Delicious exquisite pizza. To further add, the management and I chatted briefly as he rounded the restaurant to personally greet everyone and ask about their experience. I think that says everything necessary as to why our food was worth every dollar paid and assurement of future visits.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Banana Pudding, Cheesestix, All Meat Pizza, Wings, Pizza
Erica McGowan
My mom and I came in Friday February 16, 2024. When we walked up to the counter a white girl and a black girl were behind the counter one at each register. So the white girl ask my mom can she help her. My mama told her she wanted a large salad and the girl said, “A what(2 times)??” And my mom repeated herself each time and she act like she didn’t know what my mom was saying so my mom spoke loud and told her she wanted a large salad. She gonna say to my mom in a rude way, “YOU AIN’T GOT TO HOLLER”!!! And she walked off and didn’t wait on us!! First of all, she acted like she couldn’t hear her and acted like she was on drugs or something! The black girl waited on us at the register she was on. My mom asked her what was wrong with the other girl and she didn’t say a word. We didn’t get any names but VERY POOR CUSTOMER SERVICE!
Service: 1
Cindy Y.
Salad bar was nice, except the lettuce was fresh. Pizza was cold and the crust was a prefab factory made crust. For the price, I expected homemade dough. Very disappointing and we won't be back unless we decide to try the salad bar again.
Cindy Young
We had heard they had a good salad bar and it was a great selection. Only problem was the iceberg and the Romaine had a little browning and were not chopped enough (which is a personal preference). We had the buffet so now, about the pizza. By the time you walked to your table, it was cold. It was also tasteless. I tried eating only the toppings only to find a prefabricated store bought crust. No wonder it was awful. If you aren’t making crust homemade daily, can you legally use the word pizza in the title of your restaurant? Atmosphere was extremely loud (the staff). At least 5 people running around for 7 customers and I kept seeing people waiting on to go orders. Very inefficient use of staff. And they were loud and seemed to have to asked permission to do everything. Two employees should have been able to handle this business effectively. The online menu had prices at 8.99. We were charged 13.99. For prices comparable to to quality pizza places in Oxford, I definitely wouldn’t recommend this place and would make the drive to Oxford.
Dana Jones
My new favorite pizza place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matthew Harris
Had the buffet and enjoyed every slice. A hidden gem of a pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Office Information
The family just moved to Water Valley from Florida. Hometown Pizza Cafe was excellent! We really enjoyed our pizza!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sonya Putman
A relaxing atmosphere, very polite and courteous staff, food was very good and the prices are not to high. Would definitely go back!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: All Meat Pizza, Pizza
Justin Abbott
Great food, nice people!! Overall I enjoyed eating here.
I found a live huge horse fly in the Parmesan cheese. The waitress was rude after I pointed it out. Not going back...
Lisa W.
I'm a little bit of a pizza snob because honestly there is a lot to it. Toppings have to be great and the crust can make it or break it. Went to Hometown Pizza on a Sunday for lunch. They have a all you can eat which looked fantastic but if it's good pizza I want leftovers. My husband and I ordered the Hometown Favorite with original crust. It was fantastic!! Perfect topping and perfect crust. Greg the owner came by our table and talked with us. Told us to help ourselves to something sweet off the buffet because they were getting ready to close it down. He gave us a pice of pizza off the buffet because he wanted us to sample the thin crust. Where else do you meet such nice people. Small town USA!! Love this place. It will become a regular.
Sandie R.
We were there last night. The best food at a reasonable price. Great salad bar. We had pizza, spaghetti which was huge and so tasty, Lasagna, great, parmesian chicken pasta. All were excellent. Shawna, the manager was very personable and helpful. Will definitely be back
W Johnston
Had a Fantastic pizza Fri night!!!Thx!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
MKP
The pizza isn't carbon circle.Service good but i wait a long time for pay
Had the buffet wasn't
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Delicious exquisite pizza. To further add, the management and I chatted briefly as he rounded the restaurant to personally greet everyone and ask about their experience. I think that says everything necessary as to why our food was worth every dollar paid and assurement of future visits.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Banana Pudding, Cheesestix, All Meat Pizza, Wings, Pizza
My mom and I came in Friday February 16, 2024. When we walked up to the counter a white girl and a black girl were behind the counter one at each register. So the white girl ask my mom can she help her. My mama told her she wanted a large salad and the girl said, “A what(2 times)??” And my mom repeated herself each time and she act like she didn’t know what my mom was saying so my mom spoke loud and told her she wanted a large salad. She gonna say to my mom in a rude way, “YOU AIN’T GOT TO HOLLER”!!! And she walked off and didn’t wait on us!! First of all, she acted like she couldn’t hear her and acted like she was on drugs or something! The black girl waited on us at the register she was on. My mom asked her what was wrong with the other girl and she didn’t say a word. We didn’t get any names but VERY POOR CUSTOMER SERVICE!
Service: 1
Salad bar was nice, except the lettuce was fresh. Pizza was cold and the crust was a prefab factory made crust. For the price, I expected homemade dough. Very disappointing and we won't be back unless we decide to try the salad bar again.
We had heard they had a good salad bar and it was a great selection. Only problem was the iceberg and the Romaine had a little browning and were not chopped enough (which is a personal preference). We had the buffet so now, about the pizza. By the time you walked to your table, it was cold. It was also tasteless. I tried eating only the toppings only to find a prefabricated store bought crust. No wonder it was awful. If you aren’t making crust homemade daily, can you legally use the word pizza in the title of your restaurant? Atmosphere was extremely loud (the staff). At least 5 people running around for 7 customers and I kept seeing people waiting on to go orders. Very inefficient use of staff. And they were loud and seemed to have to asked permission to do everything. Two employees should have been able to handle this business effectively. The online menu had prices at 8.99. We were charged 13.99. For prices comparable to to quality pizza places in Oxford, I definitely wouldn’t recommend this place and would make the drive to Oxford.
My new favorite pizza place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Had the buffet and enjoyed every slice. A hidden gem of a pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The family just moved to Water Valley from Florida. Hometown Pizza Cafe was excellent! We really enjoyed our pizza!
Food: 5
Service: 5
A relaxing atmosphere, very polite and courteous staff, food was very good and the prices are not to high. Would definitely go back!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: All Meat Pizza, Pizza
Great food, nice people!! Overall I enjoyed eating here.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Burger, Wings
Restaurantji Recommends
I found a live huge horse fly in the Parmesan cheese. The waitress was rude after I pointed it out. Not going back...
I'm a little bit of a pizza snob because honestly there is a lot to it. Toppings have to be great and the crust can make it or break it. Went to Hometown Pizza on a Sunday for lunch. They have a all you can eat which looked fantastic but if it's good pizza I want leftovers. My husband and I ordered the Hometown Favorite with original crust. It was fantastic!! Perfect topping and perfect crust. Greg the owner came by our table and talked with us. Told us to help ourselves to something sweet off the buffet because they were getting ready to close it down. He gave us a pice of pizza off the buffet because he wanted us to sample the thin crust. Where else do you meet such nice people. Small town USA!! Love this place. It will become a regular.
We were there last night. The best food at a reasonable price. Great salad bar. We had pizza, spaghetti which was huge and so tasty, Lasagna, great, parmesian chicken pasta. All were excellent. Shawna, the manager was very personable and helpful. Will definitely be back
Had a Fantastic pizza Fri night!!!Thx!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza isn't carbon circle.Service good but i wait a long time for pay
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3