Holy Cow Creamery

I love the unique flavor offerings. There was a crowd and the tasting/ordering/pickup was disorderly. We plan on visiting again.

Really good ice cream.

Nice friendly local place

Holy Cow this is the best Ice Cream ever!!! The owner and his staff are fantastic and can't wait until coming here again next year!

Delicious ice cream, clean establishment and friendly staff.

A nice little place like you remember, with a list of five or six vegan ice creams and sorbets. I enjoyed Monkey Business, with chocolate and peanut butter, very much.

Such a cute little place! They had just the right amount of flavors without it being too overwhelming to make a decision. I like that they let you sample some flavors before committing to one. West Third Coffee was delicious! I would definitely compare it to a local place to us back home in Maryland, felt like home away from home. We will definitely be back.

This is what I call ice cream. Real creamy, homemade ice cream. They only have waffle cones - I respect it. The teenage employees were friendly. Love the benches outside. I’m not even bad about the price. This place is awesome.

This place is so unique. If you’re from out of town and looking for something more unique than the standard ice cream shop back home, come here!
As soon as we walked in, the young ladies running the front counter were super helpful and gave us a bunch of samples to try because there are so many unique flavors.
They told us we came at a great time of year(late September) because the main summer months especially around the holidays, the line is out the door because they get so many customers.
We got a “first flight” 6 full size scoops of different flavors, bourbon fig, bell Helene, Irish crunch, strawberry cactus, holycow, and death by chocolate. Strawberry cactus and bourbon fig were our favorites but they were all so good. I wish I had taken a picture for the review but I forgot because I was so busy enjoying the experience and ice cream

WOW‼️😋🤩😋 More, PLEASE ‼️😋 Yummy delicious! Lots of cool and interesting flavors and mixes! I am NOT a pumkin spice kinda gal. But, if they have it, try the pumpkin cheesecake ice cream!! You will not be sorry! It's delicious!! 😋 So are the strawberry cactus and cookie monster! 😎 The luminous cheesecake ice cream is creamy and flavorful, with big chunks of cheesecake!! 😋 If the line is out the door, wait!! It moves fast and it's worth the wait. Holy Cow, keep doing what you're doing!! We will be back again!!

Best ice cream ive ever taisted.....the cookie monster was to die for!!!!

Great selection of flavors. My favorite - caramel apple!!! Soooo good and super creamy. It was our very first stop this trip because I couldn’t wait another day 😋🍦

Local, friendly, clean and tasty ice cream that is busting with flavor!

THE best homemade ice cream. We just found it and we'll be coming back again and again

Our group has been in OBX two days and so far we have only visited Holy Cow TWICE, so our experience may be limited.

The ice cream flavors are premium plus. Bourbon Fig? Come on man I don’t stand a chance here. I’m a big fan of ice cream. I’m just in love with this ice cream. This is approaching modern art.

Unique ingredients and excellent professional craftsmanship make these flavors so unique you feel sad you don’t live here.

The parking lot is small so I think in high season it would be challenging, but in September it was pretty easy. The staff was the same two young men both times we visited. Both times they were great. They were happy to let us sample different flavors and find the one we wanted. Answer: all of them.