The atmosphere was great. The waitress was extremely friendly. The food was magnificent. Definitely going back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Steak
Kaitlyn Warren
Very well cooked steaks. I have eaten here multiple times, my steak has been excellent and cooked to order every time. Service has been wonderful.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salad with Dressing, Great Steak, House Salad, Steak
Josh H
Everyone else in my group said it was the best ribeye they ever had. For me it was second best. But they cannot get beef from South Africa.Owners really should not shut the door in peoples faces just before posted closing time. Not very Southern.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Steak
Ephriam Mauldin
They speak to you as soon as you walk into the door, ask what can we do for you today, and treat you nice whey you are waiting on your food to take out.Vegetarian options: Bake potatoes loaded
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: How Would You Like Your Steak Cooked, Salad with Dressing, Great Steak
James Norman
Best Steak I've had in the area. Specilzes in grille only options. Loved the attentiveness of wait staff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Great Steak
Joseph P.
Excellence done simply. If you do something right why try anything else. Old Hickory has it down pat.
Eric Krieger
I ambled on down to this Columbus institution last night. As it happens, I got there just early enough to avoid having to wait outside – This place is popular, and for good reason! We both got us some hot, juicy, delicious T-bones cooked just right! This is one of those places that only has steaks, baked potatoes, salads, and drinks on the menu because...well, that's all they need to offer – They specialize in steaks, steaks, and even steaks; they have been for a long time, and the experience shows!Parking: Shared parking lot with the adjoining businesses is a bit on the small side but you can find a spot with a little patience; get there early to avoid having to wait outside.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: How Would You Like Your Steak Cooked, Great Steak
Lanceri Fann
There was a nip of cold tonight. My husband and I wanted to enjoy a steak to go. The aroma coming in gave a Fourth of July BBQ feel. As you come into the entrance there are two Chefs working over a massive Grill. They actively And masterfully cook your food live through a very well lit window. It’s more than dinner and a show. From the outside looking in. The Cooking staff were friendly and maintained open communication with the staff and customers. Giving out ETA and ready stances. This was my first time coming, I was excited to see what was offered. My coworker recommend the place as the best steak house in town. Not being from Columbus, I felt an obligation to support a local business that came so highly favored. A young lady at the front took orders, handled expo, and cashier with ease. After ordering I was given a time frame the food would be up, paid and walked away. 15 to 20 minutes . There were wooden table chairs in a row outside, I past them then waited close by in my car. Where you could still see your steak being cooked through the window. About 15 minutes later, I came back inside to experience the atmosphere.Durning my re entry it was close to around 5 mins until the food would be up. A then stretched out 5 mins.It’s not certain if maybe the front of house staff was just sleepy, tired, or if maybe I was meant to wait in to-go orders outside. Uncomfortable stares pressed against the air as our eyes met. Still excited about the food I ignored this.The food was wrapped to perfection with aluminum foil to preserve the heat on the ride home while letting it rest. This is despite a few previously requested sauces not being provided.Upon coming home. I cut into my steak. Glistening with a beautiful mahogany brown hue. With a perfect medium texture. As I tasted the steak the juicy overflowing experience of quality beef did excite my senses. Will I return to dine in and support the beautiful, yet unapproachable wait staff. Not sure that is to be determined. If I did, it will be from the single smile from a seasoned waitress sitting at the table saying to have a good night as I left. The steak was undeniably high grade, and juicy.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: How Would You Like Your Steak Cooked, Great Steak
Chris Naugle
Quite possibly the best steak I have ever eaten. This hole in the wall will now be a destination.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Season Toast, Salad with Dressing, Great Steak
After eating here, I am sad the best steak I have eaten is no longer one I cooked. Their 32oz sirloin was amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Angel Ramsey
One of the best Steaks I have ever tasted.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lisamary Garcia
This place had everything you wanted for a great steak dinner. Simple and impressive. You also cannot beat the price!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Great Steak
Sonja Brown
I asked for a well done New York strip it was still bloody, I asked for a loaded baked potato it only came with sour cream the salad was just plain. Not worth the $80 spent at all. Won't be returning.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
jjmckinney59
Did not live up to the reputation. Building is old and unkept. Steaks grilled at the cash register and the remainder of the food prep was done by the cashier on the cash register desk between customer payments (without separation from other customers and without hand washing). The steak tasted reasonable until we saw the very questionable food prep. One can often get good food at “hole in the wall” places, but this was a real hole.
The atmosphere was great. The waitress was extremely friendly. The food was magnificent. Definitely going back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Steak
Very well cooked steaks. I have eaten here multiple times, my steak has been excellent and cooked to order every time. Service has been wonderful.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salad with Dressing, Great Steak, House Salad, Steak
Everyone else in my group said it was the best ribeye they ever had. For me it was second best. But they cannot get beef from South Africa.Owners really should not shut the door in peoples faces just before posted closing time. Not very Southern.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Steak
They speak to you as soon as you walk into the door, ask what can we do for you today, and treat you nice whey you are waiting on your food to take out.Vegetarian options: Bake potatoes loaded
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: How Would You Like Your Steak Cooked, Salad with Dressing, Great Steak
Best Steak I've had in the area. Specilzes in grille only options. Loved the attentiveness of wait staff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Great Steak
Excellence done simply. If you do something right why try anything else. Old Hickory has it down pat.
I ambled on down to this Columbus institution last night. As it happens, I got there just early enough to avoid having to wait outside – This place is popular, and for good reason! We both got us some hot, juicy, delicious T-bones cooked just right! This is one of those places that only has steaks, baked potatoes, salads, and drinks on the menu because...well, that's all they need to offer – They specialize in steaks, steaks, and even steaks; they have been for a long time, and the experience shows!Parking: Shared parking lot with the adjoining businesses is a bit on the small side but you can find a spot with a little patience; get there early to avoid having to wait outside.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: How Would You Like Your Steak Cooked, Great Steak
There was a nip of cold tonight. My husband and I wanted to enjoy a steak to go. The aroma coming in gave a Fourth of July BBQ feel. As you come into the entrance there are two Chefs working over a massive Grill. They actively And masterfully cook your food live through a very well lit window. It’s more than dinner and a show. From the outside looking in. The Cooking staff were friendly and maintained open communication with the staff and customers. Giving out ETA and ready stances. This was my first time coming, I was excited to see what was offered. My coworker recommend the place as the best steak house in town. Not being from Columbus, I felt an obligation to support a local business that came so highly favored. A young lady at the front took orders, handled expo, and cashier with ease. After ordering I was given a time frame the food would be up, paid and walked away. 15 to 20 minutes . There were wooden table chairs in a row outside, I past them then waited close by in my car. Where you could still see your steak being cooked through the window. About 15 minutes later, I came back inside to experience the atmosphere.Durning my re entry it was close to around 5 mins until the food would be up. A then stretched out 5 mins.It’s not certain if maybe the front of house staff was just sleepy, tired, or if maybe I was meant to wait in to-go orders outside. Uncomfortable stares pressed against the air as our eyes met. Still excited about the food I ignored this.The food was wrapped to perfection with aluminum foil to preserve the heat on the ride home while letting it rest. This is despite a few previously requested sauces not being provided.Upon coming home. I cut into my steak. Glistening with a beautiful mahogany brown hue. With a perfect medium texture. As I tasted the steak the juicy overflowing experience of quality beef did excite my senses. Will I return to dine in and support the beautiful, yet unapproachable wait staff. Not sure that is to be determined. If I did, it will be from the single smile from a seasoned waitress sitting at the table saying to have a good night as I left. The steak was undeniably high grade, and juicy.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: How Would You Like Your Steak Cooked, Great Steak
Quite possibly the best steak I have ever eaten. This hole in the wall will now be a destination.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Season Toast, Salad with Dressing, Great Steak
Just had the best steak ever!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Great Steak
Restaurantji Recommends
After eating here, I am sad the best steak I have eaten is no longer one I cooked. Their 32oz sirloin was amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
One of the best Steaks I have ever tasted.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place had everything you wanted for a great steak dinner. Simple and impressive. You also cannot beat the price!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Great Steak
I asked for a well done New York strip it was still bloody, I asked for a loaded baked potato it only came with sour cream the salad was just plain. Not worth the $80 spent at all. Won't be returning.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Did not live up to the reputation. Building is old and unkept. Steaks grilled at the cash register and the remainder of the food prep was done by the cashier on the cash register desk between customer payments (without separation from other customers and without hand washing). The steak tasted reasonable until we saw the very questionable food prep. One can often get good food at “hole in the wall” places, but this was a real hole.