New York slice I’ve ever had! The owner is an amazing guy, always willing to chat when he has time, and he’s got the best food around. I feel like I’m walking in to a neighborhood pizza shop where everybody knows your name every time I’m there. And don’t just stop at the pizza! The calzones, the sandwiches, wings, fries . . . it’s all good! Thank you for always providing the best food, service, and community, all at a great price!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Personal Stromboli, All Meat Pizza, Soda, Chicken Wings, French Fries, Mac N Cheese,
Yari English
Donaidi was extremely friendly and helpful! The pizza and wings she recommended were phenomenal. Y’all are lucky to have her! I would recommend coming here over any of the other restaurants for sure.
Donaidi Orengo
BEST PIZZA ON THE COAST!!!
THEY HAVE THE BEST STAFF!!!
THANK YOU NEW YORK PIZZA BILOXI !!!
I don't want to like mall food but the 2 people behind the counter were very engaging and the pizza was
Food: 4
Service: 5
Not for me. Too thin & not much flavor. Wouldn't order pizza again but the breadsticks cannoli were good. Overall will probably pass next time.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Garlic Bread, Cannoli
Food is ok. The customer service was not too good. The cashier kept asking the associate in the back did I get what I'm telling her I got. It was just unprofessional for no reason.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
This place was awesome with a capital A. I haven’t been truly happy in a while, but when I ate the slice of cheese, the slice of meat lovers, and consumed the Barqs Red Creme Soda, I truly felt happiness. Me and the boys enjoyed our slices and then ate a mediocre cookie from another restaurant. The food was so great that on the way out I made sure to tip five bucks because I forgot earlier. I’m sure this is the pizza that angels eat in heaven, and I hope my dog Atlas who passed recently is enjoying it there too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: All Meat Pizza, Cheese Pizza
We recently spent a rainy night in Biloxi and had New York Pizza delivered. It was awesome! We had a pepperoni pizza and an Italian sandwich. The pizza was great and the sandwich was also great, lots of fresh ingredients, both very flavorful! Thanks for being the highlight of a rainy night in a strange town.
Food: 5
I typically never take the time to leave reviews, but this place blew me away! The staff and the food was amazing! I had the lasagna with garlic bread and my child had the macaroni & cheese, it was so so good. 5 stars all day!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lasagna, Garlic Bread, Mac N Cheese
I'm from jersey and it's as good as back home. And there sauce is not bitter very smooth. Also there canoli and Stromboli is good. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
On 11/06/23 at 3:30 pm I picked up my order at the Biloxi New York Pizza. I did not get the young man and lady’s name, but after leaving I wish I had so I could recognize them personally in this review. The staff was courteous and professional and called me in advance to make sure the order I placed was prepared correctly. I appreciate they took the extra step proving they care, my food was delicious cooked perfectly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Personal Stromboli, Cheese Steak
In a mall. Can't just run over for a pizza fix. If you are looking for take out or just a slice.
Hands down best consistent slice of NY style on the coast. The dude up there claiming this is only a step above CC’s is mistaken; also you’re lucky if you can smoke OUTSIDE anywhere in Biloxi so I have no idea what time frame he is referring to but it’s obviously in error. Two out of three times I visit, the owner is behind the counter making pizzas and talking to customers. You can tell he really cares about providing a decent experience and judging by the fact I have been picking up pizzas here for years and see most of the same staff members, I have to assume he is a standup guy to work for. So if you were gonna drop 25 to 30$ at Pizza Hut do yourself a favor and call these guys ten minutes before you get there and order an extra large for pick up. Your food will be ready by the time you get there; it will taste better, cost less and you’ll be supporting a local business.
Restaurantji Recommends
Went inside the Edgewater mall in Biloxi Ms. just to get a couple slices of pizza. So one of the guys asked me if he could help me I said yes. I pointed to the two slices I wanted. He told me I could not have those Slices I would have to have the slices from the front because they have to get rid of the old pizza first. I told him when the owner is working he lets me pick my slices. He still denied me. I ask him if I could speak with the owner he said he doesn't work on Sundays. So one of the ladies over heard the conversation and responded I'm the manager. I explained to her the situation and she walked away and started helping another customer. So I left and went somewhere else were you can get good customer service along with food. I won't eat there anymore.
Absolutely the best pizza on the coast! if you haven't been here I highly recommend!
I’ve been eating New York Pizza in the Edgewater Mall for over 7 years now, and every slice of pizza is the best New York slice I’ve ever had! The owner is an amazing guy, always willing to chat when he has time, and he’s got the best food around. I feel like I’m walking in to a neighborhood pizza shop where everybody knows your name every time I’m there. And don’t just stop at the pizza! The calzones, the sandwiches, wings, fries . . . it’s all good! Thank you for always providing the best food, service, and community, all at a great price!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Personal Stromboli, All Meat Pizza, Soda, Chicken Wings, French Fries, Mac N Cheese,
Donaidi was extremely friendly and helpful! The pizza and wings she recommended were phenomenal. Y’all are lucky to have her! I would recommend coming here over any of the other restaurants for sure.
BEST PIZZA ON THE COAST!!! THEY HAVE THE BEST STAFF!!! THANK YOU NEW YORK PIZZA BILOXI !!!