Pizza Cafe

111 G Olmsted Blvd G, Pinehurst
(910) 235-0201

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Rick Olmeda

We ordered pan pizza. Baked cheese sticks and a manhattan calzone and everything was delicious. Some of the best Pan Pizza in NC. Service was terrific and everything tasted fresh. Will definitely be returning.

Michael Evans

Always delicious and staff are very nice!

Scott Kilpatrick

I ordered food to carry out. The food was terrible. Terrible is actually being nice. If this is good food in NC, I will stay in MD. On a side note, the waitress was hot and smiled at me. She is the only reason this place gets two stars.

Taran Cobb

We had pizza, salad, and pasta - all were great! Will return

Jeremy Evans

Love this place

Wade Mauney

Went there for a family get-together (nine of us). Food was great and the waitress was very nice. We’ll be back. 🍕

Scott Hodges

Dad and 3 teenagers stopped in for the buffet dinner. Total was $45 and it was worth every penny! The place was clean; salad and pizza buffet were fresh; plenty of pizzas were brought out and there was a lot of variety. Our waitress (Jacqueline) was awesome! Very friendly, helpful and attentive. Eat dinner here, you will not regret it!

Jennifer L Carlson

Ordered pizzas ? to feed lots of kiddos after our original plans were canceled. James got the pizzas made in a short window of time and even carried them out for me!
I like this place way better than any of the chain pizzas shops. 4.5 ? food, not my favorite but very good! #Pinehurst #localeats #localjenn

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

elizabeth harry

Excellent pizza and our waitress, Leaf, is always on top of things, no matter how busy it is!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

David A. McDaniel Electrical Contractor, Inc. (David)

James and his staff are always friendly and their buffet is great. Great pizza and the salad bar is always fresh.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Salad and Cheese Sticks, Double Pepperoni Pizza

Chadwick Rouse

We go there on Thursday night and get buffets on my daughter's dance break and the buffet bar and the salad bar have never inches so always stocked up. Good atmosphere good customer service and we will continue to eat there on Thursday night and it's only under $40 for three of us.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza Buffet & Salad Bar, Wings, Pepperoni and Bacon Pizza, One Large Specialty or One Pizza Three Toppings, Spaghetti with Meatballs or Meatsauce, Two Topping Pizza, Three Items Pizza, Baked Cheese Sticks, Salad and Cheese Sticks, Double Pepperoni Pizza

Michael Baddour

We love coming here. Works for a dynamic group of people when it comes to choices. James and his staff are great and the food is as expected. Love supporting small local businesses.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza Buffet & Salad Bar, Pepperoni and Bacon Pizza, Baked Cheese Sticks, Double Pepperoni Pizza

Cory Howard

We found this restaurant recently while on a quest for local places to eat. Instantly in love. From entry to exit, the experience was top notch. The pizza was exactly what we crave regularly without leaving us feeling heavy from unnecessary extra dough. The service was top tier and friendly. Pricing was appropriate.

My son said it best when we were finished... this place was heaven.

This will assuredly be our new pizza spot.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tonya Acorn

Very good food and service

Vegetarian options: Great salad bar

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Double Pepperoni Pizza

Thomas Oku

The staff is super friendly. The food is really mediocre. I'm not sure Id comeback here. The 6.99 salad bar togo was better than the pizza in my opinion. The pizza was exactly what you'd expect for a buffet style pizza. The Pepperoni is thick, which I'm not a huge fan of. The sauce is relatively cheap. It's just exactly what you'd expect. Not bad, but not great.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 5

Loading...