Little Italy Pizza

12268 NC-55, Alliance
(252) 745-5023

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Antoinette Squires - Bryant

First of all I'm a long time native of pamplico county and this place has the best pizza well I happen to call and the lady that answered the phone I could barely understand her and then when I asked her long story short 2 employees 1 manager and still didn't get what I ordered this is what happens when children run a restaurant

Joe Consentino

A nice quiet quaint restaurant. Service was great. Food was very good. Staff were very friendly. Definitely would recommend and I will definitely be eating there again

Sarah Rose

Love eating here whether we order to go or eat in. We've had two birthday parties here and everyone was wonderful, food and drinks were served on time and we had a great experience. Children love playing putt-putt as well.

Lisa Rozier

I wish I could tell you about the food, but we didn't get that far, we walked in at 7:30 and they called us to the counter and the first we are told is that they close at 8:00, so we maybe have time to eat, so needless to say we left did not feel very welcome , maybe they don't need the business .

John Tazioli

The meatlovers pizza had chunks of sliced smoked ham. The smoked ham flavor overpowered the whole pizza. Cotto ham and prosciutto are the traditional hams used, certainly not smoked. The crust was pretty good but a little soggy from oil saturation. My party was pretty much ignored on entry until one of us spoke up. Wait staff never checked on our table, but seating is pretty good and typical of a pizza joint. Members in our party had some gut unrest later in the evening but that condition is circumstantial to having the pizza.

William Deck

Above average for Pamlico county!

Theresa Holley Dail

Little Italy has been our favorite place to get Italian pizza, subs, and other Italian dishes since the 1990’s. My personal favorite is the chicken parmigiana.

Kelci Leonard

What an awesome hidden gem!!! We decided to drive around and explore random roads while on vacation about 40mim from here and wound up being hungry. Found this place and what a surprise we had when we got our food! The calzones and strombolis are ginormous and delicious!!! The spaghetti is fantastic! And the personal pizza may as well be marketed as a regular pizza because it was definitely not personal size. Needless to say, we have dinner for the night now and won’t need to worry about that back at the cabin we’re staying at. We didn’t have a chance to try out the putt putt course, but we look forward to going back one day and playing. The staff was ridiculously nice and helpful as well. A+++ place ⭐️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Christine Mandel

Good did, friendly staff. It's always a pleasure to eat there.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Baked Manicotti

Rhonda Stolins

Love their food. Large portions, great quality!! Friendly service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza Subs

Edwin Roman

Food is delicious and the service is Friendly 100% recommend....Pizza is great!

Wheelchair accessibility: Yes there is access for wheelchair

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Meat Lovers Pizza

Muriel Raker

This place was absolutely the best! It was our first time going there, but it won't be our last! The pizza was amazing, as was the baked manicotti and their bread... Oh my goodness. The service was great!! Jaiden was extremely friendly and helpful. ALSO, let me just say Jaidens' recommendations for their deserts were spot on. The best homemade carrot cake and homemade cheese cake ever!!!
So, if you are ever in the Alliance, NC area, do yourself a favor and stop in for a meal! You won't be disappointed ??? Everything is homemade, sauces, dough, bread, etc.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza

Michael Seigel

Overall, we really liked the place. The meat lovers pizza was top notch. Their "small" is what we've come to expect at most places as a large. The wings were good, not breaded. The small salad was enough for two. The carrot cake was just incredible. Hands down the best carrot cake we've had since we came here. The (we believe) owner came to check on us. We were very happy
Suggestions:
Offer more than one sauce for the wings, or failing that, offer it on the side. Some people may find it too hot.
Offer blue cheese for the wings and salads.
Offer celery/carrot sticks with the wings.

Worth the drive from James City.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Richard Linck sr

Worst lasagna I ever ate in my entire life, was made slammed full with pepperoni, they must have run out of chop meat

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 4

Linda Chandler

My 1st take out visit in years. Was a great choice!! I got a large meatball sub with cheese. It was delicious and it was gigantic. Came with chips and also got a small garden salad that was gigantic and delicious. And it came with a whole toasted sliced sub roll and plenty of dressing. Will be able to make several meals from this visit..My order was plenty to feed two people and the price was only $17.50..Give them 15-20 minutes and they will hook you up. Will definitely be back but will get a small sub next time..

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Super Subs

Loading...