El Agave Mexican Grill

Great food, atmosphere, Drinks and staff. Never had a bad experience!

Terrible I didn't like it asked them to fry me a bruttio shell they said they don't do that. So I got 2 tacos and it was cold

Ick. I’m guessing maybe we caught them on the wrong day, because reading all these reviews, I thought they would be fantastic. We liked nothing here. Even the water tasted bad. Like dirty.

Worst salsa I’ve ever tasted, hands down. It was blended down into a complete liquid. Which would have been fine, had it been flavorful. It was super bland. Like tomato water. These folks need to look into some cilantro or something, dang.

I had the taco salad. It came out and had about two inches of liquid in the bottom of it. No idea. I pierced the shell so some of it would run out, but it ended up being like a soup consistency. And it wasn’t great, even if that wasn’t the case. My companion had the actual soup; also not great. The cheese dip was not bad. If you’re on the fence, go to Hacienda next door. It’s fantastic.

So, I went to El gave in New Albany today and ordered the Nacho Fries which include fries, grilled chicken, steak, cheese sauce, pico de gallon, sour cream, and jalapeño. I also ordered a cheesy chicken quesadilla with no veggies. At first they messed my order up by handing me a Fiesta Nacho with fries in it and no quesadilla, then the second I walked in asked them to remake it the right way but they still just gave me Fiesta Nachos with fries but only added the quesadilla…honestly 4/10 at least it was edible!!😒 (THE FIRST PICTURE EIS WHAT ITS SUPPOSED TO LOOK LIKE)

Ya'll you just go there and feel the awesome experience, for your self's !! Both locations with the other awesome place in , New Albany, Ms !! Just as nice and people are sensational 👌

They left out a part of our order and we didn’t know till we got home. But they made it right and let me keep the extra stuff!!!! Amazing food so it’s all good

For the 3rd week, we have ordered carry out, got home and my order was wrong. We had even stopped requesting that a certain item be taken off that I did not want bc we thought it was causing confusion. We were trying to make it easier on them. It still wasn’t right. So I had to drive back to town and get something to eat from somewhere else. They must have new workers.

We're from Pennsylvania in the area for a few days, been at this restaurant twice now. INCREDIBLE restaurant. Blown away how great the food has been, gets to table super quick and service has been amazing as well. I'd rate this place 10/10 if I could. One of the best places I've ever ate. Thank you so much for great food and service

Pretty good! Standard Mexican food, great hospitality and infinite chips. I got the agave special burrito. Nothing mind blowing, but worth it. My missionary companion got the Big Boy burrito and LOVED it!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Big Boy Burrito

Our organization was traveling to Asheville, North Carolina to help out the victims of hurricane Helene and their food and service was outstanding very satisfied, and we will come back to visit God bless you and thank you for your service

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Chimichanga

I just left my grandson’s birthday party, my daughter booked their “party” room for the occasion.
I ordered a large cheese dip, which was about half the size of the other two Mexican Restaurants in New Albany. When I got the bill the dip was $14.00 + tax.
When I left I called Mi Pueblo $7.90 + tax & Hacienda $8.71 + tax.
Again…almost half the size.
The hostess was beyond rude. I was the 1st person there and she acted like I was trying to rob the place, she went and got the manager and had him come and look at me (sitting at the table waiting on my daughter).
My daughter said whoever she talked to the 1st time to book the room was rude and told her they didn’t book it on Sunday. She called back and talked to a different person the next day and they booked it.
The waiter was great absolutely wonderful!!
I won’t be back.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

The best Mexican restaurant in New Albany!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Always a good meal and good service. By far the best Mexican restaurant New Albany has to offer.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

FRIDAY THE 13TH 2024
EL AGAVE I'D LIKE TO THANK U FOR A WONDERFUL EXPERIENCE ESPECIALLY THE COOK FOR PREPARING AN AMAZING DINNER ALSO TO MY SERVER FRANCISCO WHO WAS ALL ATTENTIVE AND POLITE
The staff is wonderful the food is delicious hot and served in a fast time the dishes are prepared beautifully.
I ordered the Carne Al Carbon carbon and the steak chunks were so tender and juicy.
The spicy chori queso dip is delicious also the prices are very reasonable also
My server Francisco was very timely polite ,courteous and funny he was a sweetheart I will always eat her dine in or take out it's a beautiful place and very very clean
I LOVE IT ❤️❤️❤️❤️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Steak Taco Salad, Street Tacos De Carne Asada, Carne Asada, Fresh Guacamole, Cheese Dip