Customer service is not their strong suit. My son and I walked in and sat at the bar, there was a mother and her child sitting there waiting for service also. While one employee did greet us both continued to serve the walk in line and never take our order. After 15 people who came in after us had been served, I left. 10 out of 10 would not recommend.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
B P
Great ice cream! However, an actual 20 a minute wait for 2 scoops after ordering and paying is something I've never experienced in any ice cream shop.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 2
Erica Foote
I love this little ice cream shop everyone who works there is super great. The owner makes a point to say hi to me and my service dog whenever we come in. super great about being accommodating when they can. And the ice cream is just the greatest I try to go and get a pint of it it might be a half pint I'm not sure but I try to go get a big thing for the house when I can.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bessie Griffin
The ice is great! Love the variety, the staff is always patient and friendly. Enjoyed the new ice cream parlor look. Look forward to trying more flavors!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Yamika Bennett
Excellent ice cream shop and more. The owner was very friendly and everything we purchased was wonderful. Flavors were spot on and they offer adult flavors too(champagne and liquor, etc). I can't wait to visit again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Danielle
Tried Old Fashioned Ice Cream a few days ago and I wish I knew about this place sooner! The ice cream is so good and taste very fresh. They offer many flavors and allow you to sample! Customer service was great and I'm looking forward to coming back for more ????
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nathanael Bennett
My wife and I heard about this place and decided to give it a try. We love ice cream especially homemade so this was right up our alley. The server was super patient and kind allowing us to sample a lot of flavors (they have about 40)! Portion size for the money is very good!The ice cream itself is cold and delicious! I really enjoyed the variety of flavors they have and look forward to coming back! This spot is definitely worth the try if you are looking for delicious homemade ice cream in surrounding Johnston County area.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Google user
Tried Old Fashioned Ice Cream a few days ago and I wish I knew about this place sooner! The ice cream is so good and taste very fresh. They offer many flavors and allow you to sample! Customer service was great and I'm looking forward to coming back for more ???\\u200d?
Elaina B.
So many flavors it was hard to choose where to start. We got a scoop of the chocolate brownie and mint chocolate chip ice cream and enjoyed the treat. The music selection was comforting throw backs and set a nice ambiance for a bright and friendly ice cream shop. Would recommend a visit when in Selma!
Best ice cream! Super friendly staff and very fair price! A huge variety of flavors too, and it’s all fresh!
Reema B.
So many choices! I sampled a couple and got the small which is a lot of ice cream. Highly recommend the cookies n brownies which has huge pieces of brownies! Hope to come again
Gregory O.
Enjoyed delicious homemade ice cream in a house made waffle cone. Lots of flavors to choose from. Generous servings and good pricing. Service was fast. Nice seating options with table games.
Patrick K.
A great locally owned business with an owner who likes to experiment with a wide variety of flavors. You'll find a flavor for everyone here.
Michael G.
Definitely good ol' fashion ice cream. Staff was friendly and welcoming. Lots of flavors. Great value for your money. Some of the best waffle cones I've had around here. I would say I wish the ice cream was a bit firmer. You get such a healthy serving it melts before you can eat and t all. also have some good package deals listed.
Customer service is not their strong suit. My son and I walked in and sat at the bar, there was a mother and her child sitting there waiting for service also. While one employee did greet us both continued to serve the walk in line and never take our order. After 15 people who came in after us had been served, I left. 10 out of 10 would not recommend.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
Great ice cream! However, an actual 20 a minute wait for 2 scoops after ordering and paying is something I've never experienced in any ice cream shop.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 2
I love this little ice cream shop everyone who works there is super great. The owner makes a point to say hi to me and my service dog whenever we come in. super great about being accommodating when they can. And the ice cream is just the greatest I try to go and get a pint of it it might be a half pint I'm not sure but I try to go get a big thing for the house when I can.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The ice is great! Love the variety, the staff is always patient and friendly. Enjoyed the new ice cream parlor look. Look forward to trying more flavors!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent ice cream shop and more. The owner was very friendly and everything we purchased was wonderful. Flavors were spot on and they offer adult flavors too(champagne and liquor, etc). I can't wait to visit again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tried Old Fashioned Ice Cream a few days ago and I wish I knew about this place sooner! The ice cream is so good and taste very fresh. They offer many flavors and allow you to sample! Customer service was great and I'm looking forward to coming back for more ????
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My wife and I heard about this place and decided to give it a try. We love ice cream especially homemade so this was right up our alley. The server was super patient and kind allowing us to sample a lot of flavors (they have about 40)! Portion size for the money is very good!The ice cream itself is cold and delicious! I really enjoyed the variety of flavors they have and look forward to coming back! This spot is definitely worth the try if you are looking for delicious homemade ice cream in surrounding Johnston County area.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tried Old Fashioned Ice Cream a few days ago and I wish I knew about this place sooner! The ice cream is so good and taste very fresh. They offer many flavors and allow you to sample! Customer service was great and I'm looking forward to coming back for more ???\\u200d?
So many flavors it was hard to choose where to start. We got a scoop of the chocolate brownie and mint chocolate chip ice cream and enjoyed the treat. The music selection was comforting throw backs and set a nice ambiance for a bright and friendly ice cream shop. Would recommend a visit when in Selma!
This is the best homemade ice cream !!
Restaurantji Recommends
Best ice cream! Super friendly staff and very fair price! A huge variety of flavors too, and it’s all fresh!
So many choices! I sampled a couple and got the small which is a lot of ice cream. Highly recommend the cookies n brownies which has huge pieces of brownies! Hope to come again
Enjoyed delicious homemade ice cream in a house made waffle cone. Lots of flavors to choose from. Generous servings and good pricing. Service was fast. Nice seating options with table games.
A great locally owned business with an owner who likes to experiment with a wide variety of flavors. You'll find a flavor for everyone here.
Definitely good ol' fashion ice cream. Staff was friendly and welcoming. Lots of flavors. Great value for your money. Some of the best waffle cones I've had around here. I would say I wish the ice cream was a bit firmer. You get such a healthy serving it melts before you can eat and t all. also have some good package deals listed.