Ordered wings for my child who got severely sick after eating them. I went and cut open the leftover wings once he began to throw up and they were still pink on the inside. My husband called to inform them of what happened. DIDNT ASK FOR ANYTHING. Wasnt planning on writing a bad review We simply didnt want it to happen to another customer. The woman he spoke to responded with: "Well did you take him to the doctor?" "How do you know it was food poisoning?" "This has NEVER happened before". My child ate undercooked pink chicken and was sick for 12 hours then fine. Its not rocket science. Instead of being appreciative that we called or pretending to value our buisness/feedback..we were met with defensive questions. Mistakes happen. I will not spend money here anymore because of the way it was handled.
Food: 1
Service: 1
Jessica B
Yuck. Ordered a bbq chicken pizza with extra cheese. No extra cheese and it was cold and doughy in the middle. The Italian sandwich was all bread. Very disappointed. Ended up tossing the food. First and last time here. Would call to speak to management but some of the comments from the owner kinda rubbed me the wrong way. I am bummed because we are all about supporting the locals. Will continue to patronize other locations.
Food: 1
Megan
Wish I could give them a 0. Food quality is inconsistent.
Austin Jankowiak
Ordered a large pizza w/ pepperoni, roasted red peppers, and half olives.
Toppings were scattered by someone who seemingly soon needs an eye exam in order to get their driver’s license re-issued. Not even close to being well-proportioned. On top of this — peppers were not “roasted” — the red peppers were very obviously jarred. Don’t advertise as roasted if you’re too lazy to do it yourself.
Sauce was very good, surprisingly. However, the pizza was severely undercooked & the crust was like chewing gum. NOT a trademark of New York Pizza, which should be overdone if anything. Cheese on the pizza was barely melted/not molded — tell-tale sign that it is under-cooked.
Wings were also anemic — akin to Tyson frozen wings. For $1.50 a wing, would hope for higher quality.
Embarrassing for whoever owns this place to call this “New York Pizza”. Honestly, would have been better off going to Dominoes.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Kimberley Scarano Raftery
We just moved to Sneads Ferry from New York, and knew when we made the move that good pizza might only be reserved to visits back.
I found Denoia’s Pizza by accident today and gave it a shot and made my homesick son’s afternoon!!!
The staff were super sweet, the pizza was piping hot with a perfectly crunchy crust and it tasted like HOME!!!
Thank you for making our Sunday!
Von Fraley
I ordered a pepperoni pizza got home it was half cheese half pepperoni, ordered a small turkey sub got home it was ham. Had to check my receipt on line just to make sure I put it in correctly. Which I did. It was my first time ordering from there and when I went to go pick it up there wasn’t even any customers. So I know it wasn’t busy to mess up the order. But also my fault for not checking. After work I was just ready to get home.
Brian Naess
Best pizza in the N. Topsail/Sneads Ferry! The pizza's are huge, and they also have good garlic knots and sandwiches. The canolis are also tasty. They can be busy, but they usually have a big, friendly staff to take care of you.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Large Cheese Pizza, Garlic Bread
michael shields
Best pizza ever,crust was amazing, service were exceptional for take out. Love this place
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Supreme, Large Cheese Pizza
Thomas Burkhardt
Finally finding a real pizza place in NC.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Chris Clarke
Got into town 8/3/24 and got 3 large pizzas that were absolutely dynamite ?
It was a bare Bones pizza place. We did not try their Italian stuff like chicken parmesan. We just stuck to the pizza. Pizza was thin crust New York style. We got it with sausage and mushrooms. Ex It was very good. The downside being a Red Sox fan and this place was decorated for the Yankees. Boo hiss. We also got their salad which was basically a big bowl of iceberg lettuce. A couple pieces of tomato, a couple pieces of cucumber and sprinkled with mozzarella. He was a $7 bowl of lettuce more or less. I'd like to add they had clean bathrooms
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large Cheese Pizza
Bart Lakey
Food was good, we had lasagna, spaghetti w meatballs and meat spaghetti. Side of cheesesticks.
Meals came with mini garlic bread loaves that were good also.
Did not eat in the restaurant but did takeout. Staff was friendly and helpful when picking up our order.
Ordered wings for my child who got severely sick after eating them. I went and cut open the leftover wings once he began to throw up and they were still pink on the inside. My husband called to inform them of what happened. DIDNT ASK FOR ANYTHING. Wasnt planning on writing a bad review We simply didnt want it to happen to another customer. The woman he spoke to responded with: "Well did you take him to the doctor?" "How do you know it was food poisoning?" "This has NEVER happened before". My child ate undercooked pink chicken and was sick for 12 hours then fine. Its not rocket science. Instead of being appreciative that we called or pretending to value our buisness/feedback..we were met with defensive questions. Mistakes happen. I will not spend money here anymore because of the way it was handled.
Food: 1
Service: 1
Yuck. Ordered a bbq chicken pizza with extra cheese. No extra cheese and it was cold and doughy in the middle. The Italian sandwich was all bread. Very disappointed. Ended up tossing the food. First and last time here.
Would call to speak to management but some of the comments from the owner kinda rubbed me the wrong way. I am bummed because we are all about supporting the locals.
Will continue to patronize other locations.
Food: 1
Wish I could give them a 0.
Food quality is inconsistent.
Ordered a large pizza w/ pepperoni, roasted red peppers, and half olives.
Toppings were scattered by someone who seemingly soon needs an eye exam in order to get their driver’s license re-issued. Not even close to being well-proportioned. On top of this — peppers were not “roasted” — the red peppers were very obviously jarred. Don’t advertise as roasted if you’re too lazy to do it yourself.
Sauce was very good, surprisingly. However, the pizza was severely undercooked & the crust was like chewing gum. NOT a trademark of New York Pizza, which should be overdone if anything. Cheese on the pizza was barely melted/not molded — tell-tale sign that it is under-cooked.
Wings were also anemic — akin to Tyson frozen wings. For $1.50 a wing, would hope for higher quality.
Embarrassing for whoever owns this place to call this “New York Pizza”. Honestly, would have been better off going to Dominoes.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
We just moved to Sneads Ferry from New York, and knew when we made the move that good pizza might only be reserved to visits back. I found Denoia’s Pizza by accident today and gave it a shot and made my homesick son’s afternoon!!! The staff were super sweet, the pizza was piping hot with a perfectly crunchy crust and it tasted like HOME!!! Thank you for making our Sunday!
I ordered a pepperoni pizza got home it was half cheese half pepperoni, ordered a small turkey sub got home it was ham. Had to check my receipt on line just to make sure I put it in correctly. Which I did. It was my first time ordering from there and when I went to go pick it up there wasn’t even any customers. So I know it wasn’t busy to mess up the order. But also my fault for not checking. After work I was just ready to get home.
Best pizza in the N. Topsail/Sneads Ferry! The pizza's are huge, and they also have good garlic knots and sandwiches. The canolis are also tasty. They can be busy, but they usually have a big, friendly staff to take care of you.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Large Cheese Pizza, Garlic Bread
Best pizza ever,crust was amazing, service were exceptional for take out. Love this place
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Supreme, Large Cheese Pizza
Finally finding a real pizza place in NC.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Got into town 8/3/24 and got 3 large pizzas that were absolutely dynamite ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large Cheese Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
It was a bare Bones pizza place. We did not try their Italian stuff like chicken parmesan. We just stuck to the pizza. Pizza was thin crust New York style. We got it with sausage and mushrooms. Ex It was very good. The downside being a Red Sox fan and this place was decorated for the Yankees. Boo hiss. We also got their salad which was basically a big bowl of iceberg lettuce. A couple pieces of tomato, a couple pieces of cucumber and sprinkled with mozzarella. He was a $7 bowl of lettuce more or less. I'd like to add they had clean bathrooms
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large Cheese Pizza
Food was good, we had lasagna, spaghetti w meatballs and meat spaghetti. Side of cheesesticks.
Meals came with mini garlic bread loaves that were good also.
Did not eat in the restaurant but did takeout. Staff was friendly and helpful when picking up our order.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Meatballs, Lasagna, Spaghetti & Garlic Bread
Good NYC style pizza. It was a little greasy, but otherwise great
Best pizza in town!!!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian, Garlic Knots, Stromboli, Large Cheese Pizza, Zepolis, Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Great place to eat
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Supreme
Loading...