This little spot tucked right on Main Street was the cutest! đ„čâš The second we walked in, it smelled like warm cookies and fresh coffeeâtotal comfort vibes. Blue Deer serves up handcrafted cookie ice cream sandwiches, coffee, and more. And the best part? You get to sample the ice cream before choosing (yes please! đ).
We went all in with two amazing combos: đ« Double chocolate chip cookies + lemon crunch ice cream đ đ Strawberry cheesecake cookies + peach ice cream đ
The flavors were super refreshing, the cookies were warm and chewy, and the whole thing just hit the spot. So good and sooo worth the stop. Cute, cozy, and 100% deliciousâŠ.
Jennifer Cornett-Hodson
If youâre looking for the ultimate ice cream indulgence, this is the place. The ice cream is full-fat, ultra-creamy, and absolutely packed with flavor â no shortcuts or watered-down taste here. Every bite is rich and satisfying, just like real ice cream should be.
The cookies are perfectly soft and chewy, making the ice cream sandwiches feel homemade but elevated. You can tell they care about quality â from the unique flavor pairings to the textures.
And the servings? Huge. These sandwiches are no joke â theyâre big enough to share (but you probably wonât want to). This shop is a must-visit for any dessert lover. Forget the low-fat stuff â this is how ice cream is meant to be enjoyed!
Geoffrey Ross
The ice cream sandwich were good
Tony Rich
The best Icecream Cookies! Yum!đ
Jon L Albee
Come for the ice cream sandwiches, which is the real feature of this tiny shop. It advertises as a cafe, but the coffee is really not why you come. Ice cream sandwiches are huge and the quality of the cookies and the ice cream is excellent. Prices are a bit steep, but it's really good.
I stopped by this coffee shop after seeing the great reviews. I got an Americano, an iced latte, and two cookies. The cookies were good, but I was really disappointed by the drinks. The Americano had way too much waterâŠ. it was honestly undrinkable, couldnât have more than one sip (photo says it all), and the latte wasnât great either :/ I didnât finish it. 2 stars for the cute spot and the cookies.
Ashley
Surprised this place had a 4.8. Cookies taste like cheap store bought, chocolate milkshake was extremely mediocre - idk if it's even worth it to drink it lol. The cookie dough ice cream was also nothing special. Super quick service though! I personally prefer quality.
UPDATE: Milkshake made it to the trash unfinished. No one liked it, we think it was a bad chocolate syrup used with vanilla ice cream to make a chocolate shake. If it was chocolate ice cream... yikes..
Taylor Engel, FL Keys Realtor (South Florida Realtor)
Quiet coffee shop to stop at when the town is crazy. Great choice of seasonal favorites and everyday coffee satisfying all of your needs. They even have sweets and a few Ice cream choices to choose from. Apple cider was amazing on this cold day, peppermint mocha was also delicious!
Danielle Seidel
We started with house made ice cream sandwiches. They were delectable! My only regret was that the sandwiches were so big, I couldnât eat it all. Very reasonably priced! We went back 2 days later and got a fantastic mocha!
Originally from FL and was craving ice cream while it was less than 20° outside while visiting. This store offered great ice cream sandwiches. They also sell muffins! I highly recommend trying the Red Velvet Cookie ice cream sandwich with chocolate ! If you're near the area, I definitely recommend stopping by. FYI: Parking might be a bit of a slight issue if you arrive during a busy weekend, but you can parallel park near the store.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Craig Seely
Most awesome cookies ever. Great drinks. Fast service. Wife was even impressed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
James pugh
What can I say? I came all the way from Florida just to have this coffee, LOL. It's the best pumpkin chai latte I've ever tasted. I came here last year and had to come back this year just to have it again. Of course, I also took in the beautiful scenery of the neighborhood itself. The staff is always great to talk to, and their ice cream sandwiches are amazing. So, if you're looking for a nice coffee joint to get some good coffee, definitely check it out.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Scott Perrin
Order your own custom ice cream cookie sandwich ? What's not to love ...
This little spot tucked right on Main Street was the cutest! đ„čâš The second we walked in, it smelled like warm cookies and fresh coffeeâtotal comfort vibes. Blue Deer serves up handcrafted cookie ice cream sandwiches, coffee, and more. And the best part? You get to sample the ice cream before choosing (yes please! đ).
We went all in with two amazing combos:
đ« Double chocolate chip cookies + lemon crunch ice cream đ
đ Strawberry cheesecake cookies + peach ice cream đ
The flavors were super refreshing, the cookies were warm and chewy, and the whole thing just hit the spot. So good and sooo worth the stop. Cute, cozy, and 100% deliciousâŠ.
If youâre looking for the ultimate ice cream indulgence, this is the place. The ice cream is full-fat, ultra-creamy, and absolutely packed with flavor â no shortcuts or watered-down taste here. Every bite is rich and satisfying, just like real ice cream should be. The cookies are perfectly soft and chewy, making the ice cream sandwiches feel homemade but elevated. You can tell they care about quality â from the unique flavor pairings to the textures. And the servings? Huge. These sandwiches are no joke â theyâre big enough to share (but you probably wonât want to). This shop is a must-visit for any dessert lover. Forget the low-fat stuff â this is how ice cream is meant to be enjoyed!
The ice cream sandwich were good
The best Icecream Cookies! Yum!đ
Come for the ice cream sandwiches, which is the real feature of this tiny shop. It advertises as a cafe, but the coffee is really not why you come. Ice cream sandwiches are huge and the quality of the cookies and the ice cream is excellent. Prices are a bit steep, but it's really good.
I stopped by this coffee shop after seeing the great reviews. I got an Americano, an iced latte, and two cookies. The cookies were good, but I was really disappointed by the drinks. The Americano had way too much waterâŠ. it was honestly undrinkable, couldnât have more than one sip (photo says it all), and the latte wasnât great either :/ I didnât finish it.
2 stars for the cute spot and the cookies.
Surprised this place had a 4.8. Cookies taste like cheap store bought, chocolate milkshake was extremely mediocre - idk if it's even worth it to drink it lol. The cookie dough ice cream was also nothing special. Super quick service though! I personally prefer quality.
UPDATE: Milkshake made it to the trash unfinished. No one liked it, we think it was a bad chocolate syrup used with vanilla ice cream to make a chocolate shake. If it was chocolate ice cream... yikes..
Quiet coffee shop to stop at when the town is crazy. Great choice of seasonal favorites and everyday coffee satisfying all of your needs. They even have sweets and a few Ice cream choices to choose from. Apple cider was amazing on this cold day, peppermint mocha was also delicious!
We started with house made ice cream sandwiches. They were delectable! My only regret was that the sandwiches were so big, I couldnât eat it all. Very reasonably priced! We went back 2 days later and got a fantastic mocha!
Great ice cream sandwiches.
Restaurantji Recommends
Originally from FL and was craving ice cream while it was less than 20° outside while visiting. This store offered great ice cream sandwiches. They also sell muffins! I highly recommend trying the Red Velvet Cookie ice cream sandwich with chocolate ! If you're near the area, I definitely recommend stopping by. FYI: Parking might be a bit of a slight issue if you arrive during a busy weekend, but you can parallel park near the store.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Most awesome cookies ever. Great drinks. Fast service. Wife was even impressed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
What can I say? I came all the way from Florida just to have this coffee, LOL. It's the best pumpkin chai latte I've ever tasted. I came here last year and had to come back this year just to have it again. Of course, I also took in the beautiful scenery of the neighborhood itself. The staff is always great to talk to, and their ice cream sandwiches are amazing. So, if you're looking for a nice coffee joint to get some good coffee, definitely check it out.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Order your own custom ice cream cookie sandwich ? What's not to love ...
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best place to get ice cream in the village.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...