The Original NY Pizza

6458 Tryon Rd, Cary
(919) 852-2242

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Desiree OConnor

I ordered a chicken calzone and the chicken inside was not cooked very well. Being from New York was expecting a lot more. For the price to calzone was very small however, the gentleman working the counter and that one that took my order was very nice and pleasant.

Dominic Chirico

Honestly, barely edible. We were all starving and it still tasted like garbage. Paid $70 for two pizzas and some “cheesy bread”.

Ines Rios

Great service , very kind and chill people

James Michael Fidotta

Great food.

Patrick M

One of the best NY pizza places in the south. From a New Yorker.

Steven M

Fantastic Food and Service every time!! Been coming here since 2015

Josh Unruh

Top tier service and the best pizza in the triangle! I’ve been eating here since I moved to Cary in 2008. 10/10

Roxanne Nolan

Ordered the deep dish, 1 salad, and garlic knots. Pickup said 15 minutes, although it took 50. I had to keep checking in with the cashier and requesting my items as even though they had ticket, they could not tell me what my order was. Never received garlic knots and got tired of waiting. Pizza toppings were generous.

Sofia W

Had the ham and cheese calzone delivered. It was very good and cheesy. The dipping marinara sauce was very good too.

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Sauce

Maya Shostak

the pizza was amazing; best pizza around. however; i ordered a medium veggie pizza and got charged 27 DOLLARS. i looked it up later and a medium veggie pizza costs $17. a large, $20.

Kimberly Griffin-Davis

Service was very nice but my taste for pizza it wasn't my preference. My boyfriend, who is from NJ, loves it.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 5

Robert Amarante

Good pizza, fast delivery, friendly service!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Wendy Doig

Last two pizzas were terrible. The one today was burnt. Didn’t eat it

Michael Crawford

Let me tell you!!!! I'm from New Jersey, but because I live in Georgia, my idea of good pizza is Domino's. I was up visiting my daughter and, OH MY God!!! The pizza here is reminiscent of New York, New Jersey, and Philly!!! They even have Stromboli's, Calzone's, too. CHECK THIS PLACE OUT NOW!!!! Don't wait until tonight, go there NOW!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Greek Salad, Extra Large Pizza, Garlic Knots

Joel Bauer

Yujin did an amazing job. Guy was working alone and made a fantastic wrap and pizza. Give this guy his own restaurant!

Loading...