We used this bakery for our wedding cake and it turned out absolutely delicious and beautiful. It was exactly what I had envisioned and the cake tasted so good! Their customer service is also great, they asked me multiple times what I wanted just to be sure they got it right! I would 100% recommend this bakery and will be returning :)
Tim Yuhas
Amazing, beautiful cakes!
The Supraholic
We started across the street at the new coffee shop and headed to this adorable bakery after! Such a treat!!! đ§đâ¨Delicious cupcakes and cookies in a good variety of flavors, they were also finishing up a custom cake for someone when we first arrived. It was beautiful!
Punitha
I ordered a cake here for my bfâs 30th Birthday. The cake I ordered was not visually pleasing. I wanted to keep it very minimalistic by choosing a chocolate cake and a white frosting. And I asked them to write âHappy Birthdayâ and followed by a red heart. The employee suggested putting a heart on the side and I said okay. But it didnât look good how the cake came out. And the frosting was too creamy and thick and way too sweet. The cake was also too hard and the mouthfeel wasnât appealing. I work as a food product developer so I donât want to make any false statements here. But the sensory feel of the cake wasnât pleasant. I also had a feeling that it was not freshly made because I had freshly baked cakes before. Not meaning to be rude but this cake cannot even be compared with a grocery store cake. I feel like they have to improve some things. Overall I have a mixed feeling for that 50$ cake.
Also, I had to wait for some minutes because the woman at the counter was attending to another customer and they were just talking longer than not needed honestly and she didnât care to say âPlease wait I will be right back with youâ. Another employee came out of the baking room thatâs when I had to interrupt and ask her about picking up my cake. So I think less talking and more working also helps customers to have positive feedback about the place. Too much talking is not needed when you have other customers waiting in line. Other than that I would give the other two employees some good credit for being attentive.
Linda Jenkins
I have come here to get cakes for my kids and grandkids for years. Every time I come back out of convenience itâs why Iâm reminded I shouldnât have. Quality and customer service has really gone down hill since I started coming in 2019. Overall disappointed.
Susan Jones
I ordered a birthday cake for my son (he is attending college in Gunnison). The cake was decorated amazingly and was very well enjoyed by he and his friends. Super easy to order!
Jason Nantz
We used Cake Me Away Bakery for our wedding cake and could be happier! The cake was absolutely amazing and the service was unmatched! They even offered to deliver our cake last minute to ensure it arrived safe and sound! Couldnât recommend them more!
Steven Williamson
I recently had their Strawberry Champagne cake at a birthday party. It was out of this world! Went today and got the banana pudding cheesecake. It was delicious! Great customer service! I can't wait to go back and try more goodies! Support local businesses!
Randy Smith
I stopped in tonight to try some cupcakes. I purchased a dozen and letâs just say I didnât want to share after my first bite. It was amazing, the shop is set up wonderful and such nice people behind the counter. I will be recommending to all of my friends and family. You all rock!!!!
Angel Lemley
Great desserts! Especially the chocolate cake & chocolate pie. Pastries are delicious đ
I ordered a cake for a baby shower and it was beautifully done and was moist and just a great cake!! I will definitely be ordering again!
Alanna Lowe
Very helpful and reliable! Made us a cake last minute when our other baker canceled. Weâve ordered about five times and so delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gina Chiverton
I bought the white chocolate raspberry cake and the triple chocolate cupcake. The were both delicious. I will definitely be back to try more delicious cakes.
Jessie Carty
I was in town to volunteer and wanted to pick up some treats that would hold up while I was volunteering and the recommended selections did hold up well!
Service was great. I'd say the chocolate chip cookie and brownie were the best of my purchases. The snicker doodle and peanut butter bar seemed a little ... Grainy maybe? I think I wanted just a bit more flavor.
I definitely want to go back and try a few more items!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Heather Reynolds
Horrible. Unprofessional. Completely unreliable. I filled out a cake request form weeks in advance of my twins' birthday for two simple small round cakes. They emailed me back a day or two later with a detailed form to fill out and send back, which I did, along with some photos, and they said they'd get back to me shortly with a quote. Then nothing for TWO WEEKS!! I had to email THEM twice to follow up and ask about the status of my request. They replied and said they were still working on it. After two weeks of this, I thought they must be putting together a design to show me, a 3D model image or *something*, because what else could take that long? My request wasn't involved or complex at all. Just two kids cakes. Finally, I get a text out of nowhere, a few DAYS before their birthday with the most basic run-on text description and a ridiculous price. They'll never get our business, and we're telling family and friends to avoid them also. I don't want someone else to go through this and possibly be screwed by this stupid bakery for their special event. I went with another bakery and the cakes were less than $40 each.
Here is the text from them:
Good evening Heather this is Cake me away bakery reaching out with pricing for this weekends inquiry. for the harry potter/ pusheen cake we can do a 8" 2 layer cake iced in a dark blue with stars and an edible image of harry potter cat on top and pumpkin and ghosts on the side. The cost for this cake would be between $110-125 depending on the final design. For the minecraft cake we can for a 8" 2 layer square cake iced in pink and have a fondant face like the photo sent and the price would be between $110-125. the next steps would be finalizing the details and paying a deposit of half to confirm and place the order. Please let us know if you have any questions.
We used this bakery for our wedding cake and it turned out absolutely delicious and beautiful. It was exactly what I had envisioned and the cake tasted so good! Their customer service is also great, they asked me multiple times what I wanted just to be sure they got it right! I would 100% recommend this bakery and will be returning :)
Amazing, beautiful cakes!
We started across the street at the new coffee shop and headed to this adorable bakery after!
Such a treat!!! đ§đâ¨Delicious cupcakes and cookies in a good variety of flavors, they were also finishing up a custom cake for someone when we first arrived. It was beautiful!
I ordered a cake here for my bfâs 30th Birthday. The cake I ordered was not visually pleasing. I wanted to keep it very minimalistic by choosing a chocolate cake and a white frosting. And I asked them to write âHappy Birthdayâ and followed by a red heart.
The employee suggested putting a heart on the side and I said okay. But it didnât look good how the cake came out. And the frosting was too creamy and thick and way too sweet.
The cake was also too hard and the mouthfeel wasnât appealing.
I work as a food product developer so I donât want to make any false statements here. But the sensory feel of the cake wasnât pleasant. I also had a feeling that it was not freshly made because I had freshly baked cakes before. Not meaning to be rude but this cake cannot even be compared with a grocery store cake.
I feel like they have to improve some things.
Overall I have a mixed feeling for that 50$ cake.
Also, I had to wait for some minutes because the woman at the counter was attending to another customer and they were just talking longer than not needed honestly and she didnât care to say âPlease wait I will be right back with youâ. Another employee came out of the baking room thatâs when I had to interrupt and ask her about picking up my cake.
So I think less talking and more working also helps customers to have positive feedback about the place. Too much talking is not needed when you have other customers waiting in line.
Other than that I would give the other two employees some good credit for being attentive.
I have come here to get cakes for my kids and grandkids for years. Every time I come back out of convenience itâs why Iâm reminded I shouldnât have. Quality and customer service has really gone down hill since I started coming in 2019. Overall disappointed.
I ordered a birthday cake for my son (he is attending college in Gunnison). The cake was decorated amazingly and was very well enjoyed by he and his friends. Super easy to order!
We used Cake Me Away Bakery for our wedding cake and could be happier! The cake was absolutely amazing and the service was unmatched! They even offered to deliver our cake last minute to ensure it arrived safe and sound! Couldnât recommend them more!
I recently had their Strawberry Champagne cake at a birthday party. It was out of this world! Went today and got the banana pudding cheesecake. It was delicious! Great customer service! I can't wait to go back and try more goodies! Support local businesses!
I stopped in tonight to try some cupcakes. I purchased a dozen and letâs just say I didnât want to share after my first bite. It was amazing, the shop is set up wonderful and such nice people behind the counter. I will be recommending to all of my friends and family. You all rock!!!!
Great desserts! Especially the chocolate cake & chocolate pie. Pastries are delicious đ
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Brownie, Pineapple Upside Down, Lemon Bars, Birthday Cake, Cupcake, Cheesecake, Wedding Cake, Strawberry Champagne Cake, Lemon Pound Loaf, Mom's Birthday Cake, Cheesecake with Strawberries
Restaurantji Recommends
I ordered a cake for a baby shower and it was beautifully done and was moist and just a great cake!! I will definitely be ordering again!
Very helpful and reliable! Made us a cake last minute when our other baker canceled. Weâve ordered about five times and so delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I bought the white chocolate raspberry cake and the triple chocolate cupcake. The were both delicious. I will definitely be back to try more delicious cakes.
I was in town to volunteer and wanted to pick up some treats that would hold up while I was volunteering and the recommended selections did hold up well!
Service was great. I'd say the chocolate chip cookie and brownie were the best of my purchases. The snicker doodle and peanut butter bar seemed a little ... Grainy maybe? I think I wanted just a bit more flavor.
I definitely want to go back and try a few more items!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Horrible. Unprofessional. Completely unreliable. I filled out a cake request form weeks in advance of my twins' birthday for two simple small round cakes. They emailed me back a day or two later with a detailed form to fill out and send back, which I did, along with some photos, and they said they'd get back to me shortly with a quote. Then nothing for TWO WEEKS!! I had to email THEM twice to follow up and ask about the status of my request. They replied and said they were still working on it. After two weeks of this, I thought they must be putting together a design to show me, a 3D model image or *something*, because what else could take that long? My request wasn't involved or complex at all. Just two kids cakes. Finally, I get a text out of nowhere, a few DAYS before their birthday with the most basic run-on text description and a ridiculous price. They'll never get our business, and we're telling family and friends to avoid them also. I don't want someone else to go through this and possibly be screwed by this stupid bakery for their special event. I went with another bakery and the cakes were less than $40 each.
Here is the text from them:
Good evening Heather this is Cake me away bakery reaching out with pricing for this weekends inquiry. for the harry potter/ pusheen cake we can do a 8" 2 layer cake iced in a dark blue with stars and an edible image of harry potter cat on top and pumpkin and ghosts on the side. The cost for this cake would be between $110-125 depending on the final design. For the minecraft cake we can for a 8" 2 layer square cake iced in pink and have a fondant face like the photo sent and the price would be between $110-125. the next steps would be finalizing the details and paying a deposit of half to confirm and place the order. Please let us know if you have any questions.
I replied "It's been two weeks."
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Loading...