We noticed the truck advertisement on our way home and popped in to discover the best hidden gem Selma has to offer! The staff was super friendly and knowledgeable. They let us try flavors we were interested in and we had a hard time choosing but the Cookies and Cream was the best we’ve ever had. 10/10 Recommend!
B L
First time visiting the Old Fashioned Ice Cream. The server, Isaac, is friendly and does an excellent job. The ice cream was outstanding as well as the milk shakes. We will be back the next time we are in the area.
G Lipari
Absolutely fantastic, super premium, smooth to die for especially the Bannna creme ... well worth the price , which btw is very reasonable
kathy reardon
Love this cute little shop! The ice cream was delicious! You can get 4 flavors for $10!
Sam P
No ingredients listed anywhere in the store other than flavors and not available upon request..huge issue for allergens “The law requires the formula and ingredients to be documented and available for inspection, and the final product must be labeled or ingredient information provided if requested.” Worker could not confirm or deny if the ice cream had a certain ingredient and was super confused by a simple question.. the business owner should know a report to NCDA&CS Food & Drug Protection Division was made.
Lastnamesmith2
A hidden gem.. My husband and I shared a banana split. Plain chocolate is our favorite..
FRED BURGESS
Great experience, large variety and very friendly staff.
C D
Many many many different choices. Very good ice cream
Ron K
I finally tried this cute little shop after passing by so many times! Their icecream is house made with over 21 flavors! The topping are plenty and FREE-love that concept. It’s located on Raiford St. in downtown Selma amongst soooo many other cute shops. Will def return!
Amanda Sessom
Always friendly and has the best ice cream! Pistachio is one of my favorites 😍 🍨
We noticed the truck advertisement on our way home and popped in to discover the best hidden gem Selma has to offer! The staff was super friendly and knowledgeable. They let us try flavors we were interested in and we had a hard time choosing but the Cookies and Cream was the best we’ve ever had. 10/10 Recommend!
First time visiting the Old Fashioned Ice Cream. The server, Isaac, is friendly and does an excellent job. The ice cream was outstanding as well as the milk shakes. We will be back the next time we are in the area.
Absolutely fantastic, super premium, smooth to die for especially the Bannna creme ... well worth the price , which btw is very reasonable
Love this cute little shop! The ice cream was delicious! You can get 4 flavors for $10!
No ingredients listed anywhere in the store other than flavors and not available upon request..huge issue for allergens “The law requires the formula and ingredients to be documented and available for inspection, and the final product must be labeled or ingredient information provided if requested.” Worker could not confirm or deny if the ice cream had a certain ingredient and was super confused by a simple question.. the business owner should know a report to NCDA&CS Food & Drug Protection Division was made.
A hidden gem.. My husband and I shared a banana split. Plain chocolate is our favorite..
Great experience, large variety and very friendly staff.
Many many many different choices. Very good ice cream
I finally tried this cute little shop after passing by so many times! Their icecream is house made with over 21 flavors! The topping are plenty and FREE-love that concept. It’s located on Raiford St. in downtown Selma amongst soooo many other cute shops. Will def return!
Always friendly and has the best ice cream! Pistachio is one of my favorites 😍 🍨
Restaurantji Recommends
Could possibly be the best Ice Cream Place Ever!!!
Best place to get 🍨 ice cream. Homemade, amazing staff and even though they are busy at times they treat customers amazingly.
The ice cream was delicious but it has too many nuts. It's hard enjoying the ice cream especially for the kids 😊
The perfect Sunday evening treat! The staff is super friendly and cheerful! Creamy and delicious! So many flavors!
The ice cream here is amazing! So many flavors to chose from and the staff was super friendly. We will be coming back.
Loading...