New York Deli II

A, 8805, 111 Central Park Ave, Pinehurst
(910) 295-2264

Recent Reviews

Catherine Wall

The sub sandwich is good and very polite

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ryan Gault

This place is wonderful!! Everything is made fresh the meat are all boars head. The cheese is all boars head. You can’t beat a better sandwich. I suggest this place to anybody.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bagel with Butter, Roast Beef, Bagel with Cream Cheese, Fresh Mozzarella, Bagel with Lox, Pickle Spear, Italian Chicken Special, Sausage, Egg & Cheese, Plaza Pastrami, Roll, Eggs with Cheese, White or Whole Wheat

Keith Harris

The pastrami sandwich was the top 3 of all time!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Pam T.

Great service. Good chicken salad sandwich. I didn't get a picture because I ate it too fast

Richrd G.

The place stinks. I don't know why they call themselves a New York deli, and certainly not.

Rick M.

Given up on this guy the owner. Has the personality of a " Use your imagination ".The woman who runs the cash register has been with this guy for a long time and she tries. If you ask me she realizes her boss is a piece of work. I'll spend my money elsewhere.

Teresa H.

Hubs and I stopped in for lunch. There is a rather large sandwich menu, most of which seem to be hot. I found that a little unusual, but decided on a basic turkey with cheese. The turkey was tasteless and the cheese smelled off. I didn't eat much of it. Save your money, go to Circle K and get something out of their refrigerated section. You'll thank me. The ambience consists of some battered outdoor furniture with a TV blaring Fox News at everyone.

April Matise

I saw all the bad reviews so I wanted to say we loved this place! The food was great and the black and white cookies were amazing! Staff was nice also. We are gonna make make this a regular stop!

Andy Fidandis

They are always out of whatever you try to order. Hard to spend $$ here. After multiple attempts I'm done.Pinehurst sure could use a real NY style deli and a bagel shop like Noahs, Manhattans or Einsteins. This ain't it.

D. G.

Everything said below and less. Dirty, noisy place. Got a chicken parm sandwich today . You could have put the chicken on half of the roll it was served on, and no sauce.3.00 for a bottle drink ridiculous. Waste of money, unfriendly people, never again.Don't know how this place stays in business . Plenty of other better choices in adjacent shoppers centers.

Barbara T.

Second time in the store and disappointed both times. Ordered a Taylor Ham sandwich 'pork roll'. They gave me one slice of pork roll. I called them and was told that is what their sandwich is, one slice. No thanks NY deli I will take my business elsewhere!

Sally Alexander

We just moved here aside from the poor reviews we thought we would take a chance anyway what a disappointment as soon as we walked in we were greeted by a very unfriendly gentleman who took are order and then to top things off the woman who cashed us out also was extremely unfriendly we were told to seat ourselves when are sandwiches arrived she never smiled and said hope you enjoy needless to say we will not be returning

Brandon Sanderson

Delicious! Half the family is from NYC and this little deli is a favorite. They have limited hours and do things their own way which I respect. It takes years of work to get there. It's hard to find a good rueben sandwich around here. Highly recommended.

Deborah Long

Ordered two sandwiches---a Reuben and a Philly cheesesteak. The Reuben was very good; the Philly cheesesteak was not. Although it had quite a bit of roast beef, the cheese was a cold lump, the peppers and onions were more of a spread, and the entire sandwich was cold. Coupled with their blaring TV, it was not a good experience.

Jeff Biehl

Not a New York style deli at all!I grew up 20 miles Northwest of Philadelphia I think I know what a good Hoagie or Sub Is.This was nowhere near the northeastern Pennsylvania and New York standards.

Load More