Casa Garcia Mexican Restaurant

474 US-64, Plymouth
(252) 791-1229

Recent Reviews

Chris J

Fabulous local Mexican on a Sunday night on the way home. Fast, authentic. They do charge for any extras, like extra lime or some house hot sauce (very good), but for the good meal better that was fine. Very well priced all around otherwise.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Taylor Knieper

The food is great and reasonably priced, the waiters and waitresses are super friendly, their alcohol drinks are mixed the way you like. Overall, this is THE BEST Mexican restaurant your going to find in or around Plymouth. Whether you live in Plymouth or just passing through, it's worth the stop and it won't break you. The amount of food you get for the price you pay is better than getting an upgraded combo meal from McDonald's. (Actually worth the money) GO HERE RELIGIOUSLY AND WONT STOP UNLESS THEY SHUT DOWN

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fajita Taco Salad with Steak and Rice, Fried Ice Cream, One Burrito and One, Quesadilla, Taco Salad, Steak and Shrimp, Enchiladas, Beans and Cheese, One Enchilada Rice and Beans, Burrito, Chimichanga

White Knight

Waitress was extremely inattentive, didn't even bring us the check,and when we went to get our check so gave us the wrong one ,was alot more money ,we had to point out what we ate..terrible

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 1

Eric Voliva

Parking: 50/60

Recommended dishes: Fajita Taco Salad with Steak and Rice, Chicken Fajitas, Quesadilla, Fajita Burrito, Taco Salad, Fries, Steak and Shrimp, Enchiladas, Shrimp Taco Salad, Beans and Cheese

Bobby Messano

There are a few very bad reviews for this restaurant. I was driving by and stopped. My Enchilada Verdes were fantastic. Do not believe the bad ones. This is real, and it ROCKED.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Enchiladas

Marion Waters

Always delicious

Doug Swain

Great food and great service. All their food is good and they take pride in keeping it authentic Mexican.As always a great place to have a family get together for Christmas & New Years

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ivan Faure

Good experience.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Brock Harris

Great place to eat with good service.Kid-friendliness: High chairs available and large long tables to fit large families.

Recommended dishes: Fried Ice Cream, Chicken Fajitas, Steak and Shrimp

Matt Long

Asked for the chicken breast and they served my wife a piece of cardboard instead. 2 Stars because my meal was actually worthwhile.

amber lane

The food was delicious, I was very surprised. But over all it was great.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Fajitas, Quesadilla, Fries

Sheldon Groner

It's a great place to eat.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Chicken Fajitas

Ryan Moore

Good drink, wings were ok. Bartender named Christina was very Snappy sarcastic and with a nice nasty attitude. They completely ignored us at the end because they were trying to rush us out so they can close down when they technically didn't close until a whole hour

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 1

Jim Turner

My friend, who is a film producer, and myself, attempted to try this restaurant for the first time this evening. We arrived 8-8:15pm, past the dinner and rush hour. We ordered the Nachos Supreme with Chicken instead of Beef and no Sour Cream. I questioned whether toppings would be distributed equally throughout the dish as sometimes the center and lower sections are dry and lack any ingredients. I was asked how I would like the nachos prepared and I replied to distribute the toppings equally throughout and no Sour Cream. I was told the kitchen staff may not like it but they would be told. When our nachos arrived, it was a plate of tostadas with ground beef on the bottom, sprinkled with shredded lettuce, drizzled with melted cheese, one slice of tomato halved, and topped with Sour Cream. We brought this to the attention of the server who begrudgingly returned it to the kitchen. When a second dish was brought to our table it contained Chicken without Beef, and scantly shredded lettuce, grizzled with queso, topped only with one slice of tomato halved. I questioned if this was a Navi Supreme being devoid of any flavorful toppings. I was told I asked only for Chicken, no beans or other toppings. But I had initially been asked how I wanted the nachos prepared and answered saying I wanted all the toppings distributed throughout the dish. I also asked about getting diced tomatoes rather than one slice halved. After all, it was apparent my friend and I were going to share the dish. They even brought extra plates. I told the server I did not mind paying extra to have the dish prepared differently but what was before us was not like any Nacho Supreme I had ever seen. The server made a comment to the effect of what should I expect for $8. It was at this point I asked to speak with the manager. The server advised he is the owner and wondered where I had seen Nacho Supremes different from this. I explained, every other Mexican restaurant where I have ever eaten and I frequent Mexican restaurants in Greenville and Washington. This incensed the little man and he became rude and hostile. Without appropriate cause he demanded, “get out of my restaurant!” This was a first for me, having never seen such a ridiculous excuse for a Nacho Supreme AND being told to get out because the food was not what I ordered. The food, the service, and the attitude here are the worst I have ever encountered.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Andrew Buttery

Very good food and service.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Load More

Casa Garcia Mexican Restaurant

474 US-64, Plymouth, NC 27962
(252) 791-1229