The Original NY Pizza

831 Bass Pro Ln, Cary
(919) 677-8484

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Achilles Kostopoulos

Delicious and crust was crispy

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jason Bonomo

Excellent pizza, my favorite in the area. True NY pizza

Vincent DeCaro

I made the mistake of ordering from the wrk g location and the staff at the Bass Pro location were really very nice about the whole thing. Plus the pizza was freaking awesome as always.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Daniel Smyrski

One bite, everyone knows the rules and these guys kill it for authentic NY style thin crust slices! Great under carriage/crisp, nice tang to the sauce, right amount of other seasoning. Portnoy would be impressed!

Caitlin

I am long overdue with this review. This has been our go-to local pizza place for years. Reliable, delicious, really nice guys working there, and if you sign up for their loyalty program you get $10 off every now and then! Give them a try!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

brent brondyke

Really good pizza and antipasto was generous portion

Joseph Balbi

The pizza šŸ• is Great here! Take it from a New Yorker with high expectations. Quan is the King of making pizzas ! Highly recommended, great food and staff, can’t go wrong!!!

Timothy Lake

Great NY style pizza that reminds me of home.

Zary'ya Corbin

There are some good days, and some bad days--Individual slices are overpriced at nearly $5, so you may as well get a pie.
Depending on who's in there, you may end up with a re-heated, over-cheesed and old pie, or you will get an authentic, New York taste. I would recommend going earlier than later, when they're fresh, they're good.

Juanito Sabroso

Native New Yorker here - this is GOOD Pizza !

Kodiak Kid

2nd time eating here. Sicilian pizza is off the hook! Affordable and great staff!!!?

jacquelinet655

Never, ever did I think I would find one of the best pizzas I’d ever eaten in a little strip Mall in Cary! The pizza was done to perfection! The dough, just right, not ladened with too much and the sauce not too watery. The Sicilian slice I had was also great, just right crunchy, burnished with just a dab of olive oil crust and the sauce and cheese, again balancing out ( and not overpowering) the taste. Will for sure make this a pit stop every time I’m traveling through the area. Yum!

Craig Wright

There is not an abundance of good NY style pizza in the Triangle. This place is a shining beacon of hope for NY pizza lovers like myself. Pizza by the slice is awesome to have as an option. Pizza is great!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Stuffed, Pepperoni Pizza, Sicilian Pizza

Sally Scott

This restaurant is really dirty. The floors and tables were dirty and the men’s restroom was disgusting. There was only one pizza available to buy by the slice (cheese). The taste was ok but lacked substance. The employees were unfriendly and didn’t care much about the pizza or helping customers. We will not eat here again!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

yolan shiffrin

It’s definitely NY pizza. They care about their customers too. I happily recommend their food. I couldn’t say about their atmosphere because I haven’t been there but their delivery is always great.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Extra Large Pizza

Loading...