Cheesecakes by Custom Confections, LLC

1187 W Chatham St, Cary
(919) 727-9866

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Heath Toffee Cheesecake and Chocolate Torte
Specialty & Seasonal Cheesecakes
NY w Strawberry Topping Slice
White Chocolate Raspberry
Peanut Butter Bar
Coconut Cream Pie
Peanut Butter Pie
Chocolate Cake
NY Cheesecake

CHEESECAKES by the SLICE
NY (slice)
NY cheesecake baked on a graham cracker crust. Limit 3 per order. Orders with more than 3 of this item will automatically be cancelled.
NY w/ Strawberry Topping (slice)
Our NY cheesecake served with 2 oz. of homemade strawberry topping. Limit 3 per order. Orders with more than 3 of this item will automatically be cancelled.
Cookie Dough (slice)
NY cheesecake with chocolate chips throughout, baked on a layer of our homemade cookie dough. Limit 3 per order. Orders with more than 3 of this item will automatically be cancelled.
Deadly Chocolate (slice)
Chocolate cheesecake over a layer of our rich and fudgy, flourless chocolate torte. (gluten-free) Limit 3 per order. Orders with more than 3 of this item will automatically be cancelled.
Peanut Butter Cup (slice)
Chocolate and peanut butter cheesecake over a layer of peanut butter cups baked on an Oreo and Nutter Butter crust. Limit 3 per order. Orders with more than 3 of this item will automatically be cancelled.
Cookies & Cream (slice)
NY cheesecake with chunks of Oreo cookies throughout, baked on an Oreo crust. Limit 3 per order. Orders with more than 3 of this item will automatically be cancelled.
White Chocolate Raspberry (slice)
NY cheesecake flavored with Ghirardelli white chocolate with ripples of raspberry throughout, baked on an Oreo crust. Limit 3 per order. Orders with more than 3 of this item will automatically be cancelled.

FEATURED FLAVORS by the SLICE
Mint Chocolate (slice)
NY cheesecake with a hint of peppermint and chocolate chips throughout, baked on an Oreo crust. Limit 3 per order. Orders with more than 3 of this item will automatically be cancelled.
Red Velvet (slice)
NY cheesecake over red velvet cake, iced in vanilla buttercream. Limit 3 per order. Orders with more than 3 of this item will automatically be cancelled.
Tiramisu (slice)
NY cheesecake flavored with coffee and coffee liqueur over ladyfingers dipped in additional liqueur. The cake is topped with sweetened mascarpone then iced in whipped cream. Limit 3 per order. Orders with more than 3 of this item will automatically be cancelled.

DESSERT BARS & PASTRIES
Peanut Butter Bar
Imagine an extra large peanut butter cup with a slight, cookie-like texture. (made with natural peanut butter, egg-free). Limit 4 per order. Orders with more than 4 of this item will automatically be cancelled.
Lemon Bar
Extra lemon-y. Limit 4 per order. Orders with more than 4 of this item will automatically be cancelled.
Turtle Bar
Chocolate, caramel and pecans on a buttery short dough. (egg-free). Limit 4 per order. Orders with more than 4 of this item will automatically be cancelled.
Cannoli
Crispy shell filled with sweetened ricotta cream and chocolate chips. Limit 4 per order. Orders with more than 4 of this item will automatically be cancelled.
Crème Puff
Puff pastry filled with white chocolate mousse, dipped in a chocolate glaze. Limit 4 per order. Orders with more than 4 of this item will automatically be cancelled.
Whoopie Pie
Chocolate, cake-like cookies with vanilla buttercream in between. Limit 4 per order. Orders with more than 4 of this item will automatically be cancelled.
Cupcake
Standard 2" vanilla cupcake topped with vanilla buttercream. Limit 4 per order. Orders with more than 4 of this item will automatically be cancelled.

PIES & ADDITIONAL PRODUCTS
Chocolate Torte (slice)
A rich and fudgy, gluten-free cake made with 4 simple ingredients - chocolate, butter, eggs and sugar. Limit 3 per order.
Peanut Butter Pie (slice)
Creamy, peanut butter filling in a chocolate cookie shell. Limit 3 per order
Nutella Cream Pie (slice)
Creamy chocolate filling made with Nutella hazelnut spread in a chocolate cookie crust. Limit 3 per order
Mocha Cookies & Cream Pie (slice)
Creamy coffee filling with chunks of Oreo cookies throughout in our homemade chocolate cookie crust. Limit 3 per order

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: google
+75 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+74 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Love this spot! Have tried so many bakeries in the area for the best cheese cake. Hands down this is #1. Do wish they had tiny samples to be able to try new flavors if you go in person.
October 2025
Partner and I got a few slices to try!

-The base NY cheesecake slice is solid, with great flavor and texture (more creamy).
-The Irish cream coffee cheesecake slice was also really good, and hit a rich nice coffee and chocolate taste while not tasting too fake or gimmicky with it.
-The cookie dough cheesecake was not bad, if that is what you're looking for.

The rest of their desserts also looked good, and we would check...
October 2025
My wife and I love this shop! Their cheesecakes are always fresh not frozen for a month. Delicious varieties always available and the staff is wonderful! Give them a try and you will thank me!!!!
Patrick
September 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Domino's Pizza - 1183 W Chatham St
Pizza, Chicken Wings, Vegetarian
Abbey Road Tavern & Grill - 1195 W Chatham St
Bar & Grill, Bar, American, Pet Friendly, Vegetarian
Arpan Mart - 1107 Ballena Cir
Indian

Cheesecakes by Custom Confections, LLC

1187 W Chatham St, Cary, NC 27513
(919) 727-9866