We went with another couple specifically to enjoy Restaurant week and loved it! The $15 wine pairing was fabulous and food delicious! Our server was Marisa and we would absolutely love to be seated in her section again - she was super helpful with recommendations, attentive & just a very pleasant person! Can't wait to return!
Martine
Our server was wonderful, but unfortunately the two hostesses working the host stand had quite an attitude and made us feel very unwelcome.
AnnMarie
Always a lovely experience to walk through the Mayton Inn and head to Peck and Plume. Our server was great. The person serving the food kept on bringing food to our table that wasn't ours, which was kind of funny (because it happened a few times). Drinks were good. Food was good. Definitely a nice spot for a meal in downtown Cary.
Danielle
The food was wonderful, the ambiance and atmosphere were terrific, and our server was thoughtful and kind
Janice
Absolutely incredible experience. Service, food, ambience was just perfect. We sat in the library so a little quieter than the restaurant. I look forward to returning when it's warmer to sit outside on the patio.
Jason
The meal felt very rushed. On more than one occasion they tried to clear my our plates before we were finished. The overall timing of plates was fine, but they were trying to clear plate immediately. Also, the food was very mediocre. The oysters were weird and flavorless. The lobster pasta was good, not great. The cake was dense and dry. The best thing we ate was the cheese plate. It was New Years Eve, so maybe this is the reason for some of this. But, we would likely not eat here again unless we had a gift card.
Dr. Mia
We made a reservation for a small group of 10 this Sunday. Everything was excellent! The food was good, came out in a timely manner, and most of all our server was excellent!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Laura McEwen
We had a wonderful dinner tonight at Peck and Plume. Chef Greg’s brussel sprouts were out of this world. Every dish was so well executed and enjoyed by the whole table. Claire, the bartender, served my husband one of the best old fashions he’s ever had. Our server Logan was super friendly, knowledgeable about the menu, and attentive throughout the night. Definitely would recommend -10/10!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
S S
I recently had breakfast here, and the food was fantastic—fresh, delicious, and well-prepared. The service was equally great; my server, Morgan, was wonderful: friendly, attentive, and truly made the experience enjoyable. The restaurant itself is very cute and has a warm, welcoming atmosphere.
The only reason I’m not giving five stars is because of the way I observed the manager, Jericho, speaking to several staff members. It was uncomfortable and off-putting, and it took away from an otherwise excellent visit. The team works hard and deserves to be treated with respect.
I hope this is something the restaurant will address, because the food and service are outstanding and I would love to continue supporting the business.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Katherine
My favorite place to meet friends for lunch, and introduce them to Cary in such a delightful setting!
Our waiter was pleasant and knowledgeable, but once our food was (mostly) delivered, he never checked back with us.. no butter for the toast that was delivered, no ability to ask a question, etc. We will go back, I am sure, but there was some frustration.
Jonathan
Had a great time here - food and service were top notch. Main room can get a little loud when crowded. Minor complaint had a great brunch date here!
Tracey
A very disappointing experience. We asked for a simple omelette, that became a frittata, with an ingredient we never asked for. We waited and waited until a manager got engaged, who was actually able to get us the omelette we originally wanted, but the whole experience left me feeling like I don't need to return.
Tom G
Very relaxing restaurant where you can have a good conversation with your food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kevin
Our server, Brian, was best in class. Ambiance and food was good and we would dine again at this restaurant.
We went with another couple specifically to enjoy Restaurant week and loved it! The $15 wine pairing was fabulous and food delicious! Our server was Marisa and we would absolutely love to be seated in her section again - she was super helpful with recommendations, attentive & just a very pleasant person! Can't wait to return!
Our server was wonderful, but unfortunately the two hostesses working the host stand had quite an attitude and made us feel very unwelcome.
Always a lovely experience to walk through the Mayton Inn and head to Peck and Plume. Our server was great. The person serving the food kept on bringing food to our table that wasn't ours, which was kind of funny (because it happened a few times). Drinks were good. Food was good. Definitely a nice spot for a meal in downtown Cary.
The food was wonderful, the ambiance and atmosphere were terrific, and our server was thoughtful and kind
Absolutely incredible experience. Service, food, ambience was just perfect. We sat in the library so a little quieter than the restaurant. I look forward to returning when it's warmer to sit outside on the patio.
The meal felt very rushed. On more than one occasion they tried to clear my our plates before we were finished. The overall timing of plates was fine, but they were trying to clear plate immediately. Also, the food was very mediocre. The oysters were weird and flavorless. The lobster pasta was good, not great. The cake was dense and dry. The best thing we ate was the cheese plate. It was New Years Eve, so maybe this is the reason for some of this. But, we would likely not eat here again unless we had a gift card.
We made a reservation for a small group of 10 this Sunday. Everything was excellent! The food was good, came out in a timely manner, and most of all our server was excellent!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had a wonderful dinner tonight at Peck and Plume. Chef Greg’s brussel sprouts were out of this world. Every dish was so well executed and enjoyed by the whole table. Claire, the bartender, served my husband one of the best old fashions he’s ever had. Our server Logan was super friendly, knowledgeable about the menu, and attentive throughout the night. Definitely would recommend -10/10!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I recently had breakfast here, and the food was fantastic—fresh, delicious, and well-prepared. The service was equally great; my server, Morgan, was wonderful: friendly, attentive, and truly made the experience enjoyable. The restaurant itself is very cute and has a warm, welcoming atmosphere.
The only reason I’m not giving five stars is because of the way I observed the manager, Jericho, speaking to several staff members. It was uncomfortable and off-putting, and it took away from an otherwise excellent visit. The team works hard and deserves to be treated with respect.
I hope this is something the restaurant will address, because the food and service are outstanding and I would love to continue supporting the business.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My favorite place to meet friends for lunch, and introduce them to Cary in such a delightful setting!
Restaurantji Recommends
Our waiter was pleasant and knowledgeable, but once our food was (mostly) delivered, he never checked back with us.. no butter for the toast that was delivered, no ability to ask a question, etc. We will go back, I am sure, but there was some frustration.
Had a great time here - food and service were top notch. Main room can get a little loud when crowded. Minor complaint had a great brunch date here!
A very disappointing experience. We asked for a simple omelette, that became a frittata, with an ingredient we never asked for. We waited and waited until a manager got engaged, who was actually able to get us the omelette we originally wanted, but the whole experience left me feeling like I don't need to return.
Very relaxing restaurant where you can have a good conversation with your food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Our server, Brian, was best in class. Ambiance and food was good and we would dine again at this restaurant.
Loading...