The Herringbone Edenton

119 W Water St, Edenton
(252) 368-1068

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Amy Hiner Vallorani

We went for brunch on a Sunday. We didn’t have a reservation, so we sat at the bar, but the food was great and our bartender was very attentive. It’s a beautiful place. We will be back!

Beckie Freeman

Hard to get in without reservation

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Shrimp & Grits, Steak

KayKay Andrews

The food was okay but not worth the money but I will not be back specifically because of the table runner. I have never come across someone so rude within the restaurant business. My niece food came out cold and my sisters steak was cooked not to her request. The runner already had an attitude beforehand but after they came back with the steak she practically threw the plate at my sister. The kids chicken tenders were inediable even by adult standards. They tasted like frozen chicken thrown into a fryer. The entire evenings encounter was ruined by her continuous rudeness. Our sever was incredible though. Unfortunately, the runner will be the reason I will not return

Christina Davis

It was pretty good. I'd say it didn't quite live up to the hype for me. Great location and cordial professional staff. I didn't think my cocktail was as the menu described. The food was good just not great for me.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 4

john buchheit

The town is really cute. I was excited to come to this restaurant . The location is amazing and the building is cool. That is the plus. Came into an empty bar they had music playing on a Monday night with a few tables in the bar, Which we though was really cool . We decided to sit at the completely empty bar, We sat there for over 5 minutes to be completely ignored by the bartender, No eye contact ,NO I will be one minute, no nothing we were about to get up and leave and a cute waitress apologized to us so. The bartender made you feel like you were busting a private party ,not sure if it was or not. We decided to go into the dining room the food was not so good. I got soup which was extremely spicy and the chicken bowl . It was awful and looked like someone got sick and they served it. They had a lot of burgers on the menu so I probably should have got the burger. On our way out we just felt very unwelcomed by the attitude in the bar. Our waitress was the best thing about this place . Sad because this place could be amazing. But when the first person you encounter acts like your are invisible does not make it feel like a place I would return to.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 2

Gina Butler

John was our server he was fantastic 👏

Parking: Not very clear where to park or what door to go in

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kim & Jim Grauel, Jr.

This place is just a miss..:the food is bad, the drinks are bad, and the service is bad. Everyone was friendly enough, they just weren’t very good at their jobs. The food presents as bad as it tastes, and having a brunch menu until 4pm is ridiculous. Really wanted to like this place, but management really needs to read some of these reviews and make changes.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 1

Joe Richardson

Great atmosphere! Such a relaxing place and great staff! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

David Douglas

Sat down watching the servers at the bar help everyone else. Walked out after 5 minutes. I am the invisible man

Service: 2

Ryan Andrews

Good pizza that's the only good food the staff was slow and the manager was rude when we asked to remove the undercooked oysters we ordered

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 3

Mike Miller

The manager made my wife feel uncomfortable by his gawking at her to the point he fell over someone else’s chair while staring at her. This behavior happened multiple times and is very unprofessional. The food was good and our waitress was awesome!!

Food: 3

Service: 5

K.B. ogden

Nice atmosphere. Employees behind the bar need to learn how to smile and be polite.
Pricing was ok. Food was very good.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 3

Ronald Phillips

We try to like The Herringbone, but leave unimpressed and disappointed after each visit. Dinner for two there a few weeks ago (outdoors). It was daylight when we sat down, but the order took so long, it was dark and my Arribbiata was cold. Didn’t want to upset our guests, so I had it boxed and took it home. Attended dinner with 13 last night. Drink orders, you need to order a double as it takes so long to get served. Ordered the Crab Cake w/Arugula and found the portion smaller than small. Again it took forever for food to arrive. When 12 of us had nearly completed our meals, my wife’s salad arrived. Needless to say, she was not going to accept it. We paid our bill and left. Restaurant is beautiful, food and service are well below par.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 1

Ronald Kuebler

See yelp review. Terrible service; received food with extremely long delay denied by manager. Finally two entrees out of 4 arrived with other two 5-10 monutes later, delayed water refreshing. Won’t come back and reported same to hostess!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 1

Joyce Lazzara

I decided to dine in and sit at the bar. I was a little disappointed when most a few of the beers I wanted were not available but that wasn’t to any fault of the restaurant. I understand supply issues going on right now.
I ordered the peppercorn New York strip and it was cooked perfectly. I also added crab to the top and it was a delicious pairing. As a bonus I ordered the Brussels sprouts… if you haven’t had them yet I highly recommend you try them. This was my second time visiting the restaurant, and I will definitely be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Vanilla Creme Brulee

Loading...