Johnnys Pizza Fuquay

Never a bad experience here. Staff are always great. Food is always good. Love the pizza and cheese steaks.

DELICIOUS! I usually come here weekly. I've tried their calzone, stromboli, and pizza. Their food is always consistent. The dining area is clean, and employees are always friendly.

My slice of Hawaiian pizza was a generous size ,tasty and ready in no time.

From the moment I walked into Johnny’s for the first time, I knew I’d never be the same. As soon as I sat down, I was speedily greeted by the wonderful Will/Billy then he began to take our orders with care and consideration. The beverage options are plentiful and if you happen to be served by William I recommend asking him to make you a surprise drink. The food arrives with a smile and steam from it floods your vision. Cheese is delicious and melty and they have really good black olives. Bathrooms are spacious and clean, its easy to see that all those that work there have the upmost respect for their establishment. You can tell Johnny was an italian man, and I imagine he still spends summers there with his nonna, continuing to learn from her infinite wisdom.

If you want the closest, you can come to a Brooklyn pizzeria, then Johnny's is for you. Ask formthe special, 2 slices and a drink.

The pizza is great but not worth the price they charge. Plenty of other great pizza options for a MUCH better price. I have come to Johnny's a few times out of convenience however after spending $77 on 2 pizzas and 2 salads, then trying to explain the price online was different than what they had instore and was told prices vary. I can say convenient or not I will be taking my business to another establishment. The food is NOT worth the money.

I ordered the buy one get one free and I really tried it because someone recommended the place to me. The dough was so so tough it's insane. I was better off walking across the street to Pizza Hut. The flavour of the pizza itself wasnt good either. I wouldn't order again

This is hands down the closest to New York pizza that you will get in this area. The crust is very close to the same as how it tastes in New York, think they might actually get dough from up there sometimes with the way it tastes. I've never ordered anything other than pizza here fyi

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

I carry out always, but my husband started out with their veggie subs and became addicted! He came home and told me they have gf pizza and subs. Knowing I have had the worst time finding an acceptable gf pizza, well I tried both and I will not think of going anywhere else. We have gotten my parents hooked now and we are weekly customers! I highly recommend.

Food: 5

Great service and food ! Wish we had a JP near Garner 42 area.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Chicken Wings

Delicious pepperoni stromboli. Very friendly staff. I'll be coming back to try the Sicilian pizza.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Normally don’t write reviews but I just had a slice of pizza from here it was perfect! Will come back and try other things out.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

JP & the food were incredible. He went out of his way to make sure that EVERYONE in the restaurant felt like at home.
If I ever come back to Fuquay I will 100% stop by.

Thank you for everything.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lots of terrible ratings recently should be enough to keep you from wasting your time and money here.

Food was ready but I guess they couldn't be bothered to remember my name . I was the only person waiting.... you just aren't that important. Little ceasers is faster and a quarter of the price for the same experience.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

I paid $70 for 3 pizzas that smelled awful, and was some of the worst tasting pizza I have ever eaten. I could only eat one piece it was so bad.

Food: 1