Came here for an Uber Eats pickup around 1AM because the business was still showing as open in the app — and according to their hours, they’re listed as open until 12:30AM. It’s located inside a courthouse complex — there was lighting, signage, and even some cars in the lot, so it wasn’t immediately obvious that the bakery itself was closed. I called and texted the number listed and got no response, even when I tried again the next afternoon. If you’re not from the area, it can feel weird or even sketchy pulling up to a government building that late — especially when there’s no clear signage saying the business is closed. It’s not just about wasted time — it can lead to unnecessary interactions with law enforcement. Please update your hours and keep your contact info active. This is about safety, not just convenience. Food looks delicious though — wish I got to try it under better circumstances.
Susan Harrington
VERY DISAPPOINTED!! All I’m saying is $8 for this. Y’all really playing in people faces. This is not an individual cookie cake. This is just a cookie. I thought when I was spending $8 for something called an “individual cookie cake” it would be around the size of an individual pizza (6 inches in diameter). What is this?! The box isn’t even 6 inches long. Edited: I did do an online pick up order however was not directed to a shop, but a random company. I don’t knock small businesses and is very understanding of circumstances (especially in the current economy). So, I never knew if there was a place for me to go into and look around (without the 30% up charge)… Also, a cookie cake is roughly the size of a pizza; given that it is only about an inch of cookie topped with icing. Apologizing that your product wasn’t “big enough for me” when you know (given that you are in the baking business) certain measurements for specific products. What’s the difference between a regular cookie with icing and your “individual cookie cake”? You don’t see individual cakes sold the size of cupcakes so please stop playing in peoples faces. Thank you!
Food: 3
CCA
To answer your question. I was in the store about 5mo ago. I take my time to do my reviews. What I got was very over priced for what it was and very dry and stale and hard. Icing was dry like it's been there for 2 days. I wait to do my reviews to make sure of a few things most of all making sure I'm not reacting without thinking. And I think it was you that was beside the counter that day. Just by they way you reacting now. If it was you nasty attitude from whom was working that day around lunch time. I was going to try to save face but had to respond and not knowing what you were talking about. Hope you feel better now. May you have lots of fun
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Scott Jordan
Went to Sweet Fare on a daddy daughter date. She loved the decor. Whimsical, she called it. It's geared toward little ones. I felt it was a bit pricey, but some of the combinations were interesting, like the key lime pie cookie. Overall, I could crunch sugar in the butterscotch cookie we tried. It was pretty good. However, as an adult, I'm beyond filling in flavor with pure sugar. Though one look at Sweet Fare, and I know I'm not the target audience. It was a cute little stop. It's too pricey for me to bring all four children to at one time. But it was a nice stop on our date. Overall 3 stars for food, 4 for interior and decor. So the kids will be all about it. As an adult, it was ok.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Aurora
This is such a cute little bakery!! I asked that they do a gender reveal cake for my baby and they nailed it at the best price in both the Cary and Raleigh area. The cake was delicious and got so many complements ?
Cyndi Cansler
The oatmeal cream pie was massive and delicious!
Aurora P
This is such a cute little bakery!! I asked that they do a gender reveal cake for my baby and they nailed it at the best price in both the Cary and Raleigh area. The cake was delicious and got so many complements
Elizabeth Anderson
My kids and I stopped here after playing at Over the Moon around the corner, and we loved the bright, cheery space and the variety of treats! I ordered a carrot cake with tons of perfect cream cheese (carrot cake was my ideal — walnuts, pineapple, raisins!); my kids chose a red velvet cupcake and a chocolate dump truck. They even had an ancho chili tangerine truffle for my husband who likes spicy over sweet! This is our new go-to for treats when we’re in the area!
Abi Turner (Buzbuz9)
The pastries were only okay, they don't have a nice stilling area to hang out at and the cashier that was helping us didn't know anything about the products. I would suggest going somewhere else if you are looking for dessert, but they do custom cake orders which looked pretty reasonable and quick
Dori DeJong
We ordered cupcakes for an outer space themed baby shower, and they were excellent. Not only were the cupcakes gorgeous, but they were delicious and fun. We had the pumpkin, confetti, and chocolate cupcakes. Everyone raved. Highly recommend the baked goods and sweets from Sweet Fare.
Absolutely delicious and the customer service has been fantastic each time we’ve so far! Definitely try the blueberry pancake cake, the carrot cake, and the raspberry cheesecake sandwich cookie or the treat flights are a great way to try a little bit of everything!
Mackenzie Myers
The desserts here are delicious, creative, and so fun! There's truly something for everyone, and there is always something new to try. I absolutely adore this place!
Came here for an Uber Eats pickup around 1AM because the business was still showing as open in the app — and according to their hours, they’re listed as open until 12:30AM. It’s located inside a courthouse complex — there was lighting, signage, and even some cars in the lot, so it wasn’t immediately obvious that the bakery itself was closed. I called and texted the number listed and got no response, even when I tried again the next afternoon. If you’re not from the area, it can feel weird or even sketchy pulling up to a government building that late — especially when there’s no clear signage saying the business is closed. It’s not just about wasted time — it can lead to unnecessary interactions with law enforcement. Please update your hours and keep your contact info active. This is about safety, not just convenience. Food looks delicious though — wish I got to try it under better circumstances.
VERY DISAPPOINTED!! All I’m saying is $8 for this. Y’all really playing in people faces. This is not an individual cookie cake. This is just a cookie. I thought when I was spending $8 for something called an “individual cookie cake” it would be around the size of an individual pizza (6 inches in diameter). What is this?! The box isn’t even 6 inches long.
Edited:
I did do an online pick up order however was not directed to a shop, but a random company. I don’t knock small businesses and is very understanding of circumstances (especially in the current economy). So, I never knew if there was a place for me to go into and look around (without the 30% up charge)… Also, a cookie cake is roughly the size of a pizza; given that it is only about an inch of cookie topped with icing. Apologizing that your product wasn’t “big enough for me” when you know (given that you are in the baking business) certain measurements for specific products. What’s the difference between a regular cookie with icing and your “individual cookie cake”? You don’t see individual cakes sold the size of cupcakes so please stop playing in peoples faces. Thank you!
Food: 3
To answer your question. I was in the store about 5mo ago. I take my time to do my reviews. What I got was very over priced for what it was and very dry and stale and hard. Icing was dry like it's been there for 2 days. I wait to do my reviews to make sure of a few things most of all making sure I'm not reacting without thinking. And I think it was you that was beside the counter that day. Just by they way you reacting now. If it was you nasty attitude from whom was working that day around lunch time. I was going to try to save face but had to respond and not knowing what you were talking about. Hope you feel better now. May you have lots of fun
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Went to Sweet Fare on a daddy daughter date. She loved the decor. Whimsical, she called it. It's geared toward little ones. I felt it was a bit pricey, but some of the combinations were interesting, like the key lime pie cookie. Overall, I could crunch sugar in the butterscotch cookie we tried. It was pretty good. However, as an adult, I'm beyond filling in flavor with pure sugar. Though one look at Sweet Fare, and I know I'm not the target audience. It was a cute little stop. It's too pricey for me to bring all four children to at one time. But it was a nice stop on our date. Overall 3 stars for food, 4 for interior and decor. So the kids will be all about it. As an adult, it was ok.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
This is such a cute little bakery!! I asked that they do a gender reveal cake for my baby and they nailed it at the best price in both the Cary and Raleigh area. The cake was delicious and got so many complements ?
The oatmeal cream pie was massive and delicious!
This is such a cute little bakery!! I asked that they do a gender reveal cake for my baby and they nailed it at the best price in both the Cary and Raleigh area. The cake was delicious and got so many complements
My kids and I stopped here after playing at Over the Moon around the corner, and we loved the bright, cheery space and the variety of treats! I ordered a carrot cake with tons of perfect cream cheese (carrot cake was my ideal — walnuts, pineapple, raisins!); my kids chose a red velvet cupcake and a chocolate dump truck. They even had an ancho chili tangerine truffle for my husband who likes spicy over sweet! This is our new go-to for treats when we’re in the area!
The pastries were only okay, they don't have a nice stilling area to hang out at and the cashier that was helping us didn't know anything about the products. I would suggest going somewhere else if you are looking for dessert, but they do custom cake orders which looked pretty reasonable and quick
We ordered cupcakes for an outer space themed baby shower, and they were excellent. Not only were the cupcakes gorgeous, but they were delicious and fun. We had the pumpkin, confetti, and chocolate cupcakes. Everyone raved. Highly recommend the baked goods and sweets from Sweet Fare.
Restaurantji Recommends
Absolutely delicious and the customer service has been fantastic each time we’ve so far! Definitely try the blueberry pancake cake, the carrot cake, and the raspberry cheesecake sandwich cookie or the treat flights are a great way to try a little bit of everything!
The desserts here are delicious, creative, and so fun! There's truly something for everyone, and there is always something new to try. I absolutely adore this place!
Kind service and clean environment
It’s so delicious and decretive
Mmmmm yes very good
Loading...