Margherita Pizza Company

I ordered a pizza with sausage and fire-roasted onions and peppers, but when the pizza arrived, it looked like a regular Margherita pizza. The waitress said that the toppings were just crumbled really small, but I had trouble seeing or tasting them. That was really disappointing for a $19 pizza. If you just want a plain Margherita pizza though, then this isn’t a bad spot. I bet you could order any pizza off the menu and still get one.

Best Pizza in North Carolina hands down 🍷🍕❤️🍺🇮🇹

We were on vacation looking for great pizza with atmosphere & we found it! It’s going on our vacation list of favorite restaurants! My husband the “ Chef” of the family gave it a huge thumbs up

Cesar salad, cheese calzone, pepperoni pizza, and Margherita pizza—all amazing! Very friendly staff too.

Top contender for best pizza in the nation.

Food and Pizza just like back home.

Our waiter was so silly and kind! He made our dining experience and the atmosphere so great even when I drunkenly roasted the pizza comparing it to traditional NY pizza. This is a 5-star review and also an apology to our waiter!

“Sorry about the peppas!”

This is a really great place for pizza. There's wide variety of personal pizza's and you can't go wrong with any of them. The flavors combinations in the pizzas are fantastic, especially the vodka sauce with sausage pizza. Wine selection was good and a good variety of beer to include local beers.

Staff is fast, efficient and genuinely good friendly people.

Highly recommend for great food and great atmosphere

We did take out. My wife loves the Decor. My family all thought the pizza was good. Except for myself and my father, we felt the dough was not cooked quite enough, and the anchovy pizza was absent the anchovies.. there was a sprinkle of anchovy on the pie. So it's a mixed bag on this review some liked the pie very much and 2 of us were disappointed. I would try the pizza again but next time we plan to visit and eat at the restaurant and we'll see what happens next time and we'll shoot for the 5 stars 😎

Great option for a wood fired pizza!

The staff are great, very attentive and the food comes out quick from the wood fire oven. Very happy that they have opened up in town.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: San Gennaro Pizza, Queen Margherita Pizza

Absolutely love Margherita Pizza! You will not go wrong with any menu choice! Great staff and atmosphere! One of the best restaurants in Surf City and the Topsail area!

Get here right at 5 before the crowds but so delicious.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Flew in from NY, and stumbled in not thinking I would be indulging in NY PIZZA! WOW the homemade sauce will not disappoint your tastebuds! Very nice family atmosphere, put this on your must try list!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Queen Margherita Pizza, Garlic Bread

We ordered takeout while on vacation. The food was great and the staff were very friendly.
Our order was ready within 15 minutes of calling.

It may seem pricey, but it is worth it for the quality of ingredients you are getting. I also thought the serving size of each pizza was appropriate for the price we paid.

If you are in the mood for some pizza I recommend giving them a call!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: To N Y Pepperoni Pizza, Garlic Bread